View Full Version : Life Ban on suspended players
I am not sure if everyone is aware of the recent situation in the MPNFL, where a 23 Year old player has received a life ban due to him receiving 14 weeks for striking and he had a previous 2 week suspension from the year before which then gave him a total of 16 weeks which means as per the AFL rules he is to be de registered never to play again or be affiliated with football in an official position?
( Unless he appeals to the AFL and the matter is overturned )
This rule applies to all players and officials in Aussie rules Football and the de registration occurs once you hit 16 weeks in total.
http://www.footballvic.com.au/default.aspx?s=policydisplay&aid=94953
I was just wondering how many players or even officials in the SFL, would either be close or would need to be wary of this rule?
xxscubaxx
13 Jun 2007, 10:12
14 weeks for striking, thats pretty tough. i wonder what happened.
Injury prone
13 Jun 2007, 11:48
14 weeks for striking, thats pretty tough. i wonder what happened.
Broke Seafords gun players jaw. He is gone for season, so the tribunal repayed the deed and then some.
chaddles
13 Jun 2007, 13:02
Broke Seafords gun players jaw. He is gone for season, so the tribunal repayed the deed and then some.
Well sounds like a fair result from the tribunal. Should be alot more tough decisions like that to stop dirty thugs from ruining players seasons and careers even.
Master of Cooks
13 Jun 2007, 13:42
16 weeks over a career doesn't seem like that much, not saying that it should be excepted, but I'd be pretty confident that some AFL players would have racked up 16 or more weeks in total, or would at least be pretty close.
I'm pretty sure Jeff Farmer is the most suspended AFL player, and he just recieved another 6 weeks this year, so he would have to be pretty close to or over 16 weeks.:eek:
Does anyone know if he is the most suspended player and how many weeks has he been suspended for in total?
chaddles
13 Jun 2007, 14:19
16 weeks over a career doesn't seem like that much, not saying that it should be excepted, but I'd be pretty confident that some AFL players would have racked up 16 or more weeks in total, or would at least be pretty close.
I'm pretty sure Jeff Farmer is the most suspended AFL player, and he just recieved another 6 weeks this year, so he would have to be pretty close to or over 16 weeks.:eek:
Does anyone know if he is the most suspended player and how many weeks has he been suspended for in total?
Very good point- I am sure that there would be players to have received over 16 weeks. How long has this rule been in for??
xxscubaxx
13 Jun 2007, 14:31
yeh im pretty sure jeff farmer is the most suspended player, 13 games
Frankencow
13 Jun 2007, 17:01
Jonathan Brown has 14 games off, and he only started in 2001. He's 25 years old. Steven Baker is on 10, I'm pretty sure he can catch Browny.
Would be very interesting to know if Browny has been suspended in U18s, as this would carry over under AFL rules.
xxscubaxx
13 Jun 2007, 17:36
you are correct frank. also cam mooney has 13 weeks
Frankencow
13 Jun 2007, 17:42
I would be extremely surprised, however, if Jon Brown got a 2 week penalty and was deregistered.
Frankencow
13 Jun 2007, 17:48
I can only find info back to 2001 for Tribunals scuba, in which year Farmer had 13 games. Can't find info for before then. Farmer started in 1995.
xxscubaxx
13 Jun 2007, 18:31
yeh same here, i got it off some fantasy footy website. im guessing your looking at the same stuff i am.
scratcha
16 Jun 2007, 22:00
I am not sure if everyone is aware of the recent situation in the MPNFL, where a 23 Year old player has received a life ban due to him receiving 14 weeks for striking and he had a previous 2 week suspension from the year before which then gave him a total of 16 weeks which means as per the AFL rules he is to be de registered never to play again or be affiliated with football in an official position?
( Unless he appeals to the AFL and the matter is overturned )
This rule applies to all players and officials in Aussie rules Football and the de registration occurs once you hit 16 weeks in total.
http://www.footballvic.com.au/default.aspx?s=policydisplay&aid=94953
I was just wondering how many players or even officials in the SFL, would either be close or would need to be wary of this rule?
Is it true that he was only acting under the instruction of their Coach, Martin Pike, to take out Seafords gun player???
Suspending players is one thing....
Any suggestions for the Brain Surgeon in the grey beanie who leaned over the fence and belted Rob Turner (Hampton) at Murrumbeena yesterday during a little push & shove between the players
Such a clever bloke too. right in front ov the TV cameras.
Suspending players is one thing....
Any suggestions for the Brain Surgeon in the grey beanie who leaned over the fence and belted Rob Turner (Hampton) at Murrumbeena yesterday during a little push & shove between the players
Such a clever bloke too. right in front ov the TV cameras.
This goes for the doveton clown who ran on to the field two weeks ago and got involved in a push and shove. The SFL should investigate these clubs and clean up this crap:mad:
This goes for the doveton clown who ran on to the field two weeks ago and got involved in a push and shove. The SFL should investigate these clubs and clean up this crap:mad:
care to elaborate on the doveton incident smuu28?:confused:
care to elaborate on the doveton incident smuu28?:confused:
a scuffle between our CHF and a doveton player near the boundry line on the foward flank, nothing major than this clown with not sure if he was a player or supporter must not have liked the scoreboard and jumped the fence throwing windmills left right and centre. A couple of canterbury stallwarts draged this brain fade from the ground and play continued. It Sh**'s me when idiots feel the need to puff there chest out. Let the 18 blokes on the field handle it.
Kobra Khan
17 Jun 2007, 20:35
Had a pretty good view of that one vs eagles. The actual incident had not much in it - push shove here, haymaker there. The problem was the fella from the sidelines who decided it was a great time for him to get down off the wall and get in the middle of things (no intent to seperate and calm the incident!). Apparently the word was he may have part of another Doveton team??
who r u
18 Jun 2007, 12:15
Suspending players is one thing....
Any suggestions for the Brain Surgeon in the grey beanie who leaned over the fence and belted Rob Turner (Hampton) at Murrumbeena yesterday during a little push & shove between the players
Such a clever bloke too. right in front ov the TV cameras.
It wasn't Giddo was it?
It wasn't Giddo was it?
Very Smart Where are U !!:mad:
Had a pretty good view of that one vs eagles. The actual incident had not much in it - push shove here, haymaker there. The problem was the fella from the sidelines who decided it was a great time for him to get down off the wall and get in the middle of things (no intent to seperate and calm the incident!). Apparently the word was he may have part of another Doveton team??
Blac04 / Scratcha - Who was this masked man ?
scratcha
18 Jun 2007, 19:12
a scuffle between our CHF and a doveton player near the boundry line on the foward flank, nothing major than this clown with not sure if he was a player or supporter must not have liked the scoreboard and jumped the fence throwing windmills left right and centre. A couple of canterbury stallwarts draged this brain fade from the ground and play continued. It Sh**'s me when idiots feel the need to puff there chest out. Let the 18 blokes on the field handle it.
Those blokes are not from our club. Probably just down watching a mate???
scratcha
18 Jun 2007, 19:13
Blac04 / Scratcha - Who was this masked man ?
I dont know???
scratcha
18 Jun 2007, 19:17
This goes for the doveton clown who ran on to the field two weeks ago and got involved in a push and shove. The SFL should investigate these clubs and clean up this crap:mad:
He wasnt from our club!!!!
He wasnt from our club!!!!
All well and good but at the end of the day he has jumped in for you blokes, what if this "supporter/spectator" did some real damage to a canterbury player and put him in hospital? Isn't there a duty of care on behalf of doveton? :confused:
All well and good but at the end of the day he has jumped in for you blokes, what if this "supporter/spectator" did some real damage to a canterbury player and put him in hospital? Isn't there a duty of care on behalf of doveton? :confused:
No duty of care for Doveton if he wasn't a registered member of the club.
A club can't be held liable for people who attend local football games in a public place.
I would suggest if that occurred it would be matter for Police !
No duty of care for Doveton if he wasn't a registered member of the club.
A club can't be held liable for people who attend local football games in a public place.
I would suggest if that occurred it would be matter for Police !
fully concur giddo!! gee you're a smart man!:rolleyes:
bomberdude18 2
7 Jul 2007, 18:07
Is it true that he was only acting under the instruction of their Coach, Martin Pike, to take out Seafords gun player???
That would sound like a Martin Pike thing to do.
But fair dinkum, Martin Pike has got no brains at all, and he is the seniors coach of a club. How does that work out?
motorvinnie
8 Jul 2007, 12:35
That would sound like a Martin Pike thing to do.
But fair dinkum, Martin Pike has got no brains at all, and he is the seniors coach of a club. How does that work out?
you should hear hiis speaches at quarter time lol.. his favourite words are f*** and c*** and thats all he really says, absolutely shocking. he has made hastings worst