View Full Version : Lance Whitnall?
mightymightyblues
23 Aug 2007, 16:41
From a carlton's supporters perspective, i think Lance still has a fair bit to offer since he is now on top of his weight issue and can now focus on his football. Carlton though still may opt to trade him while he still has some market value to further cement their future and gain another 2nd or 3rd round pick in exchange for him. Which brings me to the question, if Lance was up for grabs would you take him? Why, why not?
Palmer Stoat
23 Aug 2007, 19:02
He's slow and undiscplined (weight problems). Yesterday's man IMO.
He's slow and undiscplined (weight problems). Yesterday's man IMO.
Having said that, he has about 2000% more worth than Rocca. :)
walkers a legend
23 Aug 2007, 20:11
i think we will keep him even though its not in my best interests
croady_fan24
30 Aug 2007, 00:13
Hawks wouldnt take any1 from Carlton..it would stuff up our whore team.:)
jonesy86
30 Aug 2007, 00:27
Lance Whitnall...seems as though he peaked at 20yrs of age and has rapidly gone down hill since
If Whitnall was put up for trade you might get a 4th round pick at best
Hawks wouldnt take any1 from Carlton..it would stuff up our whore team.:)
You have a whore team. I'm moving closer to Glenferrie Oval
Anyway, no because the games has passed him, and his knees are suspect.
JKCeagle
30 Aug 2007, 01:04
No...his much-vaunted "footy brain" can't make up for the many glaring deficiences in his game (pace, fitness, skills)...it'd be good if he finished his career at Carlton though, could probably play a good mentoring role to some of the kids and after so long he deserves to finish as a one-club man.
DapperDon
30 Aug 2007, 01:51
nup, i'm sick of paying Carlton's retirement fund.
please no more!!