View Full Version : Who do u rate higher (Bellechambers, Gaertner, Gourdis
LuKe2428
24 Nov 2007, 11:04
who do you rate higher who do you think we should get first in the PSD or rookie draft
RichosGuns
24 Nov 2007, 11:12
Gourdis, Bellchambers, Gaernter in that order
However, in our preferences, Bellchambers, Gourdis, Gaertner
Bellchambers instead of Richards, but Gourdis could be the replacement for Richo that Schultz will never be
nugget_12
24 Nov 2007, 11:43
Geartner for me......then Gourdis then bellchambers.
Drunken Wookie
24 Nov 2007, 11:50
I think we're still searching for a power CHF and Hughes needs some healthy competition so I'm going to go Gourdis.
LuKe2428
24 Nov 2007, 12:00
i dnt think we need another ruckman
we already have pattison graham and now putt
Our backline will be very strong when thurstfield gets a bigger body rance and mcguane will be good backman with polak going back and forward. we still need someone to help out hughes and reiwoldt
so i rekon gourdis
Rayzorwire
24 Nov 2007, 12:07
Rate Gourdis slightly above Bellchambers, but if it came down to a choice between getting Richards in the PSD or taking Bellchambers I'd be heading for the latter.
Bellchambers is the most mature of all the rucks available and the most able to be thrust in to deputise as a 2nd ruck if two of our more senior options go down. He and Putt or Polak could be used in tandum for very brief stints if we get that desperate.
Long term he's going to offer a lot more than Richards can, we just have to gamble a little that he won't be needed much or at all next year. If he is, the difference between what he could offer and what Richards will offer is not that much.
Drunken Wookie
24 Nov 2007, 12:28
absolutely Bellchambers over Richards. Aside from it being a 'young talent vs insurance policy' decision I don't think there'd be much difference in output on the field if we were forced to use either of them. I've watched Guy a fair bit and he's never struck me as anything more then completely out of his depth at AFL level.
Gaertner is not elligbale. We won't double-up on ruckmen. Gouridis is the one out of that group.
Deledio_Judd
24 Nov 2007, 13:28
Gourdis easily:rolleyes: I had him in my top 20, that shows how much in know though.:D
Hopefully we pick him up.
bigpapagman
24 Nov 2007, 23:19
Arrowsmith.
AGRESSION
25 Nov 2007, 00:02
Gourdas and Collard are jumping on a plane with Rance and will be at Punt Rd Monday vying for PSD pick.
Rayzorwire
25 Nov 2007, 00:19
Arrowsmith.
Where's the technicolour vomit emoticon when it is so appropriate? ;)
Drunken Wookie
25 Nov 2007, 01:48
Arrowsmith.
dude looks like a lady.
Rayzorwire
25 Nov 2007, 17:02
dude looks like a lady.
LMAO...