Here Come Carnegie

[motorvinnie]

carnegie is making a comeback in the eastern football league! carnegie as a community has gathered a senior team together involving some big name players.. sam beckham from pines, reegan stubbs from pines, tim fleming from old hailebury, simon goosey from dromana, oliver trand from seaford, bevan malloy from karingal, anthony lewis from chelsea are the big names that carnegie are going to have to participat in EFL. fantastic news that the demons will be back! carn the demons

[MELTY]

how will the demons be able to afford these players? They are all pretty handy players especially goosey, who is a state known player!!

[motorvinnie]

how will the demons be able to afford these players? They are all pretty handy players especially goosey, who is a state known player!!

MELTY, carnegie have been given a government grant which allows them to play footy on the old springvale VFL ground.. it is used for recreational purposes but has been granted to carnegie football club. they're jumpers wont be the same. that is till to be announced.. we believe carnegie football club will be competitive in division 2 EFL. great list of players with 1 massive recruit yet to come.

WE ARE LOOKING:

FOR A KPP PLAYER THAT CAN HOLD DOWN FULL BACK

DECENT $$ WILL APPLY IF YOUR SUITED TO THE POSITION

THANKS

[MELTY]

really carnegie r playing on the old springy ground! suprises me, are you sure your facts r correct?

[motorvinnie]

really carnegie r playing on the old springy ground! suprises me, are you sure your facts r correct?

yes melty as stated before!

if anyone wans to know more contact me:

(03) 9786-2851

thanks

[MELTY]

uncalled for mate

[motorvinnie]

uncalled for mate

melty

carnegie will be a good club and strong clb again

[PINNACLE HEALTH]

Bevon Malloy is coaching Mornington, Simon Goosey is nearly 40 and is not upto 2nd divy, Oliver Trand won't leave Seaford.

Mate i think your jumping the gun a bit here, people from the Mornington Peninsular would laugh at the names you've thrown up here.

[motorvinnie]

Bevon Malloy is coaching Mornington, Simon Goosey is nearly 40 and is not upto 2nd divy, Oliver Trand won't leave Seaford.

Mate i think your jumping the gun a bit here, people from the Mornington Peninsular would laugh at the names you've thrown up here.

jason mathers is going to coach mornington you moron.. and goosey is upto dvision 2 footy, as shown this year in neapean division. mpnfl is better standard then EFL anyway but this will go alright for carnegie as we are rebuilding. Oliver Trand is actually moving to london as told by him last night so he wont be apart of carnegie fc next year. We have 1 big name recruit left ill tell you at a later date!

[Can Opener]

why would tim flemming and anthony lewis play for carnegie??

[Valley Spy]

Why would the EFL allow a recessed club into 2nd division? There is no chance of this happeneing for 2008 season.

[tucker]

Are you sure it is in the EFL not the SFL, I am involed at 2nd div club in the EFL have not been told this, Carngie to come into our league would go up for a vote to all clubs in the in the league, this has not been done they would not start in div 2 as that would mean a bye clubs wouldnt vote for that, the standard of 2nd div higher then mpnfl they would need to field 2nds and u18, if they did come in they would start in 4div, south belgrave has been accepted for next season in div4 needs approval from Football Vic
jason mathers is going to coach mornington you moron.. and goosey is upto dvision 2 footy, as shown this year in neapean division. mpnfl is better standard then EFL anyway but this will go alright for carnegie as we are rebuilding. Oliver Trand is actually moving to london as told by him last night so he wont be apart of carnegie fc next year. We have 1 big name recruit left ill tell you at a later date!

[nick_savo]

im playing div4 colts nxt year, will south belgrave be playing in that?

[Blue Tongue]

South Belgrave are expecting to field teams in Seniors, Reserves & Colts next year as per EFL web site

[Conduct Unbecoming]

carnegie is making a comeback in the eastern football league! carnegie as a community has gathered a senior team together involving some big name players.. sam beckham from pines, reegan stubbs from pines, tim fleming from old hailebury, simon goosey from dromana, oliver trand from seaford, bevan malloy from karingal, anthony lewis from chelsea are the big names that carnegie are going to have to participat in EFL. fantastic news that the demons will be back! carn the demons


One Question Motorvinnie - on the 9th Oct you post here that Sam Beckham is to play at Carnegie. On the same day you also post that he has agreed to play with Parkside on the Western Region League thread.

Which one is it?;)

[Slug]

I think someone is having a leand of you. Carnegie will not be admited to the EFL for a few reasons.

All divisions now have even amount of teams in them and they wont want to change that.
It would have to go to a vote by member clubs. It hasn't and wont be.
AFL Vic knocked back Heidelberg with one of the reasons being the locatian. Carnegie is nowhere near any other club
Motorvinnie, you mentioned that MPNFL is a better standard than EFL. Mate you are off your dial. I have played in a few different comps around Vic and for a local comp EFL 1st div would be the strongest by far.

[Bright Boy]

I think someone is having a leand of you. Carnegie will not be admited to the EFL for a few reasons.

All divisions now have even amount of teams in them and they wont want to change that.
It would have to go to a vote by member clubs. It hasn't and wont be.
AFL Vic knocked back Heidelberg with one of the reasons being the locatian. Carnegie is nowhere near any other clubMotorvinnie, you mentioned that MPNFL is a better standard than EFL. Mate you are off your dial. I have played in a few different comps around Vic and for a local comp EFL 1st div would be the strongest by far.


1. AFL
2. VFL
3. EFL

I put the EFL above the O&M, GV, SFL & DVFL

[Cockle doodle doo]

1. AFL
2. VFL
3. EFL

I put the EFL above the O&M, GV, SFL & DVFL

I agree. i play and more importantly watch more local and country footy than most becuase of my job and i would say undoubtedly that the EFL is the best standard of football outside VFL, SANFL and WAFL. It is the stand out competition in most areas like depth, professionalism, gate receipts and wider community involvement. having said that, you could throw a blanket over the next tier which would be the GFL, VAFA a section, O&M FL, GVFL. not far behind would be the MPNFL, NFL, EDFL & WRFL.

[facemaker]

jason mathers is going to coach mornington you moron.. and goosey is upto dvision 2 footy, as shown this year in neapean division. mpnfl is better standard then EFL anyway but this will go alright for carnegie as we are rebuilding. Oliver Trand is actually moving to london as told by him last night so he wont be apart of carnegie fc next year. We have 1 big name recruit left ill tell you at a later date!

Lol. A mpnfl side would struggle to compete against a 4th divvy EFL side you fool. Carnegie! Spare me.

[hotpies123]

Carnegie the same team that folded after steve Thompson left as president