Player Performance Weeks 1 - 4

[Kildonan]

w1 w2 w3 w4 Player
GD VG VG VG Leigh Montagna
VG GD GD GD Nick Dal Santo
GD VG VG GD Luke Ball
VG VG GD GD Sam Fisher
GD VG GD VG Lenny Hayes
VG GD GD GD Nick Riewoldt
--w-- VG GD Brendon Goddard
GD GD GD VG Steven King
GD GD GD GD Max Hudghton
GD --w-- -- Charlie Gardiner
--w-- -- GD Sean Dempster
FR PR GD VG Justin Koschitzke
FR VG GD FR Jason Gram
FR GD GD -- Adam Schneider
GD GD -- -- Michael Gardiner
GD VG FR PR Xavier Clarke
GD FR GD GD Sam Gilbert
FR FR GD -- Raphael Clarke
GD GD GD FR Robert Harvey
GD GD FR FR Leigh Fisher
GD FR PR -- Jarryn Geary
-- GD FR FR Jason Blake
FR GD GD PR Aaron Fiora
FR --w-- GD Clinton Jones
--w-- -- FR Matt Maguire
FR GD FR FR Stephen Milne
-- GD PR FR Fraser Gehrig

[Sir Robert]

Rd 4 changes from where I'm sitting:

Dal Santo FR
Luke Ball VG
Sam Gilbert FR
Jason Blake PR
Fraser Gehrig PR

Too many GDs for a team that got thumped... On the scoreboard at least... But that's where it counts.

Hopefully the skills are up this week.

[Squizzy1970]

Fraser Gehrig was appauling - what would he have rated without the last goal?

Thought Milne was quite good - his chasing and harassing was up, which doesn't necessarily translate to points. Two very poor shots on goal I guess hold him back.

Kosi was only good imo.

Agree with Bob - Blakey had a bad one.

[Look2Me4Guidance]

Rd 4 changes from where I'm sitting:

Dal Santo FR
Luke Ball VG
Sam Gilbert FR
Jason Blake PR
Fraser Gehrig PR

Too many GDs for a team that got thumped... On the scoreboard at least... But that's where it counts.

Hopefully the skills are up this week.

I agree with all of those except Gilbo. I thought he did well moving up the field and ran to the right areas. Dal lucky not to get a poor.

[johnmandiddy]

if you don't mind a visitor, in my opinion, in round three, i thought sam fisher was really good, and nick dal santo fair at best

[sainter]

It's obviously statistically based but I wouldn't have thought Kosi was deserving of a VG last week and I think you've been a little bit generous towards Sam Gilbert. I was a bit happier with him on the weekend though, Ross gave him the task of following Ablett which will do his development a lot of good. Personally I'd have given Max VG's for rounds 1 and 2 as well. What more can a defender do than comprehensively thrash Hall and Fevola in successive weeks?

Great stuff anyway. I don't think I could go through each player and rate them in that detail, mostly because after I go to a game and we lose I don't bother with the replay because it makes me too angry.

[Sir Robert]

I agree with all of those except Gilbo. I thought he did well moving up the field and ran to the right areas. Dal lucky not to get a poor.

Yeah maybe a bit harsh on Gilbert, I'm a big fan but I know he's playing nowhere near what he's capable of. And watching him he knows it.

Agree with Sainter as well. Kosi GD. If that's his best we are in trouble.

Get on the Luke Ball train. Past two games bar two (?) woeful kicks have been awesome. Confidence will get those kicks hitting their targets I'm sure. He's reminding me more and more of the Luke Ball of old!