View Full Version : Who is the best in the draft at?
Schmick
22 Oct 2007, 01:27
Saw something similar last year and thought it'd be good to see the results this year.
Who are the best players in this years national draft at the following skills?
1) Kicking in play (stab pass)
2) Kicking for goal (set shot)
3) Handballing in traffic
4) Tackling
5) Marking overhead
6) Getting center clerances
vinnie_vegas69
22 Oct 2007, 09:09
1) Kicking in play (stab pass) Cale Morton
2) Kicking for goal (set shot) Addam Maric (small), Dave Gourdis (tall)
3) Handballing in traffic Sam Reid
4) Tackling Brad Gilder
5) Marking overhead Ben McEvoy, Scott Simpson
6) Getting center clerances Chris Masten, Craig Bird
Saw something similar last year and thought it'd be good to see the results this year.
Who are the best players in this years national draft at the following skills?
1) Kicking in play (stab pass) trent cotchin
2) Kicking for goal (set shot) addam maric
3) Handballing in traffic- luke potts
4) Tackling- cyril rioli or chris masten
5) Marking overhead- scott simpson
6) Getting center clerances- rhys palmer- trent cotchin
sinepari
23 Oct 2007, 20:37
- rhys palmer- trent cotchin
??:confused:
joefootylover
24 Oct 2007, 11:11
what skills are cothin and palmer the best in the draft at nevil?
Vic Crow
24 Oct 2007, 11:25
Looks like centre clearances. If you look at the bit that he quoted he actually answered all the questions in the quote tags except for the last one.
bigfella7
26 Oct 2007, 23:58
simpson is certainly not the best overhead mark in the draft. dropped alot of sitas.i could mention 2 or 3 of his team mates that are better. gabriel,boumann,grant.
Gavin Craig
27 Oct 2007, 14:54
1) Kicking in play (stab pass) Cale Morton
2) Kicking for goal (set shot) Addam Maric (small), Dave Gourdis (tall)
3) Handballing in traffic Sam Reid
4) Tackling Brad Gilder
5) Marking overhead Ben McEvoy, Scott Simpson
6) Getting center clerances Chris Masten, Craig Bird
Actually Gourdis' kicking accuracy would definitely be his weakest point, snagged a couple of good'uns in the champs if thats what you're basing it on, but there would be a shitload of kids with better kicks. Cale Morton's kicking is pretty faultless from what i've seen.
vinnie_vegas69
27 Oct 2007, 15:35
Actually Gourdis' kicking accuracy would definitely be his weakest point, snagged a couple of good'uns in the champs if thats what you're basing it on, but there would be a shitload of kids with better kicks.
Yeah, I haven't seen a whole heap of Gourdis, but I'd generally heard that his set shot kicking was pretty good.
I know that in particular, some of the other KPs tend to struggle with their set-shot kicking, and seeing as what I'd seen of Gourdis was good, and what I'd heard was good, I had placed him in that category.
I suppose I'll have to give the "tall" accuracy award to Ben McEvoy, in that case.