View Full Version : Random thoughts on Judd
sdb4884
16 Sep 2007, 18:20
* What are the odds of playing Judd's team in a Round 1 blockbuster at Subi?
* Is Judd the only Eagle to be traded in his deal?
* Do we give his no.3 jersey to someone next year or hold it over?
* Is this up there with the Carey 2002 incident as the most shocking moment of all time?
* When did he decide this?
:thumbsd:
SA HAWK
16 Sep 2007, 18:23
* What are the odds of playing Judd's team in a Round 1 blockbuster at Subi?
* Is Judd the only Eagle to be traded in his deal?
* Do we give his no.3 jersey to someone next year or hold it over?
* Is this up there with the Carey 2002 incident as the most shocking moment of all time?
* When did he decide this?
:thumbsd:The fact that he refused to talk about a new contract leads me to believe he has known for quite some time.
wce_all_da_way
16 Sep 2007, 18:25
He told his manager Thursday night he wanted out.
And I was thinking he would be playing us Round 1 too... :mad:
BK Eaglesfan
16 Sep 2007, 18:32
Tell you one random thought that has come to mind while I'm sitting here feeling crap......and I don't mean this at all flippantly....I am actually thankful I'm a footy fan, not a rally fan today.
Black JuJu
16 Sep 2007, 18:34
He's a weak turn coat ****.
how's that?
He's a weak turn coat ****.
how's that?
Bwuhahahaha....gold!! :thumbsu:
hawkeye23
16 Sep 2007, 18:43
#3 gets held over, for mine. It's too raw to see it next season.
Can't form opinions about anything else, my brain's gone to mush. I feel worse than I did after the 2005 GF.
imright
16 Sep 2007, 18:45
Judd now belongs in a very small club. Captains who have walked out on their clubs.
#3 gets held over, for mine. It's too raw to see it next season.
Agreed, but it will be back 2009.
Shattered as to be expected but now we must move forward. :thumbsu:
West Coast 06
16 Sep 2007, 18:47
Chris who?
It sux guys. I was hoping he would stick around. I don't like to see players like Judd move on.
Hope you blokes smash who ever he plays for next year (except if it's Collingwood;)).
larrikin
16 Sep 2007, 19:00
Get your booing voices ready
hawkeye23
16 Sep 2007, 19:01
Get your booing voices ready
We're not the Dockers. I would like to think that we have a bit more class than that.
Priddis > Judd.
Yes I am hurting leave me alone. :o
NimChief
16 Sep 2007, 19:03
* Is this up there with the Carey 2002 incident as the most shocking moment of all time?
Far from it.
Cousins incident is probably the closest.
We're not in the same class as the Dockers. I would like to think that we would throw water bottles and pies. :thumbsu:
Edited for accuracy. :cool:
arfadunger
16 Sep 2007, 19:04
Why would you hold back a player's number when that player that only gave 6 years service to a club, and then walks out.
Eagles 4 Mine
16 Sep 2007, 19:05
Priddis > Judd.
Yes I am hurting leave me alone. :o
Sorry Big man there are a lot of broken hearts around now.:thumbsd:
Sorry Big man there are a lot of broken hearts around now.:thumbsd:
Esp the nans. :(
Broken heart :o. The guy was always a poor person. Good player. Poor person. I said this a year or so ago and got throttled on this site. Turns out I was right :)
Broken heart :o. The guy was always a poor person. Good player. Poor person. I said this a year or so ago and got throttled on this site. Turns out I was right :)
He wants to go home and he's a poor person? Tyson Stenglein?
I'm feeling a mixed bag of emotion at the moment
:mad::eek::(:mad::eek::(
1) I hate Chris Judd at the moment for leaving *cough* I mean Chris you "were" our captain and have just left :(
2) I love Chris Judd because he is the best player and has done ssssooooo much for the Eagles
3) Pissed off
4) Shattered
5) I hope we don't get jipped some how and get nothing in the draft/trade time
6) It won't be the same next year without Juddy
7) on the other hand - no player is as big as the club
8) chris just wants to be near his mummy and daddy
9) thanks to the vics at our club who have stayed
10) ALL OF THE ABOVE ROLLED INTO ONE - IM GOING TO GO HIDE UNDER A ROCK NOW
wce_all_da_way
16 Sep 2007, 19:12
He wants to go home and he's a poor person? Tyson Stenglein?
Irrelevant :p
Isandula
16 Sep 2007, 19:12
Well that settles it now, Kerr is definitely the best player now :)
Jeez I agree with some people, if he werent captain I wouldnt have really cared as much....:thumbsd:
I'm feeling a mixed bag of emotion at the moment
What about your username then?
Scotland
16 Sep 2007, 19:17
Colbert, Mk II.
:mad:
Colbert, Mk II.
:mad:
And Geelong received Mooney (19 yr old), another player I cant recall, Joel Corey and James Kelly through the draft.
Its not all bad news. :thumbsu:
nearlyblonde
16 Sep 2007, 19:20
So, it`s happened, yet the sky is still up there, the sun still came up this morning and will again tomorrow.
Chris Judd is not and never has been the WCE, he is, or was, just one small part of the entire picture. Gotta say that I`m not shattered or even a little surprised cos I NEVER had the feeling that he even liked my club, let alone loved it. My most enduring image of the aftermath of the Grand Final is a huge picture of a forced semi smile from our much vaunted captain, no love there.
So, he will be off the greener pastures, fair enough we have served our purpose for him, but no tears from this brown hen.
As the song says........we shall survive.
What about your username then?
I'm obviously going to change it now to some1 who bleeds blue and gold
Im happy hes going
1) No player is worth 1 mill. If he signed on the likes of Nicoski Butler and IMO it would of unsettled the playing list
2) We get to fix a weakness
3) Priddis is a elite midfielder who can take his place.
4) Judd is a selfish individual. Bout time we weeded these types out and re established a better club culture
5) Cox becomes captain which he should of got since day 1 of Cousins giving it up
6) Fevola at Subi will kick 100
I'm obviously going to change it now to some1 who bleeds blue and gold
20Cox20
23Glass23
4Kerr4
or even....
9Cousins9.
They bleed all the way, #4 and #9 just a bit foolish. ;)
imright
16 Sep 2007, 19:29
Chris Judd is not and never has been the WCE, he is, or was, just one small part of the entire picture. Gotta say that I`m not shattered or even a little surprised cos I NEVER had the feeling that he even liked my club, let alone loved it. My most enduring image of the aftermath of the Grand Final is a huge picture of a forced semi smile from our much vaunted captain, no love there.
Yes in hindsight he never seemed to show any feeling for the club. Like you said he didn't even look happy lifting up the premiership cup after a 1 point win in a Grand final, FFS.
I always put it down to putting on his professional face but I think the reality is that either he is a perpetual sad sack or he just didn't appreciate playing for West Coast.
20Cox20
23Glass23
4Kerr4
or even....
9Cousins9.
They bleed all the way, #4 and #9 just a bit foolish. ;)
Yeah exactly - #4 and #9 are a bit silly at times but they would do anything for our great club.
I think as Kerry is my sponsored player for 07 - ill go with him
Milkman
16 Sep 2007, 19:31
Chris who?
You know, the bloke who used to be able to run.
You know, the bloke who used to be able to run.
"Not anymore"
:D
Milkman
16 Sep 2007, 19:34
"Not anymore"
:D
:D:thumbsu:
Eagles 4 Mine
16 Sep 2007, 19:37
So, it`s happened, yet the sky is still up there, the sun still came up this morning and will again tomorrow.
Chris Judd is not and never has been the WCE, he is, or was, just one small part of the entire picture. Gotta say that I`m not shattered or even a little surprised cos I NEVER had the feeling that he even liked my club, let alone loved it. My most enduring image of the aftermath of the Grand Final is a huge picture of a forced semi smile from our much vaunted captain, no love there.
So, he will be off the greener pastures, fair enough we have served our purpose for him, but no tears from this brown hen.
As the song says........we shall survive.
Totally true there nearlyblonde when you look back that should have been his proudest moment but that picture doesn't show that.:thumbsd:
**** Judd we have the Colossus!! :thumbsu:
wce_all_da_way
16 Sep 2007, 19:38
"Not anymore"
:D
Gold! :D
Jeez I agree with some people, if he werent captain I wouldnt have really cared as much....:thumbsd:
My thoughts exactly. If he wasn't the captain, I wouldn't be feeling like I do. Betrayed basically...
mudgeathon
16 Sep 2007, 19:50
I would have been more pissed if Cousins, Kerr, Cox or Glass wanted to leave - they blead west coast
However there are a number of positives to come out of this
Hurn, Butler, Priddis will all get more gametime and more importantly 'on the ball' game time
Whatever club takes him, will have to give us something very good in return
Carlton = Fevola + pick 3
Melbourne = TJ + pick 4 or Brock Mclean + pick 4
Richmond = Pick 2 + who ever we want
*these are just suggestions
By getting a high draft pick , we can get one of Palmer or Morton [who won't ditch our club] + we get a bloody good player/s
We'll come out of this very well
Scotland
16 Sep 2007, 19:53
The nickname Judas/Juddas is about to become very popular I reckon.