View Full Version : Please dont let it be Carlton.
If Judd chooses to go to Carlton, then we might find our position a little harder to get what twe want. Carlton will only offer us pick 1 for Judd and nothing else. They are in the box seat. If Judd goes into the draft he will get picked up by Carlton with Pick 1 so no need for them to offer us anything else.
Any other club but Carlton.
94_Eagles
16 Sep 2007, 18:24
Carlton has Fevloa.
We want Fevola.
whippersnipper
16 Sep 2007, 18:26
Carlton has Fevloa.
We want Fevola.
So you are saying we dont have what you want?
:D
Carlton has Fevloa.
We want Fevola.
They dont need to offer Fev. Thats my point. They still have pick 3 and Pick 1 is all it will cost regardless if its via trade or via draft.
French Tiger
16 Sep 2007, 18:27
If Judd chooses to go to Carlton, then we might find our position a little harder to get what twe want. Carlton will only offer us pick 1 for Judd and nothing else. They are in the box seat. If Judd goes into the draft he will get picked up by Carlton with Pick 1 so no need for them to offer is anything else.
Any other club but Carlton.
I agree please not the Blues! But we actually have the no 1 pick in the psd.The only way he would go into the national draft where the Blues have the 1st pick,is if the Eagles delisted him.
wavefall21
16 Sep 2007, 18:47
If Judd chooses to go to Carlton, then we might find our position a little harder to get what twe want. Carlton will only offer us pick 1 for Judd and nothing else. They are in the box seat. If Judd goes into the draft he will get picked up by Carlton with Pick 1 so no need for them to offer us anything else.
Any other club but Carlton.
You'd be crazy not to do a trade with the blues, they have frigan 3 picks in the top 20 and and a few handy young players there......who else would u get that off?
Mr Eagle
16 Sep 2007, 18:48
So you are saying we dont have what you want?
:D
Maybe we could negotiate a name change ;)
cats2rise
16 Sep 2007, 20:42
The only reason why I want Judd to go to Carlton is that I want Carlton to still be shit with him so all their hopes of one player fixing that rable will be dashed.
sticks74
16 Sep 2007, 20:47
The only reason why I want Judd to go to Carlton is that I want Carlton to still be shit with him so all their hopes of one player fixing that rable will be dashed.
Enjoy your usual choke next week cats2rise...
I thought Carlton said Fev was a wanted player next year?
Doesn't seem like they are gonna let him go.
94_Eagles
16 Sep 2007, 20:49
The only reason why I want Judd to go to Carlton is that I want Carlton to still be shit with him so all their hopes of one player fixing that rable will be dashed.
Judd will easily singlehandedly make them top 8 material.
94_Eagles
16 Sep 2007, 20:50
I thought Carlton said Fev was a wanted player next year?
Doesn't seem like they are gonna let him go.
I think Judd on the market changes things just a little.
cats2rise
16 Sep 2007, 20:56
Judd will easily singlehandedly make them top 8 material.
If he went to Carlton, you would have to think that Fev would be part of the trade.
So in reality, Judd can get the ball all he wants but will have no decent forwards to kick it to.
West Coast 06
16 Sep 2007, 20:57
Judd will easily singlehandedly make them top 8 material.
Not a chance! Nick Stevens certainly hasn't. They might win a pre-season cup but the Top 8 is years away for the blues!
cats2rise
16 Sep 2007, 20:57
Enjoy your usual choke next week cats2rise...
Enjoy being shit next year.
94_Eagles
16 Sep 2007, 20:58
If he went to Carlton, you would have to think that Fev would be part of the trade.
So in reality, Judd can get the ball all he wants but will have no decent forwards to kick it to.
Do Carlton have the first pick in the PSD?
GreekLunatic
16 Sep 2007, 21:32
Nope Richmond do they finished last