View Full Version : Boyle for Schneider?
The Cryptkeeper
10 Oct 2007, 11:15
Yes or No?
This idea was put forward by another poster (lickmerocks) and I think it has merit. Boyle may become more of a depth player for us over the next couple of seasons as Thorp and Dowler develop. Sydney are more than likely looking for a big forward to share the load with Hall and Schneider is mooted to be on the table for discussion. He is a quality crumbing forward/midfielder and fits the age criteria and type of player we need.
Hawks1523
10 Oct 2007, 11:16
Show me where to sign. :eek:
How about we keep Boyle and offer our 2nd RD pick.
I rate Schneider and I agree that he could be a great benefit to our team.
I wouldn't accept that trade though due to the fact that a competent 6'4"+ KPP player has historically been worth far more than a "crumbing forward/midfielder" who shows a lot of potential but hasn't performed to an "A" grade standard.
A trade involving Boyle for Schneider and picks though would be very tempting.
I rate Schneider and I agree that he could be a great benefit to our team.
I wouldn't accept that trade though due to the fact that a competent 6'4"+ KPP player has historically been worth far more than a "crumbing forward/midfielder" who shows a lot of potential but hasn't performed to an "A" grade standard.
A trade involving Boyle for Schneider and picks though would be very tempting.
Yes agreed. But tehy (Sydney) know what we ave and what we need and visa versa so it's all in the deal.
lickmerocks
10 Oct 2007, 11:48
I rate Schneider and I agree that he could be a great benefit to our team.
I wouldn't accept that trade though due to the fact that a competent 6'4"+ KPP player has historically been worth far more than a "crumbing forward/midfielder" who shows a lot of potential but hasn't performed to an "A" grade standard.
A trade involving Boyle for Schneider and picks though would be very tempting.
Mick, Forget currency etc in regards to Key positon vs smalls as we have a plethora of talls and we need to address our current needs that will help us win a premiership.
Pelchin has stated that Morton, Thorp, and Dowler are almost all ready to start playing consistently. If Williams Roughead or Franklin gets an injury we have some back up depth.
Lets say all are fit (fingers crossed) Boyle would not be in my starting line-up so lets move why we are in a positon to do it.