View Full Version : Mike Sheahan's Top 50
Cara_Cougar #16
17 Mar 2008, 19:42
Some interesting Brisbane inclusions, including Jamie Charman.
Enjoy!!!:thumbsu:
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/afl/story/0,26576,23375596-19742,00.html
Kochie 16
17 Mar 2008, 19:46
MIKE SHEAHAN'S TOP 50
1 - Jonathan Brown - Brisbane Lions
2 - Chris Judd - Carlton
3 - Dean Cox - West Coast
4 - Nick Riewoldt - St Kilda
5 - Gary Ablett - Geelong
6 - Daniel Kerr - West Coast
7 - Chad Cornes - Port Adelaide
8 - Matthew Pavlich - Fremantle
9 - Matthew Scarlett - Geelong
10 - Adam Goodes - Sydney
11 - Darren Glass - West Coast
12 - Brad Johnson - W Bulldogs
13 - Lance Franklin - Hawthorn
14 - Shaun Burgoyne - Port Adelaide
15 - Jimmy Bartel - Geelong
16 - Nick Dal Santo - St Kilda
17 - Scott Lucas - Essendon
18 - Luke Hodge - Hawthorn
19 - Brendan Fevola - Carlton
20 - Simon Black - Brisbane Lions
21 - Sam Mitchell - Hawthorn
22 - Brad Ottens - Geelong
23 - Nick Stevens - Carlton
24 - Joel Corey - Geelong
25 - Andrew McLeod - Adelaide
26 - Travis Cloke - Collingwood
27 - Kane Cornes - Port Adelaide
28 - Barry Hall - Sydney
29 - Brent Harvey - Kangaroos
30 - Cameron Mooney - Geelong
31 - Steve Johnson - Geelong
32 - Simon Goodwin - Adelaide
33 - Tadhg Kennelly - Sydney
34 - Brendon Lade - Port Adelaide
35 - Sam Fisher - St Kilda
36 - Robert Murphy - W Bulldogs
37 - Craig Bolton - Sydney
38 - Ben Rutten - Adelaide
39 - Paul Chapman - Geelong
40 - Ryan O'Keefe - Sydney
41 - Luke Power - Brisbane Lions
42 - Dale Thomas - Collingwood
43 _ Lindsay Gilbee - W Bulldogs
44 - Hamish McIntosh - Kangaroos
45 - Nathan Bock - Adelaide
46 - Jamie Charman - Brisbane Lions
47 - Leigh Montagna - St Kilda
48 - Campbell Brown - Hawthorn
49 - Scott Pendlebury - Collingwood
50 - Brett Deledio - Richmond
is this who he thinks is the best in the comp
or
who he thinks will have a big season
if its the first one i cant understand the selections of deledio and gilbee in particular.
Kochie 16
17 Mar 2008, 20:10
A bit of both really.
ZoBlitz
17 Mar 2008, 20:57
Sheahan's top 50 is always abit of a lottery. I tend to think he gets bored halfway through and picks some names out of a hat.
notting18
17 Mar 2008, 20:57
He says every year that the list at the start of the year is who he thinks will be the best 50 players in that year ahead (2008 this time). ie. a prediction. However, the one at the end of the year is his ratings of the best 50 players in that year that was.
This is his best list in a few years IMO, it agrees with my perspective for about 70% of the players/places. From a Brisbane POV, Adcock missing would be the only clear difference between what I think and Mike's opinion.
brisbanelioness
17 Mar 2008, 23:36
But Adcock did get a mention:
"As usual, there are 15-20 players desperately unlucky to miss.
They include Hawthorn's best-and-fairest winner Brad Sewell, the veterans Cameron Ling and Darren Milburn (Geelong), Dustin Fletcher and Matthew Lloyd (Essendon), Matthew Richardson and Nathan Brown (Richmond), Brett Kirk (Sydney), Scott West (Western Bulldogs) and Tyson Edwards (Adelaide), and the likely next wave of gun players: Aaron Davey, Nathan Foley, Jed Adcock, Jarrad Waite, Heath Shaw, Dane Swan, Ryan Griffen and Adam Cooney."
Tim the Toolman
18 Mar 2008, 10:05
Toolman's prediction: Joel Patfull will be there in 2009
xxxWillxxx
19 Mar 2008, 02:31
In all honesty there is no player i would rather have more in my side than Charman and Black is a absolute gun and is top 10 at least