PDA

View Full Version : Tim Callan

Bulldog Banana
2 Oct 2007, 20:11
Simple one guys, do you want Tim Callan or not.
bulldogtragic
2 Oct 2007, 20:16
PSD or 4th rounder.
Butane
2 Oct 2007, 20:21
I voted yes for a 4th rounder or PSD
DOG GOD
2 Oct 2007, 20:23
psd.
doggiesin08
2 Oct 2007, 20:24
3rd round. this guys a top player. would love him him at our club. Wouldn't give 2nd rounder only because we finished down the bottom.
acker
2 Oct 2007, 20:51
4th rounder or PSD.
Sorry a VFL B&F after a fair while on the senior list with 15 games to show for it does not suggest he is a top player to me.
lifelike_
2 Oct 2007, 20:53
Another vote for a 4th rounder.
borgy
2 Oct 2007, 21:29
4th rounder or PSD.
Sorry a VFL B&F after a fair while on the senior list with 15 games to show for it does not suggest he is a top player to me.
Prismall is a top player and cant crack the star studded Geelong midfield. I think the same applies here.

4th rounder or PSD.

He would be better than anything we draft 3rd round + in 2008.
doggiesin08
2 Oct 2007, 21:32
4th rounder last year but this years draft is MUCH weaker apparently.
vc_viking
2 Oct 2007, 21:37
Tim Callan won the Geelong VFL Best and Fairest and 2nd and ranked high in the VFL MVP or whatever u call it (mind has gone blank)
borgy
2 Oct 2007, 21:47
Tim Callan won the Geelong VFL Best and Fairest and 2nd and ranked high in the VFL MVP or whatever u call it (mind has gone blank)
Liston medal?
SCRAY72
2 Oct 2007, 21:48
4th rounder.
vc_viking
2 Oct 2007, 21:50
Liston medal?
yeah Highly ranked in there as far as I know, I got to double check it though, he's a bloody good player, coming back from injury in 07 ...he's highly ranked..
borgy
2 Oct 2007, 22:04
yeah Highly ranked in there as far as I know, I got to double check it though, he's a bloody good player, coming back from injury in 07 ...he's highly ranked..
You've sold me. All aboard the Callan train:thumbsu:
ErnieSigley
2 Oct 2007, 22:05
No simple yes or no to this question. At the right price is my answer.
bradism
2 Oct 2007, 22:15
Don't know enough about him to vote. Hope others feel the same.
Bulldog Banana
2 Oct 2007, 22:37
No simple yes or no to this question. At the right price is my answer.

Agree Ernie, should have been more specific.
Wouldnt want to give up too much for him, but he would be handy.
acker
2 Oct 2007, 22:51
yeah Highly ranked in there as far as I know, I got to double check it though, he's a bloody good player, coming back from injury in 07 ...he's highly ranked..

Tough call a Geelong supporter with no #uc^in% morals in a another thread offered Tom Lonergan the guy who lost his kidney late last year and got picked up on a special "AFL" rookie draft this year. Lonergan got BOG in the VFL Grand Final.
If that trade is (i dream) on I would take him over Callan.
He would provide an inspirational acquisition.