Player Votes: Round 11 vs Richmond

[Yello Mit]

5: Peter Bell
4: Matthew Pavlich
3: Des Headland
2: Josh Carr
1: Garrick Ibbotson (for his debut and kicking his first goal)

[Kenny_01]

5- Pavlich
4- Headland
3- Bell
2- Johnson
1- J Carr/ Hayden

[Ripper]

5: Bell
4: D.J.
3: Pav
2: Stringer
1: Hayden

[ImperialPurple]

5. Bell
4. Pav
3. Des
2. Johnno
1. Hayden

Josh Carr stiff to miss. :o
Good debut for Ibbo. :thumbsu:
Great game from Big Nockers. :thumbsu:
Shauny Mac still has it. :thumbsu:
Matthew Carr is the softest, laziest player on our list by a gazillion light years and more. :thumbsd:
The umpires are dead-set doing my head in.. I don't think they could be worse if they tried. :mad:

[dugrene]

5 Bell
4 Des
3 Pav
2 Josh
1 Roger

[e10pizza]

umpire 27 had a blinder:rolleyes:

[Scham]

5. Pav
4. Bell
3. Macca
2. Hayden
1. Des

Umpire 27 was Michael Avon, he gets 5 votes for Richmond! I think he only paid 1 free kick to us.

[Lach72]

I couldn't get to the game due to family commitments but saw about 2/3 on the box.
Thanking my lucky stars I didn't see all of the first quarter or may have stabbed my eyes out.
Anyway, from what I saw:
5 Bell
4 Josh Carr
3 Pav (was it him who dropped the ball short twice from inside 50? :confused:)
2 Dessie ( Dessie loves Belnakor, loves you dude I can tell)
1 Robbie Warnock (he is showing signs of being better thn Sandi, seems to have better balance and skill.)

[macka6210]

5. Bell
4. McManus
3. Headland
2. Carr J
1. Pavlich

[dominguez]

5) Des Headland- What a champion!
4) Peter Bell- Poor Bellie, must get a sore back from carrying so many.
3) Johnson
2) Josh Carr
1) Pavlova

[Yello Mit]

Matthew Carr is the softest, laziest player on our list by a gazillion light years and more. :thumbsd:
Umm... Didn't he get like 9 tackles today?

[dominguez]

Umm... Didn't he get like 9 tackles today?


Tackles only count when it is Cook, Solomon or Webster. ;)

Matt Carr could have 40 possessions and 20 tackles and he still wouldn't be in my 22 for the following week.

[Kenny_01]

Pavlich 5th best player for Freo? Did I miss something?!? I am pretty sure he will get BOG when the coaches do their 5,4,3,2,1 tomorrow night.

I think people always expect Pav to play awesome which he does but he doesn't get top votes unless he has an absolute pearler.

[Reveler]

5. Bell
4. Pavlich
3. Headland
2. Hayden
1. Johnson

[DOCKER MAN]

1. Bell
2. Pavlich
3. Headland
4. Hayden
5. Warnock

[estibador]

6 Umpires - could have at least bought us dinner before they raped us. Most biased umpiring I've seen in a long time. And that's saying something because I watch the eagles every week.

5 Pavlich - creative, unselfish and inspirational.

4 Bell - little champ is still a ball magnet. Worked his little socks off.

3 Headland - showed how dangerous he can be up forward. Should shut the baggers up for another week. (Actually no it won't, they will just whine "Why can't he kick 5 goals every week.)

2 Macca - just about his best game for the year I thought. Roved Warnock brilliantly in the 2nd half and his kicking was the best I've ever seen.

1 Hayden - words can't describe how much I love this little champ. I'm tipping a top 3 Doig finish this year.

Apologies to Johnson and J. Carr who both had great games. Warnock continues to impress me. Solid enough debut for Ibbo too - nice to see him get a goal. Congrats to Thornton on his 1st goal too.

McPharlin had a shocker though. Pity he's not allowed to play on our forwards because then he wouldn't get pinged for half the stuff he gets done for now.

[pinkus maximus]

5 pavlich
4 bell
3 des
2 warnock
1 hayden

[ImperialPurple]

Umm... Didn't he get like 9 tackles today?

Dunno - but it wouldn't surprise me as he is reactive rather than pro-active. I don't normally bag players, but I've finally lost the biscuit with Matt Carr. He's lazy and soft. The thing that did it for me was a contest on the wing on the Roberts Rd side - Carr was watching his opponent (Deledio I suspect) run towards the loose the ball. He was about half a metre behind him and didn't even attempt to get the ball himself. Next thing - like out of nowhere - Macca appeared, went in hard, body on the line, and won and cleared the ball. All the while Carr was standing back while Macca battled against his guy. :thumbsd:

(Sorry wrong thread to be having this discussion - but I've seriously had it with his half-arsed efforts. :mad:)

[Cameron_K]

5. Bell
4. Headland
3. Pavlich
2. Warnock
1. Johnson

[Dr Ralph Dagg]

5. Bell
4. Headland
3. Pavlich
2. McManus
1. Hayden

[pistol17]

5. Bell
4. Pavlich
3. Johnson
2. McManus
1. J. Carr

[Freo Big Fella]

5. Pavlich
4. Bell
3. Headland
2. Josh Carr
1. Jonno

[Topdock65]

5) Bell
4) Pav - Could have had 6-8 goals yesterday.
3) Dessie - 5 goals !!!!
2) Hayden - In our top 5 players and one of our most important
1) Warnock - Keep going young man.

[Plugga]

5 Pav
4 Desso
3 Belly
2 Johnno
1 Mcmanus

[The Joker]

5. Des
4. Pav
3. Bell
2. Roger
1. Johno

[masai]

5. Bell
4. Pav
3. Des - give credit where credit is due, but why can't he extract the digit more regularly ?.
2. Macca
1. Hayden

[masai]

Dunno - but it wouldn't surprise me as he is reactive rather than pro-active. I don't normally bag players, but I've finally lost the biscuit with Matt Carr. He's lazy and soft. The thing that did it for me was a contest on the wing on the Roberts Rd side - Carr was watching his opponent (Deledio I suspect) run towards the loose the ball. He was about half a metre behind him and didn't even attempt to get the ball himself. Next thing - like out of nowhere - Macca appeared, went in hard, body on the line, and won and cleared the ball. All the while Carr was standing back while Macca battled against his guy. :thumbsd:

(Sorry wrong thread to be having this discussion - but I've seriously had it with his half-arsed efforts. :mad:)

As Meatloaf would say, "you took the words right out of my mouth".

[The Joker]

Results Rd 11:

7 - Bell (94)
6 - Pavlich (79)
5 - Headland (69)
4 - Hayden (18)
=3 - Johnson (16)
=3 - Carr J (16)
=3 - McManus (16)
-------------------

Warnock - 9
Ibbotson - 1