PDA

View Full Version : Crawf reclaims dubious record!


noosa hawk mad
20 May 2008, 13:24
http://sportal.com.au/afl-news-display/crawf-reclaims-dubious-record-48767
http://sportal.com.au/site/_content/leadimage/00020526-image.jpg

Crawf reclaims dubious record

20/05/2008 12:01:41 PM
Paul Gough

Sportal





Former Hawthorn skipper Shane Crawford has reclaimed his record as the player with the worst tribunal record of any current AFL player after accepting a one-match suspension from the match review panel on Tuesday for striking Port Adelaide's Dean Brogan.
The 1999 Brownlow Medallist, who would have risked a two-match suspension had he chose to contest the charge, will miss Sunday's MCG clash against bottom side Melbourne, continuing the unbeaten Hawks' recent poor run at the tribunal.
But his team-mate Ben McGlynn and Port Adelaide star Shaun Burgoyne will face the AFL tribunal on Tuesday night after choosing to contest their charges of rough conduct - resulting from Saturday's clash in Launceston - after both players were reported after making head-high contact while bumping.

http://view.atdmt.com/OAT/view/lssssts80180000030oat/direct/01/6250879 (http://sportal.com.au/)http://ad.au.doubleclick.net/ad/sportalau/afl/home;tile=8;sz=300x250;ord=123456789? (http://ad.au.doubleclick.net/jump/sportalau/afl/home;tile=8;sz=300x250;ord=123456789?)

McGlynn and Burgoyne could have accepted three-match suspensions from the match review panel but will now be risking four-match bans if they are unsuccessful at the tribunal on Tuesday night.
Crawford, a four-time best-and-fairest winner who also missed the first three rounds of this season because of a suspension that carried over from last year's semi-final loss to the Kangaroos, has now been found guilty by the tribunal/match review panel on 12 separate occasions during his 296-game career.
And this latest suspension brings to nine the total number of games he has served in suspensions during that time.
Only three weeks ago Fremantle veteran Josh Carr equalled Crawford's previous record of 11 guilty verdicts when he copped a three-game suspension for kneeing Geelong's Gary Ablett but Carr has served a total of 10 matches in suspensions - one more than Crawford.
Former Carlton and Sydney champion Greg Williams holds the record for most games served in suspensions with 34 while another former Blue and Swan, David Rhys-Jones, is the game's most reported player, having been booked on 25 occasions.
Meanwhile, the Hawks and Port will be sweating on the results of Tuesday's tribunal hearing given the consequences of an unsuccessful plea.
McGlynn is risking 418.75 points for his rough conduct charge against Kane Cornes, which was assessed as reckless conduct, medium impact and high contact.
And Burgoyne is risking the same amount of points for his head-high bump on Hawks' skipper Sam Mitchell - which was assessed as negligent conduct, high impact and high contact.
Even though Mitchell was taken from the field on a stretcher, Port is likely to try to get the high impact downgraded to medium impact given Mitchell was later able to return to the field and play a crucial role in the Hawks' come-from-behind win.
Mitchell went into bat for Burgoyne on Monday saying the first-quarter incident was nowhere near as bad as it looked.
"I have seen it on (television) footage and I was just unlucky," he said.
"It was just one of those things. I turned that way and he just clipped me."
"I don't think it was very hard."
In other tribunal news, Eagles' wingman Matt Rosa accepted a reprimand and 93.75 points towards his future record for striking North's Matt Campbell while Essendon's Kyle Reimers accepted a $1950 fine for making negligent contact with an umpire and Fremantle's Dean Solomon and the Bulldogs' Tom Williams accepted fines for wrestling each other.



Would hate to see him miss any more games as the oldest & most experienced player at our Club! needs to set the example to Lewis Might Mouse & our younger players!

suedehead
20 May 2008, 13:36
Interesting to see that McGlynn is challenging the three-week ban. I reckon he and Burgoyne stand a pretty good chance of getting reductions.

Mitchell Madness
20 May 2008, 13:39
The thing is, if one gets off, the other also will, if the first gets off and the 2nd does not, he will then challenge a 2nd time and force the afls hand:thumbsu:

noosa hawk mad
20 May 2008, 13:56
The thing is, if one gets off, the other also will, if the first gets off and the 2nd does not, he will then challenge a 2nd time and force the afls hand:thumbsu:Burgoyne was stiff IMHO should & will contest!Let's hope Mighty Mouse gets a reduction!:thumbsu:

Mitchell Madness
20 May 2008, 13:57
Burgoyne was stiff IMHO should & will contest!Let's hope Mighty Mouse gets a reduction!:thumbsu:

The thing with that though, is Burgoyne had his knees bent, and arm in, meaning he was going to try and take mitchell out.... People over look that part, and skip right to the fact he "hit" mitchell with his lower back....

Leather Poisoning
20 May 2008, 14:00
Interesting to see that McGlynn is challenging the three-week ban. I reckon he and Burgoyne stand a pretty good chance of getting reductions.

That is interesting - the hawks never challenge!

markr
20 May 2008, 15:36
Neither Burgoyne nor Benny Mac's suspensions could be reduced with an early plea which is why both are challenging.

macdaddio
20 May 2008, 16:01
Burgoyne was stiff IMHO should & will contest!Let's hope Mighty Mouse gets a reduction!:thumbsu:


yer mighty mouse was silly, but burgoynes had a far more serious repercutions having mitch ko,d..

if burgoyne gets of then so must mighty mouse...

lyndhurst
20 May 2008, 16:10
The thing with that though, is Burgoyne had his knees bent, and arm in, meaning he was going to try and take mitchell out.... People over look that part, and skip right to the fact he "hit" mitchell with his lower back....

So he did, and those unmitigated tossers on Fox implied that it was all bad luck, but it is absolutely clear that he made no effort to stop, jumped late into Mitchell and turned his back to try and disguise the charge. Back or no back, he leant into the charge to maximise damage and consequently knocked him out. Nice of mitch to go into bat for him, but the charge should stand, and I hope he hangs for it.

lickmerocks
20 May 2008, 16:44
So he did, and those unmitigated tossers on Fox implied that it was all bad luck, but it is absolutely clear that he made no effort to stop, jumped late into Mitchell and turned his back to try and disguise the charge. Back or no back, he leant into the charge to maximise damage and consequently knocked him out. Nice of mitch to go into bat for him, but the charge should stand, and I hope he hangs for it.

Absolute utter B.S.

Both players came flying in from different angles at a 100 miles per hour and Sam got clipped...BIG DEAL. Its called Football.

Sam only used the stretcher cause we were trying to stop the bleeding for a minute or 2.

Burgoyne should get off.

Mcglynn is one fo my favourites. Puts his head over the ball when its his turn to go. What he did was careless but that is not an excuse to get off. 3 weeks could be argued as too tough but he will end up with 4 now.

What Hank did was just plain dumb.

I know being analytical and honest is difficult for some but the biased rubbish you write is laughable.

Carn Hawkas
20 May 2008, 17:04
Crawf is almost half way there to beating David Rhys-Jones record :P

lyndhurst
20 May 2008, 17:21
Absolute utter B.S.

Both players came flying in from different angles at a 100 miles per hour and Sam got clipped...BIG DEAL. Its called Football.

Sam only used the stretcher cause we were trying to stop the bleeding for a minute or 2.

Burgoyne should get off.

Mcglynn is one fo my favourites. Puts his head over the ball when its his turn to go. What he did was careless but that is not an excuse to get off. 3 weeks could be argued as too tough but he will end up with 4 now.

What Hank did was just plain dumb.

I know being analytical and honest is difficult for some but the biased rubbish you write is laughable.

Ah lickmerocks

Obviously still stinging after the cr@p you wrote 2 days ago was pasted by all and dragged by the moderators.

Not sure who you think I am biased towards.

Keep trying son. Someone will be listening.

Dixie Flatline
20 May 2008, 18:17
McGlynn is trying to have his charge downgraded from reckless to negligent contact.

lickmerocks
20 May 2008, 20:07
Ah lickmerocks

Obviously still stinging after the cr@p you wrote 2 days ago was pasted by all and dragged by the moderators.

Not sure who you think I am biased towards.

Keep trying son. Someone will be listening.

no probs lynn.

unlike yourself i dont get personal on a footy forum but call it exactly how it is.

If you honestly believe that what Crawf did was ok and what Burgoyne did was malicious you obviously dont watch much sport.

Mitchell Madness
20 May 2008, 21:22
So he did, and those unmitigated tossers on Fox implied that it was all bad luck, but it is absolutely clear that he made no effort to stop, jumped late into Mitchell and turned his back to try and disguise the charge. Back or no back, he leant into the charge to maximise damage and consequently knocked him out. Nice of mitch to go into bat for him, but the charge should stand, and I hope he hangs for it.

precisely! but dont forget, the main commentator... sorry special commentator was tony Shaw, has so much built up anger against the Hawks for some reason...

Just glad the port tosser got strung out:)

bak2bak8889
20 May 2008, 21:52
no probs lynn.

unlike yourself i dont get personal on a footy forum but call it exactly how it is.

If you honestly believe that what Crawf did was ok and what Burgoyne did was malicious you obviously dont watch much sport.
THE VERDICT: S.BURGS out for 3. Lost the appeal, why because it was malicious and intentional and downright reckless. Funny how he ACCIDENTLY turned his back twice in one game and hit McMouse and Mitchell... very unlucky......... yeah right