View Full Version : Injuries Aside, Who Is Our Best 25 (including emergencies)
Stants_24_Legend
12 Jul 2007, 17:36
B:Ramanaskuas Michael M.Johnson
HB: Fletcher Ryder McPhee
C: Peverill Winderlich McVeigh
HF: Hird Lucas Welsh
F: Davey Lloyd Lovett
R: Laycock Stanton J.Johnson
I/C: Hille Monfries Jetta Gumbleton/NLM
Emg: Houli NLM/Gumbleton Hislop
Houli and Hislop - just 2 young kids will def be in the team most of next year.
NLM/Gumbleton - Couldnt split them. Both should be in our best 22
Campo - Finished wont play another game this year (after saturday night)
Kepler Bradley - Not good enough
Courtney Johns - Dont want him to leave but with that side i couldnt see where he would fit.
Bolton - Finished
Heffernan - Finished
Cole - Finished
Lee - got potential just isnt using it
Dyson - Amazing potential but will go at years end.
with the rookies like Nash, Lonergan, Reimers, Hocking, Dick, Chartes, McKinnon, Neagle and Dempsey. All need more of a chance in the seniors to see them. Ive seen the likes of Reimers, Hocking, Dick and Chartes and they all look very very good and all have agilty. We need to keep McKinnon with his height cant remember the last time we had a half decent ruckmen.
Longy413
12 Jul 2007, 17:41
I reckon Watson would get a game.
Slattery likewise.
Daytripper
12 Jul 2007, 17:41
B:Ramanaskuas Michael M.Johnson
HB: Fletcher Ryder McPhee
C: Peverill Winderlich McVeigh
HF: Hird Lucas Welsh
F: Davey Lloyd Lovett
R: Laycock Stanton J.Johnson
I/C: Hille Monfries Jetta Gumbleton/NLM
Emg: Houli NLM/Gumbleton Hislop
Houli and Hislop - just 2 young kids will def be in the team most of next year.
NLM/Gumbleton - Couldnt split them. Both should be in our best 22
Campo - Finished wont play another game this year (after saturday night)
Kepler Bradley - Not good enough
Courtney Johns - Dont want him to leave but with that side i couldnt see where he would fit.
Bolton - Finished
Heffernan - Finished
Cole - Finished
Lee - got potential just isnt using it
Dyson - Amazing potential but will go at years end.
with the rookies like Nash, Lonergan, Reimers, Hocking, Dick, Chartes, McKinnon, Neagle and Dempsey. All need more of a chance in the seniors to see them. Ive seen the likes of Reimers, Hocking, Dick and Chartes and they all look very very good and all have agilty. We need to keep McKinnon with his height cant remember the last time we had a half decent ruckmen.
My opinion only but Bradley has more ability in his right toe than Houli. So does Courtney Dempsey.
DonMania#5
12 Jul 2007, 17:42
Essendon Best 22
B: Mark Johnson, Mal Michael, Nathan Lovett-Murray
HB: Paddy Ryder, Dustin Fletcher, Adam Mcphee
C: Brent Stanton, Jobe Watson, Jason Winderlich
HF: James Hird, Scott Lucas, Andrew Welsh
F: Alwyn Davey, Matthew Lloyd, Andrew Lovett
FOLL: David Hille, Jason Johnson, Damien Peverill
I/C: Angus Monfries, Jason Laycock, Henry Slattery, Jay Nash
Stants_24_Legend
12 Jul 2007, 17:45
I reckon Watson would get a game.
Slattery likewise.
they are there mate have another look
Stants_24_Legend
12 Jul 2007, 17:45
they are there mate have another look
sorry mate no there not
how could i forget them
DonMania#5
12 Jul 2007, 17:46
they are there mate have another look
I do not see Watson or Slattery.
kelvin_sheedy
12 Jul 2007, 17:49
sorry mate no there not
how could i forget them
Quite easily judging by some of your selections ;)
sheedy has been saying all year thatvhe wants to get dempsey intot he side and i have no doubt he would be in our best 22
Legend Lucas
12 Jul 2007, 19:10
B Fletcher Michael Welsh
HB Ramanauskas Ryder McPhee
C McVeigh Watson Peverill
HF Hird Lucas Lovett
F Davey Lloyd Hille
R Laycock Stanton Winderlich
INT Slattery N L-Murray Monfries Dyson
Emg Bradley Nash M.Johnson
*Laycock better tap ruck than Hille who could be dangerous as a deep forward to let lloyd roam
* Johnson boys great stalwarts for the club but unable to provide the run we need and now being beaten in their strengths in one on one contests
* We have very capable but backline and forward line but will struggle to match top teams due to very ordinary midfield we always look slow coz our midfielders can never get their hand on the ball , amazing how we look quicker in our blazing first terms when we get plenty of ball thru the middle
B Fletcher Michael Welsh
HB Ramanauskas Ryder McPhee
C McVeigh Watson Peverill
HF Hird Lucas Lovett
F Davey Lloyd Hille
R Laycock Stanton Winderlich
INT Slattery N L-Murray Monfries Dyson
Emg Bradley Nash M.Johnson
*Laycock better tap ruck than Hille who could be dangerous as a deep forward to let lloyd roam
* Johnson boys great stalwarts for the club but unable to provide the run we need and now being beaten in their strengths in one on one contests
* We have very capable but backline and forward line but will struggle to match top teams due to very ordinary midfield we always look slow coz our midfielders can never get their hand on the ball , amazing how we look quicker in our blazing first terms when we get plenty of ball thru the middle
Nash is ahead of both Dyson and Monfries. I would also have JJ ahead of Pev. I would also like to see Dempsey ahead of Dyson.
RED AND BLACK SOLDIER
12 Jul 2007, 19:42
B: Dustin Fletcher, Mal Michael, Mark Johnson
HB: Jay Nash, Paddy Ryder, Adam Mcphee
C: Brent Stanton, Jobe Watson, Jason Winderlich
HF: James Hird, Scott Lucas, Andrew Welsh
F: Alwyn Davey, Matthew Lloyd, Andrew Lovett
FOLL: David Hille, Jason Johnson, Mark McVeigh
I/C: Tom Hislop, Jason Laycock, Henry Slattery, Damien Peverill
EMG: Angus Monfries, NLM, Kepler Bradley
d-mac3276
12 Jul 2007, 20:23
B: Jay Nash Mal Michael Patrick Ryder
HB: Adam McPhee Dustin Fletcher Nathan Lovett-Murray
C: Jason Winderlich Jobe Watson Brent Stanton
HF: Andrew Welsh Scott Lucas Andrew Lovett
F: Alwyn Davey Matthew Lloyd Angus Monfries
Foll: David Hille Jason Johnson Mark McVeigh
Inter: Tom Hislop Henry Slattery Bachar Houli Leroy Jetta Jason Laycock Scott Gumbleton
Emerg: Mark Johnson Damien Peverill Adam Ramanauskas
This is post James Hird so basically for next year this is the side i want running around just couldn't squeeze 2 out so went for a 6 man bench which it should b anyway.
grindog
12 Jul 2007, 22:35
B: Mark Johnson Mal Michael Dustin Fletcher
HB: Adam McPhee Paddy Ryder Nathan Lovett-Murray
C: Jobe Watson Brent Stanton Jason Winderlich
HF: James Hird Scott Lucas Andrew Lovett
F: Alwyn Davey Matthew Lloyd Jason Laycock
R: David Hille Jason Johnson Damien Peverill
I: Andrew Welsh Mark McVeigh Adam Ramanaskus Henry Slattery
E: Angus Monfries Jay Nash Leroy Jetta
Very tought team to beat IMO.
bomberstomake8
13 Jul 2007, 01:25
B:Ramanaskuas Michael M.Johnson
HB: Fletcher Ryder McPhee
C: Peverill Winderlich McVeigh
HF: Hird Lucas Welsh
F: Davey Lloyd Lovett
R: Laycock Stanton J.Johnson
I/C: Hille Monfries Jetta Gumbleton/NLM
Emg: Houli NLM/Gumbleton Hislop
Houli and Hislop - just 2 young kids will def be in the team most of next year.
NLM/Gumbleton - Couldnt split them. Both should be in our best 22
Campo - Finished wont play another game this year (after saturday night)
Kepler Bradley - Not good enough
Courtney Johns - Dont want him to leave but with that side i couldnt see where he would fit.
Bolton - Finished
Heffernan - Finished
Cole - Finished
Lee - got potential just isnt using it
Dyson - Amazing potential but will go at years end.
with the rookies like Nash, Lonergan, Reimers, Hocking, Dick, Chartes, McKinnon, Neagle and Dempsey. All need more of a chance in the seniors to see them. Ive seen the likes of Reimers, Hocking, Dick and Chartes and they all look very very good and all have agilty. We need to keep McKinnon with his height cant remember the last time we had a half decent ruckmen.
yeah watson and slattery should be in there... definately.. i also need to ask why you put laycock starting in the ruck and hille on the bench... surely you dont think that laycock is a better footballer then hille.
mattdavies_03
13 Jul 2007, 07:30
Essendon Best 22
B: Mark Johnson, Mal Michael, Nathan Lovett-Murray
HB: Paddy Ryder, Dustin Fletcher, Adam Mcphee
C: Brent Stanton, Jobe Watson, Jason Winderlich
HF: James Hird, Scott Lucas, Andrew Welsh
F: Alwyn Davey, Matthew Lloyd, Andrew Lovett
FOLL: David Hille, Jason Johnson, Damien Peverill
I/C: Angus Monfries, Jason Laycock, Henry Slattery, Jay Nash
I like this one, EMG would be Houli, Jetta and Kep IMO
Stants_24_Legend
13 Jul 2007, 10:23
yeah watson and slattery should be in there... definately.. i also need to ask why you put laycock starting in the ruck and hille on the bench... surely you dont think that laycock is a better footballer then hille.
yes i do think Laycock is a better player than Hille. Definately a better ruckmen than Hille...Watch closely that Laycock will try and tap the ball to our midfielders...with hille, he runs into the opposition ruckmen or takes the ball out of the ruck. The Idea of being a ruckmen is to tap the ball down to your crumbing midfielders
Daytripper
13 Jul 2007, 12:02
yes i do think Laycock is a better player than Hille. Definately a better ruckmen than Hille...Watch closely that Laycock will try and tap the ball to our midfielders...with hille, he runs into the opposition ruckmen or takes the ball out of the ruck. The Idea of being a ruckmen is to tap the ball down to your crumbing midfielders
I really don't know what to respond to this other than to say its ridiculous.
Bombers Fan
13 Jul 2007, 12:17
I'll give it a go
Probably similar to some, but I haven't looked.
B: Lovett-Murray, Michael, M. Johnson
HB: Ryder, Fletcher, McPhee
C: Lovett, Watson, Winderlich
HF: Hird, Lucas, Welsh
F: Monfries, Lloyd, Davey
R: Hille, Stanton, J, Johnson
I/C: Laycock, Slattery, Nash, Peverill
EMG: Jetta, Hislop, Dyson
d-mac3276
14 Jul 2007, 14:47
where's judd d-mac????? Couldn't fit him in mate likewise Nick Riewoldt, Nick Dal Santo and Matthew Pavlich. But they were close.