votes vs eagles [Archive]

bring it on

8 Jun 2007, 23:30

the best match i have seen in ages... bloody awesome

my votes
3.hird (well wat is left to say... LEDGE)
2.hille best game he has played... bloody brilliant
1.fletcher (without him in the backline we would of got flogged... AA backman)

drew_j

8 Jun 2007, 23:32

Same but different

3. Hird
2. Fletch.
1. Hille.

vantheman32

8 Jun 2007, 23:47

3- Hird
2- Lucas
1- Fletch
Honourable mentions
Jobe, Winders, Lloyd, Hille, Pev, Campo, McVeigh
n everyone else im just stoked we won!!!

PS. we have come from behind 3 weeks in a row to win, the 4th quarter assasins! quote that!

S.C[BANKS]

9 Jun 2007, 00:19

3. Hird
2. Winders
1. Lucas

Hom mention - Flect

:thumbsu::thumbsu::thumbsu:

DonMania#5

9 Jun 2007, 00:23

3 - Hird
2 - Fletcher
1 - Lucas

Apologies to Winderlich, Watson and Hille.

silk

9 Jun 2007, 00:26

3. Hird
2. Fletcher
1. Hille

Metions to lucas, winders, and pev.

Special mention to slattery, great game, which will probaly go a little unnoticed.

kainokaino

9 Jun 2007, 00:30

5. Fletcher
4. Hird
3. Lucas
2. Winderlich
1. Hille

i no you only said 3 lol but hey take what you can get off a richmond supporter

great win

RED AND BLACK SOLDIER

9 Jun 2007, 00:39

3 - Hird
2 - Pev
0.5-Hille
0.5-Fletcher

EssendonPride

9 Jun 2007, 00:42

3 players just doesn't do it justice.

Winders played the game of his career.

Too close to split.

But Hirdy, Hille, Pev, Lucas, Fletch, Winderlich all played oustandingly.

When Stant's went down i thought we were done for sure.

Slatts continues to impress.

Bomberland06

9 Jun 2007, 00:43

3, Hird
2. lucas
1. fletcher

mentions too winderlich and pevril

Itsmyshow

9 Jun 2007, 00:45

5 - Hird
4 - Hille
3 - Fletcher
2 - Lucas
1 - Watson

Lance Uppercut

9 Jun 2007, 00:45

very hard, but:

3 - Hird
2 - Peverill
1 - Winderlich

Fletcher, sincerest apologies

grantyc77

9 Jun 2007, 00:46

Im a harsh bomber hater, and i loved the game of Winderlich ( spelling ) His run tonight was awesome, easily i thought BOG, Hird was great as always, I thought Lloyd stood up and was very phyiscal, but big Fletch was great also.

Forgetting big Hilles last half, he was great, beat the best ruckman in the league.

the votes as seen from a cats supporter

3 Winderlich

2 Fletcher

1 Hille

Left out Hird because everyone else is climaxing over his game.

Margim

9 Jun 2007, 00:47

3. Fletch
2. Hird
1. Winders

Scotty Lucas.

EssendonPride

9 Jun 2007, 00:54

Doesn't really fit here but didn't want to start a new thread.

Laycocks couple of goals were great... Very accurate at long range.

I for one didn't want him in the team this week, glad he proved me wrong.

We even had both he AND Hille at a few of the tapouts in the forward 50. That could be very very handy.

I'd love to see him groomed as a key forward, at least until he gets fitness behind him to play more in the ruck.

jules101

9 Jun 2007, 01:05

3. Hird
2. Hille
1. Winder

jnash196

9 Jun 2007, 01:05

3-James (Don't retire)
2-Winderlich (Best game so far)
1-Dustin (Don't retire)

jules101

9 Jun 2007, 01:07

donsman4eva

9 Jun 2007, 01:09

3. Hird
2. Pev
1. Slattery. (surprised on one has mentioned him yet, he absolutely destroyed Kerr.)
Honourables to Fletch, Lucas, Winders and Hille.

bmwofoz

9 Jun 2007, 01:10

3 Flect - When he retires I think will miss him more than a Lloyd or even Hird

2 Hillie - Ruck work was good tonight and his around the ground stuff

1 Windlelich - His speed was great and his carry though the middle was a key to us winning.

Special mention to Hird, Laycock, Ryder, Campo, Watson.

Sam the RAMA fan

9 Jun 2007, 01:13

3--Hird
2--Fletch
1--Pev

Hille,Winderlich,Stanton,Lucas...

donsman4eva

9 Jun 2007, 01:15

3--Hird
2--Fletch
1--Pev

Hille,Winderlich,Stanton,Lucas...
He did nothing, he was off injured. Surely this is a typo.

Crave

9 Jun 2007, 01:16

3 - Fletcher
2 - Hird
1 - Hille

bossco

9 Jun 2007, 01:22

3.Hird
2.Winderlich
1.Hille

Apologies to bolts, sign him up now for 2008!

jhgoat

9 Jun 2007, 01:23

3 hird
2 winderlich
1 slattery

no idea really... cant remember much appart from the final siren going and then hugging 2 blokes i never met before

GmeUP

9 Jun 2007, 01:27

3 - Hird
2 - Hille
1 - Fletcher

kelvin_sheedy

9 Jun 2007, 01:31

5. Fletch
4.5 Lucas
4. Hille
3. Hird
2. Slattery
1. McVeigh, Winderlich, Mal, Pev, Lloyd

Just so damn hard to do the votes....

How good is Dustin Fletcher!

peterss

9 Jun 2007, 01:39

5. Hird
4. Hille
3. Winderlich
2. Fletcher
1. Lucas

phoenix77

9 Jun 2007, 02:00

what a game!!! nothing short of awesome.

And make no mistake, without Fletcher we would have lost that game for sure, yes he is a recognised champ, but i still think he is so under-rated. Like Hird he is a football genius.

High Ryder

9 Jun 2007, 02:09

3 Winderlich
2 Hird
1 Hille

Bomber32

9 Jun 2007, 02:11

3. Hird
2. Winderlich
1. Fletcher

Bombers1234

9 Jun 2007, 02:24

anyone who doesnt give hird 3 votes has gotta be blind
3 - j hird
2 - d hille
1 - s lucas

bmwofoz

9 Jun 2007, 02:28

anyone who doesnt give hird 3 votes has gotta be blind
3 - j hird
2 - d hille
1 - s lucas

Mate Flect was bloody outstanding in the backline tonight, the number of times the WEC sweeped forward and the only thing that saved us was Flect, yes Hird was great in fact in the second half they all were, but Flect was BOG

theone5

9 Jun 2007, 02:32

bmwofoz

9 Jun 2007, 02:35

D.Fletcher was BOG by an ABSOULTE MILE.
It was the little things he did which won us the match.
That spoil on A.Hunter in the last minute from the kick from D.Kerr and his spoil right at the end.
On top of that, he did so many other good things and played the 'sweeping' role perfectly.
In saying this, J.Hird was amazing (once again) and would be leading our B&F quite easily at this stage.

And I can't think of one clanger from Flect, but on at least 3 or 4 occasions Hirds kicks were wasted as in they when to context that WEC's players won or ball went out of bound.

jules101

9 Jun 2007, 02:38

And I can't think of one clanger from Flect, but on at least 3 or 4 occasions Hirds kicks were wasted as in they when to context that WEC's players won or ball went out of bound.

I thought Fletch's kicking in the first half was disapointing

cbreban

9 Jun 2007, 02:56

3. Winderlich
2. Hird
1. Lucas

Hille unlucky.

bomberstomake8

9 Jun 2007, 09:55

3. hird (brownlow anyone)
2. hille
1. fletcher

dishonourable
3. mcphee (absolute shocker)
2. MJ (his first half was very poor
1. gus.. (another quiet one)

Pawtucket Patriot

9 Jun 2007, 11:02

3. Hille
2. Hird
1. Winderlich

Also outstanding: Lucas, Fletcher, Michael, Lloyd, Slattery

goal sneak

9 Jun 2007, 11:20

This is a view from a nuetral supporter of the match.

3 - Hird - No need to explain.
2 - Winderlich - Though he gave you guys great drive off half back. Has really come a long way this year and could be the next superstar of the competion with his fast running and good skills.
1 - Fletcher - Absolute rock 9in defence. May be having his best season yet.

Hille was excellent after quarter time but was belted in the first quarter and was a major reason for the quarter time defecit so left him out.
Lucas despite kicking 5 gaols was not one of the dominant players on the ground.
Peverill very unlucky to miss out on votes. Also thought that McVeigh an Welsh played good games.
And Matthew Llyod's final half was inspirational.

Raskolnikov

9 Jun 2007, 11:27

3. Jimmy Hird
2. Fletch
1. Winders

Darealrath

9 Jun 2007, 11:28

3. Fletcher
2. Hird
1. Winderlich

Hille and Lucas next.

Jem

9 Jun 2007, 11:30

3. Hird
2. Flethcer
1. Winderlich

Apologies to Slattery, Hille and Lucas

kizza

9 Jun 2007, 11:36

3. Winderlich
2. Hird
1. Fletch

Winder's had a cracker last night! Provides so much run for us, so important.
Hirdy was great, as always. And Fletch just keeps on smashing it. Hopefully he's fine, but the HeraldSun or Age (can't remember which one) claimed that he may have torn an adductor muscle...hope not.

Special mentions to Hille and Slattery. Was impressed with Hille's effort to not concede that behind in the dying minutes too. Slatts took Kerr apart last night, his tackling was fantastic!

hotwizz

9 Jun 2007, 11:37

3- window licker
2- hird
1- hille

many played great games... i would still like to see heff, hislop or lonergan in the side before campo.. too slow and doesnt have the desperation - numerous occasions last night where his didnt chase hard, tackle hard or attempt to smother when they were there for the taking

Darealrath

9 Jun 2007, 11:41

Winder's had a cracker last night! Provides so much run for us, so important.

How good was that play in the last quarter where he sprinted about 500m (slight exaggeration) to provide an option at half back, couldn't stop and almost tripped over he was running that hard ?

We didn't miss Stanton in the second half because Winderlich ran so hard.

rule of four

9 Jun 2007, 11:44

3. hird (brownlow anyone)
2. hille
1. fletcher

dishonourable
3. mcphee (absolute shocker)
2. MJ (his first half was very poor
1. gus.. (another quiet one)

I agree...i looked in the paper this morning and it said 10 critical errors for McPhee. He just seemed to have lost the plot last night. Can't fault him on his effort though, where in the last quarter he won a two on one except the umpire picket a WC free out of nowhere

DaSawx

9 Jun 2007, 11:48

How good was that play in the last quarter where he sprinted about 500m (slight exaggeration) to provide an option at half back, couldn't stop and almost tripped over he was running that hard ?

We didn't miss Stanton in the second half because Winderlich ran so hard.

yeah, happened right in front of me, thought he was going to do a hammy LOL

I agree...i looked in the paper this morning and it said 10 critical errors for McPhee. He just seemed to have lost the plot last night. Can't fault him on his effort though, where in the last quarter he won a two on one except the umpire picket a WC free out of nowhere

Ah well, not one of his best, but he has been terriffic as of late, no one is perfect, he should bounce back

Bomber57

9 Jun 2007, 12:18

3 hird
2 fletch
1 hille

I am having flashbacks of 1993 :)

Bomber Bears

9 Jun 2007, 12:32

3. Fletch
2. Hird
1. Winderlich

Ted Ed Fred

9 Jun 2007, 15:43

Good win guys. As I saw it

5 votes: Hird
4: Hille
3. Peverell
2. Lucas
1. Winderlich

kelvin_sheedy

9 Jun 2007, 15:44

anyone who doesnt give hird 3 votes has gotta be blind
3 - j hird
2 - d hille
1 - s lucas

Fletch was BOG by the length of the straight at Flemington.

GoDons

9 Jun 2007, 16:23

3: J. Hird
2: D. Fletcher
1: D. Hille

DaSawx

9 Jun 2007, 20:44

3 - Fletch
2 - Sir James
1 - Scotty

dodgyJim

10 Jun 2007, 07:27

Laycocks couple of goals were great... Very accurate at long range.

I for one didn't want him in the team this week, glad he proved me wrong.

I agree. His kicking from ~50 at goal was spot on, I was a nervous wreck waiting him to line up based on his past shots at goal.

Well done to the boys on Coxy, he got the better of them in the 1st half but they came back well.

dodgyJim

10 Jun 2007, 07:59

By the way, the game was released a few hours ago on the net if anyone is looking for it.

Mine is at about 12% so far.

Sorry mods, dunno if this oversteps the mark or not....:(

DaSawx

10 Jun 2007, 11:56

By the way, the game was released a few hours ago on the net if anyone is looking for it.

Mine is at about 12% so far.

Sorry mods, dunno if this oversteps the mark or not....:(

Pfft, don't see anything wrong with it, can't say I'm sqeaky clean

Lynch takes a mark

10 Jun 2007, 22:33

3 - Fletcher - dominated the backline and was in everything
2 - Hird - legend
1 - Hille - massive influence on the game

if I was going with 5 4 3 2 1 I would add lucas and winderlich to the list

Tony Delaney

11 Jun 2007, 12:01

3 Hird

2 Fletcher

1 Winderlich

Apologies Hille who started very slow and Lucas.

coxon

12 Jun 2007, 13:31

back after long weekend, and i got a crapload of threads to read up on... wow...

3. hird
2. winders
1. fletch

as another fan mentioned last week... i wonder who's turn it is to get 'slatterized' !