View Full Version : bringbackschwarter5's Phantom Draft first round
bringbackschwarter5
26 Oct 2007, 00:15
Only going with the first round so far
Pick 1: Carlton - Matthew Kreuzer (ruck)
Pick 2: Richmond - Trent Cotchin (Mid/HFF)
Pick 3: West Coast - Cale Morton (Utility)
Pick 4: Melbourne - Alex Rance (KPD)
Pick 5: Bulldogs - Lachie Henderson (KPF)
Pick 6: Essendon - Chris Masten (Mid)
Pick 7: Fremantle - Brad Ebert (Utility)
Pick 8: Brisbane - David Myers (Utility)
Pick 9: StKilda - Ben McEvoy (Ruck)
Pick 10: Adelaide - Rhys Palmer (Mid)
Pick 11: Sydney - Tom Collier (KPD)
Pick 12: Hawthorn - Pat Veszpremi (Mid)
Pick 13: West Coast - Cyril Rioli (Mid)
Pick 14: Melbourne - Dave Gourdis (KPF)
Pick 15: Kangaroos - Tayte Pears (KPD)
Pick 16: Port Adelaide - Scott Simpson (KPF)
Pick 17: Geelong - Jack Grimes (Mid)
Pick 18: Richmond - Levi Greenwood (Mid)
Looking back it is loaded up on Key position players
Rioli the slider can see him going even further down.
Feel free to help fix any of my mistakes
SS_Fury
26 Oct 2007, 00:22
myers and rance a touch too high...no selwood on the radar?
Eagles wont take morton...
morton>tigers
cotchin<eagles
or masten>eagles
doh its me
26 Oct 2007, 00:33
Why does everyone have the Tigers taking Morton ?
Does anyone think there is anything to the rumour/theory that Mitch Morton was traded cheaply to the Tigers in a deal that saw them agree to pass on Cotchin (this was put to Miller and he denied it)
goodie23
26 Oct 2007, 00:43
Why does everyone have the Tigers taking Morton ?
Does anyone think there is anything to the rumour/theory that Mitch Morton was traded cheaply to the Tigers in a deal that saw them agree to pass on Cotchin (this was put to Miller and he denied it)
Well he's hardly going to say 'Yes, we did it! We made a deal which I'm stupidly going to confess to. We've been very naughty boys, please take our draft picks away from us, we deserve to be punished.'
Stripes666
26 Oct 2007, 00:45
Why does everyone have the Tigers taking Morton ?
Does anyone think there is anything to the rumour/theory that Mitch Morton was traded cheaply to the Tigers in a deal that saw them agree to pass on Cotchin (this was put to Miller and he denied it)
1. he makes sense in terms of Wallaces game plan and who we need
2. Miller has praised him highly, more so than Cotchin
3. Brothers coiuld work well together
Tommyneu
26 Oct 2007, 00:51
Ha, Schwarter...I know how keen you are on Rance, but 4 is simply too high. He won't get through to 14 so I think that pretty much rules him out for us. Palmer before 10 for sure as well. Myers and Pears a tad high.
Porthos
26 Oct 2007, 00:51
1. he makes sense in terms of Wallaces game plan and who we need
2. Miller has praised him highly, more so than Cotchin
3. Brothers coiuld work well togetherAlso, three sets of brothers played in the 2007 grand final.
Not the most logical or relevant reason, but we are talking about Richmond ;)
DCFCFAN84
26 Oct 2007, 00:57
Pick 10: Adelaide - Rhys Palmer (Mid)
Palmer wont slide that far.
vinnie_vegas69
26 Oct 2007, 08:28
How you can have that many talls in there and no Jarrod Grant astonishes me.
IddyBiddy
26 Oct 2007, 10:32
Freo won't be taking Ebert if Palmer is there.
skybeau
26 Oct 2007, 10:49
Also, three sets of brothers played in the 2007 grand final.
Not the most logical or relevant reason, but we are talking about Richmond ;)
Didn't two of those sets of brothers get their asses kicked in the 2007 Grand Final? Even them being BOG for their side didn't help...
Australia
26 Oct 2007, 11:05
I actually believe the top 5 will look like this:
1. Carlton - Kruezer
2. Richmond - Morton
3. West Coast Cotchin
4. Melbourne - Palmer
5. Western Bulldogs - Henderson
scooter600x
26 Oct 2007, 11:19
How you can have that many talls in there and no Jarrod Grant astonishes me.
So that the Dogs could take him @ 19?
sydney eagle
26 Oct 2007, 11:36
I actually believe the top 5 will look like this:
1. Carlton - Kruezer
2. Richmond - Morton
3. West Coast Cotchin
4. Melbourne - Palmer
5. Western Bulldogs - Henderson I too think that the Eagles will go for another midfielder (Cotchin, Masten or Palmer) ahead of Morton.
If Cotchin isn't available, i still think the Eagles will take Morton. Has far more potential that either of Masten or Palmer. But if not Morton, then Palmer all the way!
WC will definately take Masten if Cotchin isnt available. They WONT be taking Morton. Not at all.
If we take Cotchin at 2, we won't take another mid at 18.