bee dee's world exclusive scoops (2008)

[bee dee]

A young player has injured his knee at the training session at trinity today at 2.30pm. Not sure who it is, so many new young players.Someone will know although not many supporters there.

[giantroo]

Ok then. Zebra where are you?

[micky_11]

I had a dream last night that Riggio hurt his leg.

Hopefully my dream is very wrong.

[theduckfan]

please don't be thommo

[giantroo]

please don't be thommo


He did say a young player.

[m0nty]

Ahhhh, it feels like footy season is about to start, bee dee is posting complete bulltish again. :)

[helsy3]

After just checking bee dee's posts on injuries from last year, I wouldn't be putting any $ on this rumour being correct!

[Oneout Oneback]

After just checking bee dee's posts on injuries from last year, I wouldn't be putting any $ on this rumour being correct!
Was it capsicum spray to the knee?? That can be painful.

[giantroo]

After just checking bee dee's posts on injuries from last year, I wouldn't be putting any $ on this rumour being correct!


Yep,remember those old ones.:p

[RoyalBlue]

After just checking bee dee's posts on injuries from last year, I wouldn't be putting any $ on this rumour being correct!
Last week beedee posted info from another trinity training session that included info I've since found to be true.

I wouldnt doubt that he or she was there. Severity of the knee injury is doubtful though.

[#1 Dogs Fan]

No confirmation on which player it is or how bad the injure is ?

[pharro]

Last week beedee posted info from another trinity training session that included info I've since found to be true.

I wouldnt doubt that he or she was there. Severity of the knee injury is doubtful though.

When you sling as much bile as Bee Dee does, some of it is bound to stick.

[shinboner magic]

Well all you guys on here with all your contacts got any news or do we have to wait for the papers then you can all have your scoops .

[Tas]

Seriously, why is this clown alowed to post in our forum. If one us posted as much shit in other forums we would be out in a nanosecond.

[1jasonoz]

Don't no how true it is, but i've heard a little rumour myself that JWS has been injured.

[giantroo]

One of his best work


http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=294577

[giantroo]

Don't no how true it is, but i've heard a little rumour myself that JWS has been injured.

I hope you're wrong, wrong,wrong!! :(

[gokangas]

I believe it is Nathan Grima (according to a friend) - won't know how bad until tomorrow but doesn't look good.

[1jasonoz]

I hope you're wrong, wrong,wrong!! :(

So do i, it was told to me over a few beers a couple of hours ago at my place from a North supporting friend.

Fingers crossed its just a rumour.

[giantroo]

I believe it is Nathan Grima (according to a friend) - won't know how bad until tomorrow but doesn't look good.


Who ever it is, i hope it isn't someone who will play a major part in our team.

[Woodson]

A young player has injured his knee at the training session at trinity today at 2.30pm. Not sure who it is, so many new young players.Someone will know although not many supporters there.

Serial poster PEST returns. :rolleyes:

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

I believe it is Nathan Grima (according to a friend) - won't know how bad until tomorrow but doesn't look good.


That's disappointing. I really hoped we could avoid serious injury's like that this season. Hope it isn't a knee reco in the waiting.

[year of the roo]

It could be Urch?

[CrazyQ]

It could be Urch?
Not the future hall of famer!

[micky_11]

I believe it is Nathan Grima (according to a friend) - won't know how bad until tomorrow but doesn't look good.
Thats a real shame, out of all our rookies he would have been the one to play seniors and have a real impact, awesome player

[r_boy]

Thats a real shame, out of all our rookies he would have been the one to play seniors and have a real impact, awesome player

Yep, had the physical attributes to be the KPP defender we were looking for.

[HongKongRoo]

So is it all bs?

[gokangas]

So is it all bs?

Haven't seen anything official but been told it is true that he has a knee injury, but not sure how serious. My source said it looked bad.
Hopefullywe will hear something from the club soon. I'm only going on what I was able to get from a good source.

[HongKongRoo]

Haven't seen anything official but been told it is true that he has a knee injury, but not sure how serious. My source said it looked bad.
Hopefullywe will hear something from the club soon. I'm only going on what I was able to get from a good source.

sucks for whoever it is but let's hope it's not a frontliner

[gokangas]

From my source - full reco. Bad luck for the kid.

[The Teflon Dean]

From my source - full reco. Bad luck for the kid.

Which kid? Grima?

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

From my source - full reco. Bad luck for the kid.


Disappointing, Very disappointing.

[micky_11]

Which kid? Grima?
I think so,

**** thats so unlucky, worked his arse off in Tassie and then Adelaide, gets drafted as a mature age recruit and bang out for the year and prob wont be retained :(


Where is the pink text?

[The big ROObowski]

If Harding got retained surely this kid will get another one, he plays a possie were pretty light on.

[gokangas]

Which kid? Grima?

Yep - tough break but young enough to recover.

[Anti Gold Coast]

Really hoping this isn't a precursor to anything.

It's a shame for him, and I hope the club give him another chance.

[The Teflon Dean]

Where is the pink text?

This is nothing to be cheery about.

Yep - tough break but young enough to recover.

Shit!

[tommydee]

Has this been confirmed by the club or by any media outlet, or is it just trash talk??

Hope its only trash talk:confused::mad:

[KangaMatt]

Can confirm it is a full reco. I work with his g/f's friend here in Adelaide and she emailed her at work today saying he has torn the anterior cruciate. Hope the operation goes well, by all reports he is a talented footballer.

[micky_11]

Has this been confirmed by the club or by any media outlet, or is it just trash talk??

Hope its only trash talk:confused::mad:
Ask your brother...bee dee

[bee dee]

Ask your brother...bee dee

I can only pass on what l see and hear and while 50% of supporters have had me banned from their sites and the main board, things like this can be told to the faithful a lot earlier than the club will ever let its members know.
However as you have read people want me banned and no doubt they will get their wish from the mods and u guys will have to wait however long the club wants you to wait.
Apologies accepted from the early posters who again attacked this post. Guess that wont happen hey?

[bee dee]

Ahhhh, it feels like footy season is about to start, bee dee is posting complete bulltish again. :)

Thanks

[bee dee]

Seriously, why is this clown alowed to post in our forum. If one us posted as much shit in other forums we would be out in a nanosecond.

Cannot await your response now

[Anti Gold Coast]

Cannot await your response now

You try so much that you'll eventually get one right.

[Boozeroo]

Yep, it a AC Knee injury, full year out.:(

And, yes we are all related down here in Tassie- heard it from his cousin.

[benno87]

Atrocious news.

Whether it is a rookie or 300 gamer, never like to see players go down pre-season.

[Lidge]

I can only pass on what l see and hear and while 50% of supporters have had me banned from their sites and the main board, things like this can be told to the faithful a lot earlier than the club will ever let its members know.
However as you have read people want me banned and no doubt they will get their wish from the mods and u guys will have to wait however long the club wants you to wait.
Apologies accepted from the early posters who again attacked this post. Guess that wont happen hey?

Hey bee dee.

We aint the Hawthorn board and don't ban someone for looking in the wrong direction.

Tell you what we'll do. I'll sticky a thread for you in the player lounge (our sub board where game & training reports end up). We'll leave it there all year for you to dump your 'scoops' into and for the punters to post their replies.

Let's see how good your strike rate is in 6-8 months.

[year of the roo]

Should have kept Urch.

[jozeph]

bee dee was at the roosistence gig.

[Jimmy's Hot Dogs]

bee dee was at the roosistence gig.

Scooter out the front?

[DarwinRoo]

Should have kept Urch.

Why? The guys hamstrings twanged more times than a banjo at a redneck convention.

And was he going to be elevated to the Rookie list to replace Nathan Grima? :rolleyes:

[gokangas]

Grima story in the Herald Sun this morning. :(

[bee dee]

Just some bad news for J.W.Smith.
He injured his ankle when they went on camp and didnt ice it that night, thought it want too bad and the club didnt have any ice with them ( where did they go?) Anyway it blew up like a balloon and he is now 8 weeks behind schedule. So dont expect him to be doing anything in the short term. The ankle is becoming a major issue for him. Cant get it right and any sort of twist/turn can affect it.
This is 100% correct info.
Just for any Blues fans, shame about Judd breaking down last Monday week ago doing his other side of his groin, they are covering it up very well, however someone in the media will be going with it very very shortly, the word is out. ( as usual no one has broken this) and l expect to be shot down. Lets wait and see hey?

[micky_11]

Just some bad news for J.W.Smith.
He injured his ankle when they went on camp and didnt ice it that night, thought it want too bad and the club didnt have any ice with them ( where did they go?) Anyway it blew up like a balloon and he is now 8 weeks behind schedule. So dont expect him to be doing anything in the short term. The ankle is becoming a major issue for him. Cant get it right and any sort of twist/turn can affect it.
This is 100% correct info.
Just for any Blues fans, shame about Judd breaking down last Monday week ago doing his other side of his groin, they are covering it up very well, however someone in the media will be going with it very very shortly, the word is out. ( as usual no one has broken this) and l expect to be shot down. Lets wait and see hey?
Shit, F my life :(


Oh and you have a designated thread remember bee dee, Lidge created it for you and stickied it

[giantroo]

FFS,this is shit news!:(

[The Zebra]

Not good news, but this time last year he was having an operation and still managed to get back by round 6 and play 19 games and dominated a final.

Probably won't see any intra-club or NAB action, but I am not panicking yet.

[Divado]

He didn't ice his ankle? wtf

[micky_11]

Not good news, but this time last year he was having an operation and still managed to get back by round 6 and play 19 games and dominated a final.

Probably won't see any intra-club or NAB action, but I am not panicking yet.
My heart has now calmed down and beating steadily, thanks Zebra

[giantroo]

He didn't ice his ankle? wtf


No ice at the camp.

[The big ROObowski]

*****. Hopefully it's nothing that cant be fixed.

[Divado]

No ice at the camp.

no ice? at the entire camp. very unprofessional.

[giantroo]

no ice? at the entire camp. very unprofessional.


well that's according to bee dee.

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Truly stupid if its come down to ice not being available.:mad: I guess its a wait & see thing.

[Divado]

well that's according to bee dee.
that can't be true.

[micky_11]

Truly stupid if its come down to ice not being available.:mad: I guess its a wait & see thing.
Exactly, you would think a Profesional Sporting Club would have ice available when ever it was needed.

[micky_11]

that can't be true.
Bee Dee has been on the money recently, i am certainly beleiving him on this one

[Divado]

Truly stupid if its come down to ice not being available.:mad: I guess its a wait & see thing.drive to the nearest service station, a freezer, there are ice packs that use chemicals and don't need to be stored in a freezer.

Were was teh camp? the simpson desert.

[micky_11]

drive to the nearest service station, a freezer, there are ice packs that use chemicals and don't need to be stored in a freezer.

Were was teh camp? the simpson desert.
Wasnt it that Secret Service camp or something in a forrest? where they had to use guns. like an army camp or sometihng???

[NimChief]

Very strange.

I remember Smith saying last year how diligently he'd been looking after his ankle, icing it daily, general exercises etc.

After coming back from so far, I can't believe that he could get so careless and just ignore getting the ankle treated.

[blackshadow]

What type of camp doesn't have ice? How are you supposed to keep your beer cold?

Rule number one of camps - bring plenty of ice to keep the eskies cold!

[Manbearpig]

Hey bee dee, I found some medical records of some footballers in the gutter near my place, you wanna buy em?

[giantroo]

Wasnt it that Secret Service camp or something in a forrest? where they had to use guns. like an army camp or sometihng???


I think it was.

[Kangalicious]

Ummmm . . . call me cynical, but isn't our camp scheduled for next week?

[Tas]

Bee Dee has been on the money recently, i am certainly beleiving him on this one

How does the saying go... even a stopped clock is right twice a day. Fire enough shots and you are bound to hit something.

Smith has had a lot of issues with his ankle, soreness is nothing new. 8 weeks for swelling, yeah right... He was out for 8 weeks when he was operated on last year.

[micky_11]

What type of camp doesn't have ice? How are you supposed to keep your beer cold?

Rule number one of camps - bring plenty of ice to keep the eskies cold!


Band Camp and Fat Camp.

I have been no neither hahahahha

[Manbearpig]

What type of camp doesn't have ice?

I have a great line to reply to that about some other AFL clubs, but I might get in trouble.;)

[HELLSBELLS]

Bee dee almost would of had us if he didnt use the no ice at the camp that bit shoots this thread to pieces .

There is no way on gods green earth they would of had NO ice whatsoever , and if true could even be negligence on the part of n.m.f.c

Ill put this rumour down to crap plus would of heard something by now .

[blackshadow]

Do it manbearpig - don't be a big girls blouse!

[bee dee]

Ummmm . . . call me cynical, but isn't our camp scheduled for next week?

One b4 christmas was a training camp, next week is a bulltish community camp where the players hardly train

[bee dee]

Bee dee almost would of had us if he didnt use the no ice at the camp that bit shoots this thread to pieces .

There is no way on gods green earth they would of had NO ice whatsoever , and if true could even be negligence on the part of n.m.f.c

Ill put this rumour down to crap plus would of heard something by now .
Has any fan/member seen Smith run since Christmas at training? Answer is no, so work it out

[ArjenTheGreat]

How does the saying go... even a stopped clock is right twice a day. Fire enough shots and you are bound to hit something.

Smith has had a lot of issues with his ankle, soreness is nothing new. 8 weeks for swelling, yeah right... He was out for 8 weeks when he was operated on last year.


Saw JWS and Azza at Crown playing poker a few weeks ago and noticed how badly he was limping then... Nothing new for the kid though... always seems to be limping yet also seems to be faster than Wells on some occasions so who knows?

My guess would be that he'll play rd 1 no matter what. And on the WING.

[Kangalicious]

One b4 christmas was a training camp, next week is a bulltish community camp where the players hardly train


Are you talking about the military thing they did - pictures in the paper the day of the Dallas Brooks Hall meeting?

Which would explain why JWS wasn't involved in any of the drills etc in Zebra's report . . . and would also explain why there was no ice at the camp (hard to simulate battle conditions with ice on hand).

So, are you saying 8 weeks from now, or 8 weeks in total?

[HELLSBELLS]

Has any fan/member seen Smith run since Christmas at training? Answer is no, so work it out


we giving the 2008 brownlow winner a slow start as not to burn out to early .:D

And i suppose if true it poses the other questions

will he ever get it right ?

and how long will we persist with him ?

[bellzy]

FFS,this is shit news!:(
No, it's bee dee news...

[1jasonoz]

I mentioned that i heard this rumour the other day;

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=9960303&postcount=15

The rumour i'd heard the other day when i first mentioned it came from a friend of JWS cousin whom had said he had done his ankle again at the boot camp. Didn't go into details about how bad, but from what they had been told it was going to seriously slow JWS progress down.

[Master Chief]

No, it's bee dee news...

Same thing.

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Are you talking about the military thing they did - pictures in the paper the day of the Dallas Brooks Hall meeting?

Which would explain why JWS wasn't involved in any of the drills etc in Zebra's report . . . and would also explain why there was no ice at the camp (hard to simulate battle conditions with ice on hand).

So, are you saying 8 weeks from now, or 8 weeks in total?


Its been like 6 weeks since the training camp so he should be up & running for the NAB cup going by this thread.

[jschwag]

Jesse was saying after the season that he will likely always have to manage the ankle. They were on an army base. It may very well have been that there was no ice immediately available so he didn't worry about it. There wold not have been a lack of ice on the entire base!

Jesse hasn't been in the practice (intra-squad) matches and hasn't been running with the main group. I wouldn't be at all surprised if this is true. However, if it isn't season ending, or at least long term, I would say that the club is being overly cautious in order to get him ready for the 'real' stuff.

In terms of how long do we 'persevere', it's not like he's a liability. He is arguably our most talented player with great speed, good size, and sublime skills. He will be an Embley type player at his best. Near impossible to match up on.

[salamander]

I mentioned that i heard this rumour the other day;

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=9960303&postcount=15

The rumour i'd heard the other day when i first mentioned it came from a friend of JWS cousin whom had said he had done his ankle again at the boot camp. Didn't go into details about how bad, but from what they had been told it was going to seriously slow JWS progress down.

First with da scoop..................

[gokangas]

Jesse was saying after the season that he will likely always have to manage the ankle. They were on an army base. It may very well have been that there was no ice immediately available so he didn't worry about it. There wold not have been a lack of ice on the entire base!

Jesse hasn't been in the practice (intra-squad) matches and hasn't been running with the main group. I wouldn't be at all surprised if this is true. However, if it isn't season ending, or at least long term, I would say that the club is being overly cautious in order to get him ready for the 'real' stuff.

In terms of how long do we 'persevere', it's not like he's a liability. He is arguably our most talented player with great speed, good size, and sublime skills. He will be an Embley type player at his best. Near impossible to match up on.

Enquiries with a friend sort of confirms this. I am told his non appearance in practice matches and training is part of the general management strategy for his ankle. He has a problem that requires more management at the moment.
He did sound a little guarded so I hope it is as simple as that and not something more serious.

[m0nty]

The Judd part of it is complete crap, he was shown on Channel 10 news just then striding out at training without any problem in South Africa.

[m0nty]

Thanks

Typical bee dee, can't help himself with his one success of the week, goes off and steals someone else's scoop from this very thread and passes it off as his own (http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=411390), then adds on some some complete bollocks about Judd doing his groin. Back to his 30% success rate.

[micky_11]

The Judd part of it is complete crap, he was shown on Channel 10 news just then striding out at training without any problem in South Africa.
Who is Judd?

This thread should only be about Smith :P

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

Enquiries with a friend sort of confirms this. I am told his non appearance in practice matches and training is part of the general management strategy for his ankle. He has a problem that requires more management at the moment.
He did sound a little guarded so I hope it is as simple as that and not something more serious.


He will probably always have ankle problems, like swelling & inflammation.

[micky_11]

He will probably always have ankle problems, like swelling & inflammation.
unfortunately

[NICK_ROOBOY83]

unfortunately


Yep.

[Tas]

10 years ago Smith's ankle injury would have been a career ending one, he is likely going to have issues with it all his career. He will miss games because of it like Carey missed games constantly because of his shoulders.

When someone says he is struggling with the ankle my reaction is tell me something I don't know.

If he requires major surgery on it then that is newsworthy. He will have minor procedures on it for the rest of his football career to help manage the injury. I am just thankful that he can still play footy while managing the ankle.

[The Other Dean]

Looks to me like ice was the deciding factor.

[micky_11]

Looks to me like ice was the deciding factor.
you sure? he could have slipped on soap, there fore re-injuring the ankle

[wakeboardandy]

10 years ago Smith's ankle injury would have been a career ending one, he is likely going to have issues with it all his career. He will miss games because of it like Carey missed games constantly because of his shoulders.

When someone says he is struggling with the ankle my reaction is tell me something I don't know.

If he requires major surgery on it then that is newsworthy. He will have minor procedures on it for the rest of his football career to help manage the injury. I am just thankful that he can still play footy while managing the ankle.

steve johnson has similar problems with his ankle (after jumping the fence at a pub after a piss up) and they said he would never be able to play out a full season.. look at him now..

I think smith can overcome the injury just like johnno.