View Full Version : Phantom Draft Semi Final 2
Bluebear
14 Nov 2007, 16:00
So who would win through to a GF?
Team C
FB: Max Rooke - Daniel Merrett - Joel Patfull
HB: Heath Shaw - Tyson Goldsack - Josh Drummond
C: Scott Pendlebury - Matt Priddis - Grant Birchall
HF: Beau Waters - Michael Newton - Adam Schneider
FF: Sean Rusling - Justin Koschitzke - Justin Westhoff
R: Brendon Lade - Nick Dal Santo - Nigel Lappin
INT: Damien Peverill - Clint Bartram - Ricky Petterd - Ben Reid
vs
Team D
B: Mark McVeigh, Matthew Scarlett, Stephen Gilham
HB: Heath Scotland, Sam Fisher, Shannon Hurn
C: Corey Enright, Brett Kirk, Chance Bateman
HF: James Kelly, Jarrad Waite, Bryce Gibbs
F: Tim Boyle, Brendan Fevola, Alwyn Davey
Foll: Mark Seaby, Daniel Cross, Tyson Edwards
I: Cameron Wood, Shane O'Bree, Shannon Watt, Mitch Clark
Phantom Draft Semi Final 1 (http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=396075)
Bluebear
14 Nov 2007, 16:02
Team D for me.
Two good rucks vs no back up ruck with C (C should never have got this far :()
Fev, Scarlett, Kelly and Cross.............will be hard to beat IMO.
TorresIsGod
14 Nov 2007, 16:14
In my opinion, Team C would smash Team D
Who does Team C belong too? What a list of kids, they'd dominate all
Blue Dimension
14 Nov 2007, 16:31
This is by far the toughest of the lot so far.
Team D probably for me. Superior backline.
walkers a legend
14 Nov 2007, 16:35
team d
Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite
14 Nov 2007, 16:36
Team D - is the best team out of everybody i rkn. will get my g/f vote if they make it
CarltonFan
14 Nov 2007, 19:53
Could eveyone stop sending me pm's regarding who i think will win.
Anyway, CarltonFan's tip is....... Team D.
whippersnipper
14 Nov 2007, 20:39
Team D. Again, Fevola and Scarlett get them over the line.
BlueDevil
14 Nov 2007, 20:52
team d for me. good spine.
So who would win through to a GF?
Team C
FB: Max Rooke - Daniel Merrett - Joel Patfull
HB: Heath Shaw - Tyson Goldsack - Josh Drummond
C: Scott Pendlebury - Matt Priddis - Grant Birchall
HF: Beau Waters - Michael Newton - Adam Schneider
FF: Sean Rusling - Justin Koschitzke - Justin Westhoff
R: Brendon Lade - Nick Dal Santo - Nigel Lappin
INT: Damien Peverill - Clint Bartram - Ricky Petterd - Ben Reid
vs
Team D
B: Mark McVeigh, Matthew Scarlett, Stephen Gilham
HB: Heath Scotland, Sam Fisher, Shannon Hurn
C: Corey Enright, Brett Kirk, Chance Bateman
HF: James Kelly, Jarrad Waite, Bryce Gibbs
F: Tim Boyle, Brendan Fevola, Alwyn Davey
Foll: Mark Seaby, Daniel Cross, Tyson Edwards
I: Cameron Wood, Shane O'Bree, Shannon Watt, Mitch Clark
Phantom Draft Semi Final 1 (http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=396075)
where do you get the time for this? or do you work for the government?
:)
and team C for me.
only because team D went in cocky and had a horrible 1st half...
bluegal1983
15 Nov 2007, 07:55
Team D - is the best team out of everybody i rkn. will get my g/f vote if they make it
Now that's what I call loyalty!
Cheers :thumbsu:
Bluebear
15 Nov 2007, 08:10
where do you get the time for this? or do you work for the government?
:)
I do work unusual hours and have some mornings and afternoons free, buit other days I work 8am - 8pm........not that it's relevant...........it took 5 minutes to cut and paste these teams and post the thread.
You have maybe missed the fact that the teams were created in a phantom draft run on this board through the latter part of the season.
I am simply posting the teams with a poll to see who people think would win.:thumbsu:
TorresIsGod
15 Nov 2007, 11:38
That Team C is a gun side, it would murder Team D
Bluebear
15 Nov 2007, 11:40
That Team C is a gun side, it would murder Team D
I want an inquiry into the voting on the quarter final............team C should never have got this far. This result is more evidence of the sham.:p
bluegal1983
15 Nov 2007, 12:16
That Team C is a gun side, it would murder Team D
Doubt it. Team D is much stronger across all lines :D
TorresIsGod
15 Nov 2007, 13:17
Just out of curiosity BG, don't you think it's a bit silly advertising above your avatar? If people want to vote, they'll vote for the best team? After all, it is a game...
Also, I have no idea how I got past the quarter finals, although my team is the best, I'm surprised I even beat my brother in the first round
bluegal1983
15 Nov 2007, 15:33
Should have made the voting viewable BB.
It's a bit suss IMO.
Should have made the voting viewable BB.
It's a bit suss IMO.
Why's that BG?
Are you saying the integrity of the voting here his flawed, or you just don't like it this close?
bluegal1983
15 Nov 2007, 15:40
Why's that BG?
Are you saying the integrity of the voting here his flawed, or you just don't like it this close?
The closer the better.
But I agree with BB - Team C should never have gotten this far and I would love to see who has voted :thumbsu:
Jezza U Beauty
15 Nov 2007, 16:51
Team D would win this easily. Easily.
Bluebear
15 Nov 2007, 16:57
The closer the better.
But I agree with BB - Team C should never have gotten this far and I would love to see who has voted :thumbsu:
I didn't want it to seem like sour grapes BG, but now that you mention it, the team in question is a joke and democracy has failed - I should have had a veto.:D
Tarkyn_24
15 Nov 2007, 17:58
Team C. The young guns easily outshine the decidedly unbalanced Team D. Shaw and Pendlebury are a massive combo, I do understand the bias against them; but to let the two go to the same team?
Admittedly, D has a better spine. For now.
TorresIsGod
15 Nov 2007, 20:22
Should have made the voting viewable BB.
It's a bit suss IMO.
Of course it is, because you're not winning :rolleyes:
bluegal1983
16 Nov 2007, 12:01
Team D > Team C despite what the poll says.
It's funny how the majority of people who have actually posted in this thread have given Team D the thumbs up yet the poll reflects the opposite.
I would love to know who has voted for Team C.... REVEAL YOURSELF!
bexta444
16 Nov 2007, 17:10
So who would win through to a GF?
Team D, no question.
TorresIsGod
17 Nov 2007, 22:02
Yeah Team D is so much better than Team C it's not funny.
I cannot believe that Team C is winning this poll
What a joke. There's absolutely no way Team C would get within 10 goals Team D, let alone win this poll easily and get to the granny ahead of other much better teams.
I also like the way there's 69 votes in this semi and just 26 in the other, gimme a break.
Djibril however you've done it, i don't know, but to rort this whole game like that is just lame. Clever - but lame.
Bluebear
22 Nov 2007, 16:50
What a joke. There's absolutely no way Team C would get within 10 goals Team D, let alone win this poll easily and get to the granny ahead of other much better teams.
I also like the way there's 69 votes in this semi and just 26 in the other, gimme a break.
Djibril however you've done it, i don't know, but to rort this whole game like that is just lame. Clever - but lame.
Same thing happened in the quarter finals........DC's team made a late charge whwen they were being spanked early.
A public poll for the granny.:thumbsu:
Will put the GF up after the stewards enquiry into the votes and we get the all clear.;)
TorresIsGod
22 Nov 2007, 21:19
I did nothing, if people voted for me, they voted for me? Good on them?
So, because I won, it's being treated like I cheated, yet, BG puts 'vote Team D, Semi Final 2' above her avatar, and there's nothing wrong with that?
Why change the rules to a public vote for the Grand Final when it hasn't been like that for the whole competition? Changing the rules because you haven't liked the outcome of some of the games? Pretty petty in my opinion..
But hey, I have nothing to hide, if you want a Public Poll, go ahead, people will still vote for me, because I have a team full of young guns
So, because I won, it's being treated like I cheated, yet, BG puts 'vote Team D, Semi Final 2' above her avatar, and there's nothing wrong with that?
lol, no difference to these, but hey there's nothing to say you can't talk up your own teams.
In my opinion, Team C would smash Team D
Who does Team C belong too? What a list of kids, they'd dominate all
That Team C is a gun side, it would murder Team D
bluegal1983
23 Nov 2007, 12:01
It's all good people. If DC has to cheat to win, then is he really winning? I THINK NOT!!
Everybody who has OPENLY voted and actually posted a comment in the thread all know which was the better side... funny that none of DC's fan club did this :rolleyes:
one_twelve112
23 Nov 2007, 12:13
Team D easily. Fevola alone would destroy the Team C backline. The poll does not seem to be reflecting th opinion of most posts in this thread. It seems a little suss to me.
bluegal1983
23 Nov 2007, 12:21
And yet another vote to team D - WOW!!
Tally from what people actually typed into the thread.
Team C - 3
Team D - 13
one_twelve112
23 Nov 2007, 12:31
And yet another vote to team D - WOW!!
Tally from what people actually typed into the thread.
Team C - 3
Team D - 13
Perhaps we need to get someone from Internal Affairs down here....sounds like an inside job to me.
Bluebear
23 Nov 2007, 12:40
I did nothing, if people voted for me, they voted for me? Good on them?
So, because I won, it's being treated like I cheated, yet, BG puts 'vote Team D, Semi Final 2' above her avatar, and there's nothing wrong with that?
Why change the rules to a public vote for the Grand Final when it hasn't been like that for the whole competition? Changing the rules because you haven't liked the outcome of some of the games? Pretty petty in my opinion..
But hey, I have nothing to hide, if you want a Public Poll, go ahead, people will still vote for me, because I have a team full of young guns
Because I can.:thumbsu:
bluegal1983
23 Nov 2007, 12:54
Perhaps we need to get someone from Internal Affairs down here....sounds like an inside job to me.
We can go one better than that.... Mods.... OFF WITH HIS HEAD! ;) :p
TorresIsGod
23 Nov 2007, 15:09
I used 40 of my 712 (only 699 passwords I can remember anyway) to vote, the other 659 will be voting in the grand final.
And I didn't cheat, how can I cheat to win a poll? It's not like I hacked a mods account and added in more votes for me. If people vote for me, they vote for me?
But you can change all the rules you want, and you can do whatever it is you have to do to ensure I don't win, because hey, DC winning? You cant have that can you?
Bluebear
23 Nov 2007, 17:19
I used 40 of my 712 (only 699 passwords I can remember anyway) to vote, the other 659 will be voting in the grand final.
And I didn't cheat, how can I cheat to win a poll? It's not like I hacked a mods account and added in more votes for me. If people vote for me, they vote for me?
But you can change all the rules you want, and you can do whatever it is you have to do to ensure I don't win, because hey, DC winning? You cant have that can you?
Nope.:thumbsu:
TorresIsGod
23 Nov 2007, 18:05
Then why even bother with this, if certain results happened that you didn't want?
Since it's pretty clear to me that I'm not gonna be allowed into the final, because 'I cheated'... then go ahead and re-do the whole game, because I shouldn't have beaten my brother, I shouldn't have beaten Bluebear, and clearly, I shouldn't have beaten BG... and if you make it that BG goes into the final, that's cheating on your part, because had I not 'cheated'... to get that far, BG's team may have been beaten by someone else...
Or just go ahead and put BG's team into the final, and if she wins, she wins by default, because the real grand finalist isn't in the match-up.
Bluebear
26 Nov 2007, 07:32
Settle down DC.
When I get a chance I'll put the GF and it will be you vs DIG.
Whether we like it (or trust it) or not the polls give you the wins.
I've been very busy over the past week, and with baby bear teething ATM I've barely had time to sit down on the computer for 5 mins to sort it out.
Maybe lunchtime today.:thumbsu:
TorresIsGod
26 Nov 2007, 11:20
I already put up the Grand Final thread, DIG vs. Bluegal is the game.
Made it public voting and everything for you mate :thumbsu: