View Full Version : What about Brennan?
Ancient Tiger
12 Oct 2007, 00:09
How hard should we try to get this guy if he is available and willing? Seems to be a prodigious talent but very inconsistent. He is a freak but if Matthews can't get the best out of him, I doubt that we can...
tony_montana
12 Oct 2007, 00:37
we should do everything we can to try and nail this guy as the number 1 pick in the PSD
RockJobster0312
12 Oct 2007, 00:42
I'd rather not pick him up with the number 1 pick in the PSD, surely there would be some other players ahead of him in the consistency department.
At the end of the day, the Tigers finished last. Dead last. They were the worst team in the AFL. This is one of the little gifts the AFL world gives us for failing miserable, and I don't understand why we should use that gift on a player whom firstly doesn't have a solidified position on the ground as of yet, and secondly who is inconsistent. Surely you'd want to pick up a guy who can improve your list from day 1, and do it 22+ times in 22+ games. Not a guy who may or may not improve your list, and may only decide to play like an AFL player for a third of the games in a season. Give me someone who can contribute.
tony_montana
12 Oct 2007, 00:47
he is an immensely talented player
freak
would be silly not to pick up a player of such prodigious talent if he were available for FREE!!!
he would contribute from day 1 absolutely, id put him ahead of a lot of the boys on our list
RockJobster0312
12 Oct 2007, 00:49
So would I, but my point is that there should be (hopefully), a better, more consistent, more skillful player coming into the PSD which fits a greater need, and that is more worthwhile of the number 1 pick.
we cant afford to get the number 1 pick in the psd wrong
polakthetiger
12 Oct 2007, 01:25
Earth to that place where reality has been lost. It is the PSD...who do imagine will be there for the much prized No1 pick? You can be fairly sure players of his class will not be there. Unless he told Leigh he was an over the hill hack who had lost the plot.
Lets look back a few years..Ackland, McLaren, Knobel, Rawlings, Powell
I see a trend!
tony_montana
12 Oct 2007, 01:29
exactly polak which is why we should be dining and serenading him for all we're worth, get in his ear now and get him to commit
polakthetiger
12 Oct 2007, 01:34
Would love to see it TM! As 'inconsistant' as people have posted, the guy has got some skills:thumbsu:
Interesting in that other thread claiming the Bummers are trying to get him in the PSD..yeah ..likely to happen....not!
Realistic Tiger
12 Oct 2007, 03:22
Would love to see it TM! As 'inconsistant' as people have posted, the guy has got some skills:thumbsu:
Interesting in that other thread claiming the Bummers are trying to get him in the PSD..yeah ..likely to happen....not!
Hopefully the Bummers do all the work to get him in the PSD and then we come waltzing in with pick 1 and say J. Brennan thank you very much. Might be a prick of a thing to do but stuff it why not screw another club over for once.
Brennan? Yes please. X-factor.
Darth_Tiger
12 Oct 2007, 13:41
get him get him get him get him.
AT 2008
12 Oct 2007, 13:43
show him the money tigers!!!
money money money - give it to him !!!
if we could have afforded a massive price to get judd in the file:///C:/DOCUME%7E1/ADMINI%7E1/LOCALS%7E1/Temp/moz-screenshot.jpgPSD - like u jest 0 surely we can lure this bloke with the bags with the $ to the club in the PSD:thumbsu: