View Full Version : AFL Umpire Appointments Round 15 (4 Changes, Goldspink has Hawks)
*All 3 umpires from Coll v St.K were appointed even though the AFL admitted a below average performance
ST KILDA vs ADELAIDE
Scott McLaren (11) (VIC), Shaun Ryan (25) (VIC), Scott Jeffery (29) (TAS)
GEELONG vs COLLINGWOOD
Stephen McBurney (3) (VIC), Dean Margetts (6) (WA), Brett Rosebury (8) (WA)
PORT ADELAIDE vs WEST COAST
Michael Vozzo (2) (VIC), Matthew Head (16) (VIC), Michael Avon (27) (SA)
ESSENDON vs WESTERN BULLDOGS
Chris Donlon (1) (VIC), Brett Allen (10) (VIC), Stuart Wenn (22) (VIC)
MELBOURNE vs BRISBANE LIONS
Martin Ellis (23) (VIC), Kieron Nicholls (28) (VIC), Troy Pannell (31) (NSW)
SYDNEY vs CARLTON
Hayden Kennedy (7) (VIC), Chris Kamolins (19) (VIC), Simon Meredith (21) (VIC)
HAWTHORN vs RICHMOND
Matt Stevic (9) (VIC), Stefan Grun (13) (SA), Darren Goldspink (32) (VIC)
FREMANTLE vs KANGAROOS
Ray Chamberlain (18) (VIC), Craig Hendrie (24) (WA), Shane McInerney (30) (VIC)
UMPIRES IN:
Matthew Head (16)
Michael Avon (27)
Chris Kamolins (19)
Stefan Grun (13)
UMPIRES OUT:
Luke Farmer (4) WCE v Bris
Mathew James (5)
Damien Sully (12) Rich v Kang
Jason Quigley (14)
Matt Nicholls (15)
Justin Schmitt (17)
Derek Woodcock (26) WB v Port
Gary Fila (37) Carl v Melb
ST.K
McLaren- 1L
Ryan- 1W 1L
Jeffery- 1W 2L
ADE
McLaren- 1L
Ryan- 3W 1L
Jeffery- 2W
GEEL
McBurney- 1W
Margetts- 1L
Rosebury-
COLL
McBurney- 2W
Margetts- 1W 2L
Rosebury- 1L
PORT
Vozzo- 1L
Head- 2W 1L
Avon- 1L
WCE
Vozzo- 2W 1L
Head- 1W 1L
Avon- 1W
ESS
Donlon- 2W
Allen- 1W
Wenn- 1L
WB
Donlon- 1W 2L
Allen-
Wenn- 1W 1L
MELB
Ellis- 2L
K. Nicholls-
Pannell- 1L
BL
Ellis- 1L
K. Nicholls- 1W 2L
Pannell- 1W 1L
SYD
Kennedy- 1W
Kamolins- 1W
Meredith- 2W 1L
CARL
Kennedy- 1W 1L
Kamolins- 1W 1L
Meredith- 1L
HAW
Stevic- 1W
Grun- 2W 1L
Goldspink-
RICH
Stevic- 2L
Grun- 2L 1D
Goldspink-
FREO
Chamberlain- 1W 1L
Hendrie- 1W
McInerney- 2W 1L
KANG
Chamberlain- 1W 1L
Hendrie- 1L
McInerney- 1W 1L
McBurney again. Just fantastic.
McBurney again. Just fantastic.
Be thankful that we at least got Rosebury in that game, he has had a good year.
pjcrows
12 Jul 2007, 20:11
ST KILDA vs ADELAIDE
Scott McLaren (11) (VIC), Shaun Ryan (25) (VIC), Scott Jeffery (29) (TAS)
We got the trifecta!!! :thumbsu:
Be thankful that we at least got Rosebury in that game, he has had a good year.
Oh yeah, Margetts and Rosebury are 2 of the better umpires going around. Would both be in line for their 1st GF this season.
It's just there's a select group of umps such as McBurney, McLaren, Goldy etc. that you dread seeing umpire each week.
Avoided Rampaging Ray ****ing Chamberlain again :thumbsu:
I thought we were due. One more week without him at least.
TylerDurden
12 Jul 2007, 20:20
Mate, we got Goldstink - bring the pain...
How does Chamberlain get another gig?
Scroater
12 Jul 2007, 20:47
Farmer and Fila unlucky. Both are only new aren't they?
Didn't think Fila did too much wrong in Melb v Carl and saw Farmer WB v Nth, he stayed out of the way although probably didn't notice him because of Wenn (22).
Bewdy got him again for the Ess game.:mad:
And Donlon:eek:
Brett Allen - step up and take control.
Russian
12 Jul 2007, 21:59
Farmer and Fila unlucky. Both are only new aren't they?They wouldn't be dropped if they weren't
Scroater
12 Jul 2007, 22:00
They wouldn't be dropped if they weren't
Not new or not unlucky
brucetiki
12 Jul 2007, 22:44
Surprised to see Grun back in after his shocker in the SANFL last week - it was one of the most poorly umpired SANFL games (not involving Richard Williams) I've seen in quite some time.
GOALden Hawk
13 Jul 2007, 10:11
I love it, AFL admits umpirires were terrible in the SK v Collingwood game, then gives all 3 games!
I can only pray Goldspink injures himself between now and Sunday.
I love it, AFL admits umpirires were terrible in the SK v Collingwood game, then gives all 3 games!
I can only pray Goldspink injures himself between now and Sunday.
No, it said they made some mistakes.
If you dropped every Hawthorn player that made some mistakes last week, you wouldn't have a team this week.
Appointments
2007 Premiership season
Round 15
Fri. 13 July St.Kilda v. Adelaide Telstra Dome
Field : Scott McLaren (11) Shaun Ryan (25) Scott Jeffery (29)
Boundary : Scott Hutton John Wilson Matthew Vitiritti
Goal : Steven Stirling Mark Harrison
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sat.14 July Geelong v. Collingwood MCG
Field : Stephen McBurney (3) Dean Margetts (6) Brett Rosebury (8)
Boundary : Ian Burrows Adam Coote Rob Haala
Goal : Peter Nastasi Luke Walker
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sat 14 July Port Adelaide v. West Coast Eagles AAMI Stadium
Field : Michael Vozzo (2) Matthew Head (16) Michael Avon (27)
Boundary : Darren Wilson Amin Chehade Jonathan Creasey
Goal : Steve Axon
Darren Trengove
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sat 14 July Essendon v. Western Bulldogs Telstra Dome
Field : Chris Donlon (1) Brett Allen (10) Stuart Wenn (22)
Boundary : Matthew Payton Chris Macdonald Gordon Muir
Goal : Peter Gonis Daniel Wilson
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sat.14 July Melbourne v. Brisbane Lions Gabba
Field : Martin Ellis (23) Kieron Nicholls (28) Troy Pannell (31)
Boundary : Cameron Ward Mark Hill Aaron Deckys
Goal : Troy Mavroudis Chelsea Roffey
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sun.15 July Sydney v Carlton SCG
Field : Hayden Kennedy (7) Chris Kamolins (19) Simon Meredith (21)
Boundary : Luke Roberts Adam McDonald Luke McSperrin
Goal : Sergio Villagra James Savage
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sun. 15 July Hawthorn v. Richmond MCG
Field : Matt Stevic (9) Darren Goldspink (32) Stefan Grun (13)
Boundary : Chris Morrison Mark Foster Glenn Gibson
Goal : Craig Clark Jason Venkataya
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sun. 8 July Fremantle v. Kangaroos Subiaco
Field : Ray Chamberlain (18) Craig Hendrie (24) Shane McInerney (30)
Boundary : Hadin Martin Jamie Giles Alan Zanich
Goal : Mike Spear Dale Edwick
Hawkamania!
13 Jul 2007, 13:24
I noticed all the anti-Goldspink threads have "disappeared".
I am not happy with Goldspink umpiring the Hawks game. We deserve a capable umpire with a proven track record of being unbiased. There are many capable and fair umpires running around in the state leagues. Time to give them a go as they deserve the spot wasted on Goldspink.
Donlon must be an Essendon supporter.
HAWKS HEROES
14 Jul 2007, 17:48
*
HAWTHORN vs RICHMOND
Matt Stevic (9) (VIC), Stefan Grun (13) (SA), Darren Goldspink (32) (VIC)
noooooooooo :(
well at least we don't have ray too would not mind mr james but no ray oh well lets hope it is fair and consistent umpiring for both teams !
Field Umpire Matthew Head had the VFL game betweeen Box Hill and Tasmania today.
Matthew Head was at AAMI stadium today. Not Box Hill
drewie_rama
15 Jul 2007, 18:25
how did grun go?
how he keeps getting a game il never know
bloody useless hack!!!
Sportsman
15 Jul 2007, 20:38
Farmer and Fila unlucky. Both are only new aren't they?
Didn't think Fila did too much wrong in Melb v Carl and saw Farmer WB v Nth, he stayed out of the way although probably didn't notice him because of Wenn (22).
Bewdy got him again for the Ess game.:mad:
And Donlon:eek:
Brett Allen - step up and take control.
Fila is fairly new.
Promoted up off the rookie list earlier this year due to the retirement of Mark Fraser.
Matthew Head was at AAMI stadium today. Not Box Hill
My apologies it was Matthew Nicholls. At Port Melbourne today Justin Schmitt was umpiring.
Mr Hard Ball Get
15 Jul 2007, 21:32
My apologies it was Matthew Nicholls. At Port Melbourne today Justin Schmitt was umpiring.
yeah schmitt should be back soon next week or the week after coming back from injury