View Full Version : Will he stay or will he go??
Alphanumeric
15 Sep 2007, 19:01
Chris Judd. Will he stay or will he go??
What is your gut feeling??
West Coast 06
15 Sep 2007, 19:07
Chris Judd. Will he stay or will he go??
What is your gut feeling??
Gone!
Isandula
15 Sep 2007, 19:11
We shall know in 5 days
paicey-awa
15 Sep 2007, 19:14
Gawn, although I almost changed my mind seeing his reaction last night.
I hope it gets sorted quickly enough that we can get Fev and pick #1 or #3 orr Carlton :thumbsu:
West Coast 06
15 Sep 2007, 19:15
We shall know in 5 days
Why five days?
Isandula
15 Sep 2007, 19:21
Why five days?
Coz that's what his manager said when WC season had finished he'll sort it out in 5 days
Coastal Rocks
15 Sep 2007, 19:23
The way this year has gone, it would NOT surprise me if he leaves.
imright
15 Sep 2007, 19:24
Chris Judd. Will he stay or will he go??
What is your gut feeling??
Why wouldn't he sign up for the Eagles?
Captain of the best or equal best squad of players in the league. Guarenteed of playing finals for a super club which makes monstrous amounts of money. He gets to play in front of family and friends in Victoria at least 8 times a year not including finals.
The question is why would he want to start again with a bottom club?
Why wouldn't he sign up for the Eagles?
Captain of the best or equal best squad of players in the league. Guarenteed of playing finals for a super club which makes monstrous amounts of money. He gets to play in front of family and friends in Victoria at least 8 times a year not including finals.
The question is why would he want to start again with a bottom club?
This is what I don't understand. Why would he leave? Because of the drug scandals earlier in the year? He needs to be closer to mummy and daddy? He's 24 FFS.
People talk about the fishbowl that is Perth, but if he goes to play in Melbourne then the pressure and scrutiny on him will be just as intense because any club that gets him is going to give up alot.
Unless he really hates living in Perth, I can't for the life of me, understand him making a decision to go.
This is what I don't understand. Why would he leave? Because of the drug scandals earlier in the year? He needs to be closer to mummy and daddy? He's 24 FFS.
People talk about the fishbowl that is Perth, but if he goes to play in Melbourne then the pressure and scrutiny on him will be just as intense because any club that gets him is going to give up alot.
Unless he really hates living in Perth, I can't for the life of me, understand him making a decision to go.
the thing about perth is that its actually getting better to live. dullsville is under attack.
larrikin
15 Sep 2007, 21:15
For the first time, today I've actually started feeling he may go. Woosha's interview on 3AW, in which he said nothing, was probably the thing that made me most nervous
I know that doesn't make sense but......
He'll sign on for 2 years. After that he'll sign on for another 3 and end up staying till he's 35.
In that time we will have won 3 premierships and he would have 2 more brownlows and another norm smith.
For the first time, today I've actually started feeling he may go. Woosha's interview on 3AW, in which he said nothing, was probably the thing that made me most nervous
I know that doesn't make sense but......
No I know exactly what you mean Larrikin.
Doesnt sound promising when nothing is said....
Juddism
15 Sep 2007, 22:11
staying....would expect him to be back in Melbourne for the 2010 season but I think he still has some unfinished business at West Coast.
Genesis67
15 Sep 2007, 22:43
Staying.
I have no idea which way he'll decide.
But geez - if he didn't sign on it would cap off a pretty disapointing season.
Freaking injuries and other smack that has gone on.
CMON JUDDY - sign on and stop causing this circus for nothing.
If he does go a lot of us might have to think about changing out nicks ha
Jimmy_the_Gent
15 Sep 2007, 23:44
I predict it's announced that he'll leave but then, after a few days, he changes his mind and stays.
It's all very romantic...Like Peter Matera that time with the Demons.
West Coast 06
15 Sep 2007, 23:46
Gone!He will stay you tosser!
CMON JUDDY - sign on and stop causing this circus for nothing.
As annoying as this constant, tiresome conjecture is Judd did say he would be making his decision at the end of the season, and he stuck to his guns.
Personally, I'll still go along with someone who's as close to him as anyone (bar Twiggers) and that's Kerr, who said straight out, unscripted, unrehearsed "He's staying".
Re-sign for 3 years is my bet.
Keyser Soze
15 Sep 2007, 23:59
As annoying as this constant, tiresome conjecture is Judd did say he would be making his decision at the end of the season, and he stuck to his guns.
Personally, I'll still go along with someone who's as close to him as anyone (bar Twiggers) and that's Kerr, who said straight out, unscripted, unrehearsed "He's staying".
Re-sign for 3 years is my bet.
Was going to post this myself.
But you beat me to it so I'll just agree with you.
It looks more and more likely he is gone this season fellas.
http://realfooty.com.au/news/news/judd-turns-back-on-eagles/2007/09/15/1189277048831.html
West Coast 06
16 Sep 2007, 13:53
He will stay you tosser!
No way, he is gawn!
Keyser Soze
16 Sep 2007, 13:54
Chin up BM it's no more than speculation on their part.
He aint going. That's my baseless speculation.
hinders
16 Sep 2007, 13:56
Chin up BM it's no more than speculation on their part.
He aint going. That's my baseless speculation.
hes going. we may as well merge with freo this is the end of us
Chin up BM it's no more than speculation on their part.
Im not actually upset.
Call me a jilted girlfriend but I've had a gutfull.
Cya Chris * waves at screen*
Gunnar Longshanks
16 Sep 2007, 13:56
I'm going to be bitter if he goes.
We've still got a great window to win a flag while Cousins is around. If Judd bails, I'm not sure that we're as much of a chance, even if we pick up a young gun in the top 3 of the draft.
Judd's 24. Why can't he wait another 2 years to go back to Melbourne?
hes going. we may as well merge with freo this is the end of us
Pfft.
Your confidence disappeared in a hurry bro.
We are a lot more than C.Judd let me tell you.
Gunnar Longshanks
16 Sep 2007, 13:59
It looks more and more likely he is gone this season fellas.
http://realfooty.com.au/news/news/judd-turns-back-on-eagles/2007/09/15/1189277048831.htmlBut there's nothing in that article that really points to Judd leaving.
The headline doesn't match the content of the article.
But there's nothing in that article that really points to Judd leaving.
The headline doesn't match the content of the article.
Agreed G.
But, where there is smoke there is fire, I believe.