who would you want taking a shot after the siren to win you a game?

[oaks II]

1.Lance Franklin
2. Matthew Lloyd
3.Jonothan Brown
4. Brendon Fevola
5.Matthew Richardson


no particular order

[KGCC07]

Depends from where abouts..

But Fraser Gehrig would be up there surely?

[KGCC07]

^^^^^

[anti.]

franklin due to the fact he lifts for the occasion. other players there may be better kicks overall but franklin is a deadset big game player.

[bender22]

franklin due to the fact he lifts for the occasion. other players there may be better kicks overall but franklin is a deadset big game player.
Queue the North Melbourne trolls....

[Theprofessional]

Anyone else remember last year? Lions faced Sydney, Jonathan Brown fifty something meter kick from close to the boundary, siren goes.

Flogs it, straight through the middle, it's a draw.

I can also remember Fevola doing that from the sideline many years ago.

Brown for me.

[thebigboy]

The way Fevola is kicking at the moment, i'd take him in a heartbeat. From my club, a fully fit Lucas is the man now, Lloyds accuracy hasn't been the same since he did his Hamstring.

[Shaymuhz]

out of the options i chose brown, but i would have pavlich from any distance, any angle.

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

Brown out of those people. You could also have Ling in there.

[Tiger Battler]

Out of the above Franklin

As a Richmond supporter, I would rather Browny take the shot then Richo.

[Quinz]

Fev, fantastic shot on goal.

[walkers a legend]

Right now probably FEVA

[aaronm46]

juice newton

[lynchy23]

cameron ling would not miss gaurenteed

[Eel_storm]

Buddy cos he likes winning the game off his own boot

[TheGeneral]

Nick Gill.
Buddy cos he likes winning the game off his own boot
And the other four players look to pass it off when they're in range. :confused: :rolleyes:

[TigerGlory]

Brett Deledio in my opinion.

Couldnt miss if you paid him. :thumbsu:

[stewrox19]

cameron ling would not miss gaurenteed

couldnt agree more gun set shot:thumbsu:

[Slash_LP]

Will Minson:p. But out of the poll Fev, gun shot.

[legitimatic]

Fev, fantastic shot on goal.

Yep agree.

[vinnie_vegas69]

juice newton
Which one of them is your Angel of the Morning?

[PUSSIES_07_FLAG]

Inside the 50 Ling
Outside the 50 Fev

[bender22]

Fev every day and tuesday.

[RevDog]

Brian Lake.

[Power King]

Anyone else remember last year? Lions faced Sydney, Jonathan Brown fifty something meter kick from close to the boundary, siren goes.

Flogs it, straight through the middle, it's a draw.

I can also remember Fevola doing that from the sideline many years ago.

Brown for me.

^For me it was between Brown and Franklin, with Fev just behind.

Brown did do that last year, but Franklin also did it, in a final, to win the match. Brown had the chance to help Brisbane get back in the game against port the other week and shanked one or two kicks. Bradshaw lifted to the occasion better in this recent game.

Franklin's accuracy can be improved, although already it is quite good (has had a couple of poor matches), but as mentioned already, he is a big game player, and often i have seen him name shots straight through the sticks from 50+ out.

Fev does have a nice kick on him, but he's not as consistent as the above two, so if he's had a poor game i wouldn't be as confident with him.

edit: i chose buddy

[Raydosh]

probably fev but buddy would make it so much more exciting because of the unpredictability

[hellfire]

Not sure, probably Fevola.

For us: Didak (yes, even after Saturday), Medhurst or Burns.

[abs kebabs24]

I don't think richo should be up there, i would never trust him kicking for goal. I would go with fev, he is doing well

[Claude Balls]

Of those options, probably Lloyd or Fev.

I think Paul Chapman and Mathew Stokes are worthy of being included in this poll as well. Actually Cameron Ling is a dead-eye as well.

[davey_magik]

Where the hell is Mark Williams?
He'd be mine for sure.

[OZZA]

Simon Beasley.
Straighest kick ever.

[burto]

Since last year, Ling has kicked 24-0 from set shots.

[gopower]

Franklin over the whole competition. For Port, probably Shaun Burgoyne. Or anyone but Daniel Motlop.

[MinerBoy]

franklin due to the fact he lifts for the occasion. other players there may be better kicks overall but franklin is a deadset big game player.

Agreed. Although Fev and Lloyd are generally beautiful kicks.

[stifler's mom]

Where the hell is Mark Williams?
He'd be mine for sure.


Mine too. Fantastic kick for goal.

[Carn Hawkas]

Cameron Ling
Hasn't missed a set shot in 2 years or something like that.

[razarback]

Where the hell is Mark Williams?
He'd be mine for sure.


Mine too. :thumbsu:

[Bronson23]

Brendan Fevola.
Big Time Player.

[Stants_24_Legend]

Where's Scott Lucas? Remember in the NAB Cup kicked 3 Super Goals on the boundary on his wrong side?

He would definately be mine.
Don't know why Lloyd is there. Anyone see his miss from 30m out on friday night? :thumbsd:

[Hodgies Heroes]

You missed by far the best option _ Mark Williams. Start the poll again.

[Notorious_29]

out of the options i chose brown, but i would have pavlich from any distance, any angle.

i agree, i feel so confident when he has the ball in his hand from anywhere.

[mcglee]

Gotta be joking on Richo - great player but ordinary converter. Franklin if it is on a ridiculous angle but from that list I'd go Fev for consistency and variety of angles he's good from ( and apparently Will Minson after Sunday)

[oaks II]

You missed by far the best option _ Mark Williams. Start the poll again.

im not cofindent he would even get in that position lol. he isnt good enough

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Inside 50: Porplyzia
Outside 50:Goodwin.

Simple; really

[i_love_the_hoff]

Inside 50: Porplyzia




OH FOR GOD SAKE !!! :thumbsd::rolleyes::thumbsd:

[Thrawn]

His best IMO:

5ZKcqWmtsvI

Apparently that pocket is the hardest to kick from, either from AAMI or any other ground. Or at least, what some Adelaide supporters claimed.

Right at the moment, he's deadly accurate - I think he's only had, what, 6 behinds so far this year? So 26.6, and three of those behinds were posters! Or was it four? So at the moment, the big Fev!

Franklin is great too, but he does miss a lot of shots.

[Anthony_]

Will Minson ;)

[jiphoc]

Got to be Brown. He never seams to feel the pressure, and lets admit it he has a fantastic kick

[Kram81]

Haselby

[lynchy23]

before this year, i would back scott welsh anyday

[oaks II]

[quote=Thrawn;10769359]His best IMO:

5ZKcqWmtsvI

i hope carlton play like this against adelaide this week!

[crawf_legend]

Buddy. Fevola couldnt do that in an elim.

[Thrawn]

Buddy. Fevola couldnt do that in an elim.

Give him the opportunity and he might.

[Bigeasy]

Leigh Harding

[gandaal]

Buddy. Fevola couldnt do that in an elim.

I have no doubt that Fev could and would. He thrives on the pressure of the big occasion.

[davey_magik]

im not cofindent he would even get in that position lol. he isnt good enough

You clearly have NFI.

Williams is the best set shot in the league. Best technique going around and thrives on the pressure kicks.

[wce4premiership]

Lloyd.

[Blind Blink]

Stephen Kernahan, or however you spell it.

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

Definitely not Pavlich after tonights result.

[Power King]

i think he did everything right, it looked good off the boot to me and i thought it was going through for a goal

wasn't the easiest of angles and a bit of bad luck in hitting the post

of course even pav would say no excuses, a point is a point

[Magpie Magic]

Fevola. He's a beautiful kick for goal especially from outside 50.

[WN123]

Over their whole career Lloyd has been easily the most accurate. Last year it was Brown marginally ahead of Lucas and Lloyd. Fev and Franklin not even in the race.
The only reason Essendon supporters have noticed Lloyd miss a few lately is because he does it so rarely.

[Anthony_]

Over their whole career Lloyd has been easily the most accurate. Last year it was Brown marginally ahead of Lucas and Lloyd. Fev and Franklin not even in the race.
The only reason Essendon supporters have noticed Lloyd miss a few lately is because he does it so rarely.

He missed a sitter in that drawn game against us after the siren.

[Nardz]

Paul Medhurst :)

[davomavo]

Richo All The Waay

[NANX]

Jack Riewoldt

[kizzaob]

I don't think richo should be up there, i would never trust him kicking for goal. I would go with fev, he is doing well


Richo is kicking pretty well this year, a lot better than buddy anyway.

[kizzaob]

Mine too. Fantastic kick for goal.


bahahahahahahaha yeh inside 35 and snapping maybe.

[kizzaob]

Jack Riewoldt


yeh real funny, he was 55-60 out after a big game and is still developing, give the kid a break.



if there is one player you wouldn't having kicking for goal, it would be MOORE!!!!!!!

[kizzaob]

Brown or Fev.

Buddy is the most overated kick in the comp, he can kick great goals, but he's not consistant enough. The only thing going for him is that he goes well under pressure.



For the tiges i'd go with Lids or mayb even Simmo.
For the whole comp, Ling, Gilbey, Fev, Brown, Bradshaw, Aka.

[carn tigez]

I don't think richo should be up there, i would never trust him kicking for goal. I would go with fev, he is doing well

24.12 for the year, compared to Buddy's???? 55% at best

[TheBigT]

cameron ling would not miss gaurenteed
absolutely anything from 40 or closer the ball would go sailing through the middle, probably cause theres no pressure on him to kick it cause he already cops enough abuse about his looks

[benny_furs]

Fevola. He's a beautiful kick for goal especially from outside 50.

Interesting.

Fevola is clear 1st, while Richo is clear last in the poll.

Both have similar goal kicking accuracy of 59 and 60% respectively.

Interesting how public perception works ;)

[jonoman89]

currently fevola, a year or two ago lloyd. franklin too innaccurate. richo gets the yips. brown goes ok.

[footy4ever]

BUDDY the @#&**@@##@@!!.

Sunk us with a mighty bomb, last score of 07 hawks/crows final. He knew he had kicked it before he even took his run up.

[ZachPower]

Buddy from most angles.

BUT

If it's tight Motlop all the way!

[Masten2McKinley]

Fev, he is a dead eye dick shooting at goal and would love the occasion

[benny_furs]

Fev, he is a dead eye dick shooting at goal and would love the occasion

This is what I was talking about :cool:

Line Richo and Fev up for 100 shots on goal and Fev would only get 1 more than Richo.

[kizzaob]

This is what I was talking about :cool:

Line Richo and Fev up for 100 shots on goal and Fev would only get 1 more than Richo.

settle.

[donsman4eva]

Id love Stiffy Laycock to be kicking after the siren for us. Problem is getting that close in the first place :p

[Hirdy_5]

Have go with Fevola..

[gandaal]

That's a big No to Matthew Pavlich, and another big No to Brad Johnson.

[blue_n_wyte]

Anyone else remember last year? Lions faced Sydney, Jonathan Brown fifty something meter kick from close to the boundary, siren goes.

Flogs it, straight through the middle, it's a draw.

I can also remember Fevola doing that from the sideline many years ago.

Brown for me.

Yes that's why I voted brown.. Id also love shannon grant from 50 or cam ling an even ablett junior.. Richio I love as a player has been fantastic but his chances of spraying it are very high.. Franklin is like a richio SOMETIMES what's his total goals an behinds telly anyway? An I think llyod should be in there although id take brown over anyone in the comp 9/10 he'd split the middle

[adamania11]

I'd like Richo, but only against a good team that we shouldn't normally be within a kick of in the first place, because it means that Richmond have put up a bloody good effort to get that close in the first place.
If it was a match the team I was supporting was expected to win: i.e. against Essendon, Freo, Melbourne, etc. I would want Fevola out of all of those guys kicking to win the match

[GuzzLG]

LOL

People voting Fevola, or anyone for that matter, ahead of Lloyd.:D:D:D

All 4 are renowned for their poor accuracy.

Meanwhile Lloyd shows why he is clearly the best shot for goal for a key forward YET AGAIN.

Lloyd - 74.2%


*daylight*


Fevola - 64.9%
Richardson - 64.3%
Brown - 64.3%
Franklin - 57.7%

[iGNITER]

From my team Didak.
From the list Fevola.

[#6 Mark Williams]

i agree, i feel so confident when he has the ball in his hand from anywhere.I bet you were utterly disappointed when he hit the post against Geelong.

[#6 Mark Williams]

You clearly have NFI.

Williams is the best set shot in the league. Best technique going around and thrives on the pressure kicks.Are you talking about my Williams? :D

[rainman06]

All you fools who voted Franklin are deluded. He is a terrible set shot for goal. His routine is a hit or miss lucky dip. That stupid late swerve means that he has to hit the ball as it is moving in the wrong direction which leaves such a high percentage risk. Hence why he often spews out those wobbly helicopters. For me it is Lloyd just ahead of Fevola.

[always right]

From the list...Fev
From my team...Robert Murphy or Gilbee. Also no problem with Johnno who has been a clutch goalkicker over his career....except for one particular match:(

[Jordan...]

Pavvo.

[CENTERMAN]

Fev ATM.

[Shane_Mag]

Fevola. I rate him as one of the best kicks for goal in the AFL.

[Powersaur]

Pavlich if you want to hit the post, Fev from outside 50.

[super_phaser]

1.Lance Franklin
2. Matthew Lloyd
3.Jonothan Brown
4. Brendon Fevola
5.Matthew Richardson


no particular order


Brad Green thanks.

[fightingdreamer88]

Nick Gill.