View Full Version : Rd 5 St Kilda v Essendon - Player Votes
Kildonan
19 Apr 2008, 02:08
Please feel welcome to vote
We're using a flexible system of voting where 15 pts are allocated to vote with. You can give a maximum vote of 5 pts and a minimum of 1 pt for any one player.
Typical Vote: N Riewoldt 5, L Hayes 4, L Ball 3, S Milne 2, J Geary 1
Acceptable: N Riewoldt 5, L Hayes 5, L Ball 2, S Milne 2, J Geary 1
Acceptable: N Riewoldt 3, L Hayes 3, L Ball 3, S Milne 2, J Geary 1, J Koschitzke 1, L Montagna 1, D Armitage 1
Please be aware that there are two Fishers, Clarkes, and Gardiners so please use initials to clarify.
This thread will be stickied until next Friday and the totals will be tabulated.
AFL MAN
19 Apr 2008, 10:56
5-Harvey
4-Max H
3-Armitage
2-Hayes
1-Milne
HoldenMCaulfield
19 Apr 2008, 11:54
4 R Harvey
3 M Hudghton
3 L Hayes
2 D Armitage
1 S Milne
1 N Riewoldt
1 S Fisher
SIR SAINT HOTDOG
19 Apr 2008, 11:57
4- Maxy
4- Hayes
3 - Harvey
2 - Armitage
1 - S Fisher
1 - C Gardiner
SAINTS 4 07 FLAG
19 Apr 2008, 12:10
5-Harvey
4-Hayes
3-Hudghton
2-Armitage
1-Ball
mailman4
19 Apr 2008, 12:39
4- Maxxy
4- Banga
4- Lenny
1- Armi
1- Roo
1- S. Fish
foxy_dal
19 Apr 2008, 12:50
5. Hudgton
4. Harvey
3. Hayes
2. Riewoldt
1. Dal Santo
3 - Hayes
3 - Maxy
3 - Dal
3 - Roo
3 - Banger
Unlucky - Armo (What a gun), S.Fisher, Bally, Charlie, Yapper, Dempster
TassieSaint
19 Apr 2008, 16:07
5 - Hudghton (Dear god he gave Lloyd a thrashing, can't remember ever seeing Lloyd beaten so bad. I expect to be hearing Dermie call for his head mid-week)
4 - Hayes
3 - Harvey
1 - Dal Santo
1 - S. Fisher
1 - Riewoldt
Unlucky: Armitage, Milne, Ball
SaintsSeptember
19 Apr 2008, 16:27
3 - M Hudghton
2 - S Fisher
2 - X Clark - Most fired up iv'e ever seen him.
2 - Armitage
2 - Harvey
2 - Reiwoldt
1 - Milne - If his accuracy had been better he would have been amazing.
1 - Hayes
Persevering Saint
20 Apr 2008, 00:38
4. Harvey ("take that Dermie", #1)
3. "Hugeton" of a performance from Maxy ("take that Dermie", #2)
3. Hayes
2. Roo (a captain's knock)
1. Milney
1. Armitage (watch this space...)
1. C Gardiner (we just looked so much more damaging with him, didn't we)
bubblegoose
20 Apr 2008, 12:28
5 Harves
4 Lenny
3 Max
2 Armo
1 X
Kildonan
20 Apr 2008, 15:23
5 L Hayes
3 M Hudghton
2 N Dal Santo
2 D Armitage
1 R Harvey
1 N Riewoldt
1 S Fisher
Special mention: S King - are we already taking him for granted ? His performances have enabled our mids to excel. Was noticable by his absence and the ensuing turnaround by Essendon. How good has he been for us so far ?
bluejay
20 Apr 2008, 19:20
5. Hayes
4. Hudghton
3. Harvey
2. King
1. Milne
5 - Max
3 - Harves
3 - Hayes
2 - Armo
1 - Milne
1 - C. Gardiner
saintmont
20 Apr 2008, 21:16
5)L Hayes
4)Max
3)R Harvey
2) S Fisher
1)C Gardiner
35Harvs
21 Apr 2008, 10:02
5 - lenny
4- Harvs
3- max - come on Dermie, where's your call for Lloydy?
2- Dal
1 - Amitage
The Punter
21 Apr 2008, 11:01
5 Harvey
4 Hudghton
3 Hayes
2 Milne
1 Goddard
Squizzy1970
21 Apr 2008, 11:31
4 - Lenny (again the go-to man in the centre)
4 - Max (thrashed Harry High Pants. Sorry Robert Walls, what was that you said?)
2 - Rooey (we didn't kick well to him, but he just kept presenting all night. 3 goals, 3 score assists)
2 - Harvs (some great link work. 29 touches in 69% TOG)
1 - BJ (thank god he is back, awesome foot skills)
1 - Dal (vote for both being an effective player and courage to come back when we needed him to after a jab).
1 - Sam F (23 effective touches, 4 spoils, 4 tackles. Very good game given hammies are giving him a bit of trouble).
Armo, X & Milne close to votes. Plenty of other effective players, although CJ needs a rest (too much watching the man instead of the play).
Look2Me4Guidance
21 Apr 2008, 13:21
5 - Maxy H (superstar)
4 - Lenny Hayes (superstar)
4 - The King (Robert Harvey for all the lay people)
1 - X Clarke (very happy with the work of #3)
1 - D Armitage (keep kicking those sausage rolls son)
4 Maxie
3 Lenny
3 Harvs
2 Big Fish
2 Arma
1 Roo
sainter
21 Apr 2008, 23:42
4 - Hudghton
3 - Harvey
3 - Hayes
1 - Armitage
1 - Dal Santo
1 - C Gardiner
1 - Milne
1 - Riewoldt
Juggalo Balla
21 Apr 2008, 23:52
Armitage - 5 - Deserves more - What a debut
Montagna - 5 - $900 fine. Good work mate. :D
Gram - 3 - Still getting the ball moving
X-Man Clarke - 2 - Run boy!! :p
Hugh Jars
23 Apr 2008, 14:27
4 - Harvey
4 - Hudghton
3 - Hayes
2 - Dal Santo
1 - C Gardiner
1 - X Clarke
Rough_Edges
23 Apr 2008, 18:08
4- Maxxy
4- Banga
4- Lenny
1- Armi
1- Roo
1- S. Fish
WASaintsFan08
24 Apr 2008, 17:41
5. harvey
4. hayes
3. armo
2. dempster
1. dal santo (courage)
die hard sfl fan
26 Apr 2008, 10:53
yeh harvey was best on for sure