View Full Version : Who Has a Better 22
gocats88
29 May 2007, 15:38
Stikilda B:Goddard Hugdton L.Fisher
HB:Gram Maguire S.Fisher
C: Montagna Ball Dal santo
HF:Harvey Rievwoldt Hamill
F: Kosi Gerhig Milne
FOLL: M. Clarke Hayes Thompson
Inter: Gilbert Gwilt X. Clarke R. Clarke
Geelong B Tenace Scarlett Makie
HB Milburn Egan Rooke
C Wojak Chapman Enright
HF Ling Nablett Johnson
F Stokes Mooney Ablett
FOLL Ottens Corey Bartel
Inter Prismall Blake Selwood Harley
Lynch takes a mark
29 May 2007, 15:47
Geelong
Stronger Ruck
Harder and fitter midfield
Overall better defence
Versatile and improving Forward line
DapperDon
29 May 2007, 20:11
IMO Saints when fully fit are just better than Geelong.
Better forwards and stronger backline with a consistent midfield, only thing missing is a decent ruckman.
SIR SAINT HOTDOG
30 May 2007, 01:00
Geelong
Stronger Ruck
Harder and fitter midfield
Overall better defence
Versatile and improving Forward line
Rucks the beat us easily.
We have an unbelievable defence if we can just get it out on the park. Hudghton the quiet achiever only conceded 23 goals in 21 games last year the best of any defender. While Maguire is a very reliable CHB as is the improved Fishers, also having great run from Goddard and Gram. Their backline is solid and very consistant.
Midfield is quite even. We have the class and they probably have the fitness while both teams go pretty hard at the ball.
Forwards although they are improving can not match our best 6 when playing. They have the better crumbing forwards/midfielders (chappy and ablett) while we have Nicky,Kosi,Gerhig and Hamil when he plays, which is like never.
Overall pretty even but we definately have the advantage when we are fully fit
SIR SAINT HOTDOG
30 May 2007, 01:03
Stikilda B:Goddard Hugdton L.Fisher
HB:Gram Maguire S.Fisher
C: Montagna Ball Dal santo
HF:Harvey Rievwoldt Hamill
F: Kosi Gerhig Milne
FOLL: M. Clarke Hayes Thompson
Inter: Gilbert Gwilt X. Clarke R. Clarke
Geelong B Tenace Scarlett Makie
HB Milburn Egan Rooke
C Wojak Chapman Enright
HF Ling Nablett Johnson
F Stokes Mooney Ablett
FOLL Ottens Corey Bartel
Inter Prismall Blake Selwood Harley
u left out Baker, makes it look stronger now
Rucks the beat us easily.
We have an unbelievable defence if we can just get it out on the park. Hudghton the quiet achiever only conceded 23 goals in 21 games last year the best of any defender. While Maguire is a very reliable CHB as is the improved Fishers, also having great run from Goddard and Gram. Their backline is solid and very consistant.
Midfield is quite even. We have the class and they probably have the fitness while both teams go pretty hard at the ball.
Forwards although they are improving can not match our best 6 when playing. They have the better crumbing forwards/midfielders (chappy and ablett) while we have Nicky,Kosi,Gerhig and Hamil when he plays, which is like never.
Overall pretty even but we definately have the advantage when we are fully fit
probably agree with that
crosby123
30 May 2007, 12:33
Reckon our backline equals or surpasses yours. Scarlett former AA full-back, unlike Hudghton creates plenty of run, our half-backline is the form group of the competition, Egan is a quality CHB. Mackie, Harley, Milburn can take 3rd/4th talls while still creating plenty of rebound.
Midfield I don't think you have equal depth to us. Bartel, Corey are as good around the clearances as your guys, and with a pair of quality ruckmen supplying them should win out.
You've got the edge with the forwards, though.
M. Clarke, Gilbert, Gwilt, R. Clarke wouldnt even get a look in at Geelong's best 22.
I'd be interested to hear what Geelong players Saints fans dont rate.
SIR SAINT HOTDOG
31 May 2007, 21:58
M. Clarke, Gilbert, Gwilt, R. Clarke wouldnt even get a look in at Geelong's best 22.
I'd be interested to hear what Geelong players Saints fans dont rate.
Gilbert would be the only one in our best 22
crosby123
31 May 2007, 22:02
Gilbert would be the only one in our best 22
Doc Clarke isn't in your best 22?
SIR SAINT HOTDOG
31 May 2007, 22:04
Doc Clarke isn't in your best 22?
Na deff not
crosby123
1 Jun 2007, 15:11
Na deff not
Sorry, but who would you play as ruckman? Kosi? Rix? You need Clarke.