View Full Version : Brownlow- Hird an off chance??
bomberstomake8
3 Jun 2007, 14:44
im not saying i think he will get it or nothing even close to that, but he wouldnt be too far off right now would he? at least 2 BOG performances and a few others were he would get 2 or 1 votes... if judd/bartel/chad cornes get reported and lose form, and hird continues his great form from the last month can he possibly win it? a lot of ifs there but there is always hope... judd would get votes taken from him by kerr and other eagles, hopefully bartel gets reported :D and with a bit of luck he could be close
donsman4eva
3 Jun 2007, 14:46
Well Judd had a shocker, Cornes is playing poorly ATM, and Hird should get a vote from last night. He might be a chance. Fletcher, Lucas and McPhee might take votes off him though. They have also been in the votes for sure. The other thing is that we need to keep winning.
Lance Uppercut
3 Jun 2007, 14:48
very very unlikely.
But can you imagine? :D Has any reigning Brownlow medallist retired before?
donsman4eva
3 Jun 2007, 14:50
Well if he did, he couldnt be accused of having the Brownlow Blues!
Longy413
3 Jun 2007, 14:50
very very unlikely.
But can you imagine? :D Has any reigning Brownlow medallist retired before?
Our very own Graham Moss.
He didn't retire as such, but went home straight after winning the Brownlow.
Darealrath
3 Jun 2007, 14:52
very very unlikely.
But can you imagine? :D Has any reigning Brownlow medallist retired before?
Dunno, but Goodes should have.
Lance Uppercut
3 Jun 2007, 15:03
Our very own Graham Moss.
He didn't retire as such, but went home straight after winning the Brownlow.
talk about going out on top
Well they were saying last night that he is playing better statisically than he ever has. can they convince him to go on again, i reckon highly unlikely but gees if he keeps going on the way he has been who no's maybe finish 3rd 4th in the charlie. average over 20 possie's every game
donsman4eva
3 Jun 2007, 16:17
If he continues, I just hope it is because he thinks we are a chance for a flag, not just because he is playing well
nicho_magic
3 Jun 2007, 16:24
very very unlikely.
But can you imagine? :D Has any reigning Brownlow medallist retired before?
would be just awesome.
wont happen tho.
mark judd in.
Let's not make mention of this 'til Brownlow Night. 'Cos hopefully he'd have 1 more game to go 'til retirement. ;)
Well, in my perspective, he has already BOG's against
Rd 8 Vs Brisbane
Rd 9 Vs Richmond
He would have also got 1-2 votes against
Rd 3 Vs Carlton
Rd 7 Vs Roos
Rd 10 Vs Swans
Any thoughts ?
Longy413
4 Jun 2007, 20:36
He's just as likely not to get a vote against Richmond as he is to get one.
Boris_Bewick
4 Jun 2007, 20:48
Yeah I don't think he'll get one against the Tigers. One at the most
Cornes is playing poorly ATM
You reckon? Was quiet against Sydney but he has been top 5 nearly every other game. Is in great form.
At the moment I think it is a race between Judd, Bartel and Cornes.
I'm doing a Champion Data Brownlow thing, where the top 3 get 3-2-1 respectively, and this is the top 10.
Bartel 14
Fletcher 12
Kerr 12
C.Cornes 12
Judd 9
Black 9
Mitchell 9
Lucas 9
Pavlich 8
H.Shaw 8
B.Harvey 8
West 8
Adcock 8
While obviously not going to be accurate, think it is a pretty good reflection of who is going to be thereabouts this year. For what it's worth, Hird has 3 votes for his BOG against Brisbane.
havoc_planet
4 Jun 2007, 21:02
Yeah I don't think he'll get one against the Tigers. One at the most
You reckon? Was quiet against Sydney but he has been top 5 nearly every other game. Is in great form.
At the moment I think it is a race between Judd, Bartel and Cornes.
I'm doing a Champion Data Brownlow thing, where the top 3 get 3-2-1 respectively, and this is the top 10.
Bartel 14
Fletcher 12
Kerr 12
C.Cornes 12
Judd 9
Black 9
Mitchell 9
Lucas 9
Pavlich 8
H.Shaw 8
B.Harvey 8
West 8
Adcock 8
While obviously not going to be accurate, think it is a pretty good reflection of who is going to be thereabouts this year. For what it's worth, Hird has 3 votes for his BOG against Brisbane.
Is that Fletcher as in DUSTIN lol
donsman4eva
4 Jun 2007, 21:09
Yeah I don't think he'll get one against the Tigers. One at the most
You reckon? Was quiet against Sydney but he has been top 5 nearly every other game. Is in great form.
At the moment I think it is a race between Judd, Bartel and Cornes.
I'm doing a Champion Data Brownlow thing, where the top 3 get 3-2-1 respectively, and this is the top 10.
Bartel 14
Fletcher 12
Kerr 12
C.Cornes 12
Judd 9
Black 9
Mitchell 9
Lucas 9
Pavlich 8
H.Shaw 8
B.Harvey 8
West 8
Adcock 8
While obviously not going to be accurate, think it is a pretty good reflection of who is going to be thereabouts this year. For what it's worth, Hird has 3 votes for his BOG against Brisbane.
I was talking about his form at that stage of the match against Hawthorn. Obviously he is a chance for the b/low. In fact if it isnt an Essendon players, I hope it is between him and Bartel.
Boris_Bewick
4 Jun 2007, 21:12
Is that Fletcher as in DUSTIN lol
Ahh yep, well its definitely not Chad, he's played like three games
I was talking about his form at that stage of the match against Hawthorn. Obviously he is a chance for the b/low. In fact if it isnt an Essendon players, I hope it is between him and Bartel.
My bad Donsman, misinterpreted
Our very own Graham Moss.
He didn't retire as such, but went home straight after winning the Brownlow.
see that's where mossie got it wrong.. i would've hit the town after my win and got blind drunk..
He could very well have polled between 7-9 votes over the last 3 weeks.
Slattery_20
5 Jun 2007, 00:03
How many games has Scottie McLaren umpired him/us?