Your Top 5 Favourite Current Swans

[trumby]

Most Popular Officially Brett Kirk

I'm trying to figure out which player is the most popular among our bigfooty fans so if everyone could give a 5-4-3-2-1 vote, 5 being your favourite and 1 being your 5th favourite that would be great. People from different clubs can vote aswell.

I'll update a leaderboard reguarly.

Thanks.

These are the final votes

87 - Brett Kirk
75 - Adam Goodes
62 - Ryan O'Keefe
45 - Tadgh Kennelly
38 - Nick Malceski
31 - Michael O'Loughlin
26 - Craig Bolton
17 - Nick Davis
17 - Jared Moore
16 - Amon Buchanan
12 - Kieren Jack
12 - Lewis Roberts-Thomson
10 - Barry Hall
10 - Luke Ablett
8 - Ted Richards
8 - Leo Barry
7 - Darren Jolly
7 - Jude Bolton
6 - Craig Bird
6 - Martin Mattner
6 - Henry Playfair
5 - Ben Matthews
5 - Nic Fosdike
3 - Peter Everitt
3 - Ed Barlow
2 - Jarrad McVeigh
1 - Paul Bevan

[MalceskiFan]

5. Brett Kirk
4. Adam Goodes
3. Craig Bolton
2. Ryan O'Keefe
1. Nick Malceski

[Hooley McBoob]

5. Craig Bolton
4. Brett Kirk
3. Ted Richards
2. Darren Jolly
1. Ryan O'Keefe

[mitch820]

5. Ryan O'Keefe
4. Darren Jolly
3. Michael O'Loughlin
2. Jarred Moore
1. Ed Barlow

[potatomasher]

5. Lewis Roberts-Thomson - not our most talented by any stretch of the imagination, but you have to like him
4. Brett Kirk
3. Jarred Moore (bandwagoning)
2. Adam Goodes
1. Nick Malceski

[Hooley McBoob]

I think LRT would be -5 for me :D

[Hooley McBoob]

I wonder if Soph will put Adam Schneider as one of her faves?

[Jaymeee]

5- Kennelly
4- Kirk
3- MOL
2- Goodes
1- ROK

[bonzaburgers]

5. Kennely
4. Goodes
3. Barry
2. Kirk
1. Davis (Folklore prevails)

[No1SwansFan]

5 - Richards
4 - Kennelly
3 - Davis
2 - Lewie
1 - Malceski

[grimlock]

5. Malceski
4. Goodes
3. Kennelly
2. Kirk
1. Craig Bolton

[natlovestheswans]

1. Leo Barry
2. Tadhg Kennelly
3. Nick Malceski
4. Lewis Roberts-Thomson
5. Keiran Jack

[SOPH_CROSS]

5. JARRED MOORE my future husband
4. Luke Ablett
3. Craig Bird
2. Jack
1. Amon

[funkyfetlock]

5. Kirk
4. Malceski
3. Goodes
2. Craig Bolton
1. O'Keefe

[BIGBEZ]

Not alot of love for Hall in here?

[ssfc0203]

5 Nick Davis
4 Ryan O'Keefe
3 Adam Goodes
2 Brett Kirk
1 Tadhg Kennelly

[is2SWaNz]

5. Amon Buchanan
4. Brett Kirk
3. Adam Goodes
2. Nick Malceski
1. Jarrad McVeigh

[J-swan]

5. Craig Bolton






4. Ryan O'keefe
3. Nick Davis
2. Nic Fosdike
1. Marty Mattner (only 10 games for us but I love the way he plays)

[big ed]

5 N Davis
4B Hall
3ROK
2Amon
1Micky O

[Chinners100]

5. k jack
4. M O Loughlin
3. B kirk
2. A goodes
1. B hall (gives that presence that makes other teams fear us)

[SouthSwans]

5. Ben Mathews
4. Nick Malceski
3. Craig Bolton
2. Brett Kirk
1. Jarred Moore

[SouthSwans]

I think LRT would be -5 for me :D
-39 for me. We have 44 on our list dont we? :p

[BFC101]

5.Kirk
4.Ablett
3.Fosdike
2.O'Keefe
1.Bevan

[MalceskiFan]

Not alot of love for Hall in here?

I originally had him at number 5 but I think his "brainsnap" this year cost him a spot or two in my eyes. He'd make my 7.

[royboy2]

6. P Roos
5. C Bolton
4. J Bolton
3. R O Keefe
2. Jack
1. Hall

[J-swan]

6. P Roos
5. C Bolton
4. J Bolton
3. R O Keefe
2. Jack
1. Hall
Nice touch

[voodooguru]

Captain K
Too Goodes
T-Dhgiddy
Muhammad
Bionic
Honourable Mention: J-Mo, WPIF, El Queso Grande

[Hooley McBoob]

Captain K
Too Goodes
T-Dhgiddy
Muhammad
Bionic
Honourable Mention: J-Mo, WPIF, El Queso Grande

I have no idea who T-Dhgiddy, Muhammad, WPIF and El whatever are :confused:

[Hooley McBoob]

-39 for me. We have 44 on our list dont we? :p

Haha. I concur wholeheartedly.

GRRRR LRT! :thumbsd:

[Footbrawler]

1. Goodesy
2. Hally
3. Kirky
4. Kennelly
5. Mickey O

[voodooguru]

I have no idea who T-Dhgiddy, Muhammad, WPIF and El whatever are :confused:


T-Dhgiddy
Muhammad - who else could it be?
WPIF - Worst Player In Football
El Queso Grande - don't be such a xenophobic wowser

[lazy]

5- Kennelly
4- Kirk
3- MOL
2- Goodes
1- ROK

Thats My top 5 but slightly moved around

5 Goodes
4 Micky O
3 Kirk
2 ROK
1. Kennelly

[The Whisper05]

5. Matner
4. Kirk
3. Bird
2. Goodes
1. C Bolton

[Tuco]

I seriously cannot restrain my list to a mere top 5. Watching our old stagers playing so enthusiastically alongside so many exciting young players...no...just can't do it.

[EatBig Australia]

Goodes
O'Keefe
Micky O
LRT
Malceski

[Liesha]

5. Kennelly
4. Micky O
3. Spida (has been one of my favourites since his St Kilda days)
2. Goodes
1. McVeigh

Kieran Jack just misses my top 5 at the moment.

[lifelike_]

5. O'Keefe
4. Kirk
3. Kennelly
2. Malceski
1. Goodes

[Costanza_]

So many possible criterion, hard to narrow it down to five. But the players I most love to watch...

5. Kennelly
4. Malceski
3. Kirk
2. O'Loughlin
1. Goodes

C.Bolton, O'Keefe, Leo, and Moore are all unlucky to miss out.

[ripitup27]

5. R.O'Keefe
4. B.Kirk
3. H.Playfair
2. A.Buchanan
1. L.Ablett

[Rhino5]

5. O'Keefe
4. Goodes
3. Kirk
2. Barlow
1. Jack

[J-swan]

5. R.O'Keefe
4. B.Kirk
3. H.Playfair
2. A.Buchanan
1. L.Ablett

Good on you Geelong person for your vote for Henry. As he's only played 3 games for us, I couldn't fit him in, but I'm feelin' the lurve for him more and more each week. :thumbsu:

[Hooley McBoob]

Good on you Geelong person for your vote for Henry. As he's only played 3 games for us, I couldn't fit him in, but I'm feelin' the lurve for him more and more each week. :thumbsu:

Ditto! I love Henry! He's such a gumby, but for some reason I just like him. Plus, he is my friend's cousin.

[Silky]

5. A.Goodes
4. J. Moore
3. N. Malceski
2. R. O'Keefe
1. K. Jack


Can anyone advise me of who is Adam Goodes manager? I am currently doing a case study on him and need this information.

A post reply or PM would be much appreciated.

Cheers in advance

[SouthSwans]

Ditto! I love Henry! He's such a gumby, but for some reason I just like him. Plus, he is my friend's cousin.
We only need one goofy looking, 190cm+, slack-jawed yokel.

Henry > LRT.

[Jeffers1984]

5. Kirk
4. Goodes
3. Magic
2. Malceski
1. Buchanan

[bedford]

5. A.Goodes
4. J. Moore
3. N. Malceski
2. R. O'Keefe
1. K. Jack


Can anyone advise me of who is Adam Goodes manager? I am currently doing a case study on him and need this information.

A post reply or PM would be much appreciated.

Cheers in advance
Paul Conners who also manages Judd,his office is in Hawthorn rd. East Brighton

[Spuddy23]

5. Malceski
4. O'Keefe
3. J.Bolton
2. Kirk
1. Jolly

[search and destroy]

5) Buchanan
4) O'Keefe
3) Playfair
2) Goodes
1) Kennelly

[Lakeside Legacy]

Not alot of love for Hall in here?

Agreed BB, out of sight out of mind. I am sure in a few weeks after he has helped to shake what life is left out of St. Kilda, THE LUFF for BIGBEZ will return. It is hard to limit to just 5 favs at the moment. As Bruce McAveney would say in his best gravally tone the Swans are "SPECIAL".

[trumby]

As there are 2 players that could finish out on top, I will stop taking votes on "June 3rd at 8pm Eastern Time". When that time is up a result on most popular will be decided.

[Skystyler]

5. Kirk
4. Goodes
3. O'loughlin
2. O'keefe
1. Bolton C

[bedford]

5 Goodes
4 Kirk
3 O'keefe
2 Kennelly
1 Ablett

[cardiff_city]

5. CAPTAIN Kirk
4. Irish
3. Goodesy
2. Cannon Ball (Jarad Moore)
1. LRT

[funkyfetlock]

Updated after #49

73 - Brett Kirk
63 - Adam Goodes
57 - Ryan O'Keefe
39 - Tadgh Kennelly
38 - Nick Malceski
28 - Michael O'Loughlin
25 - Craig Bolton
17 - Nick Davis
16 - Amon Buchanan
15 - Jared Moore
12 - Kieren Jack
11 - Lewis Roberts-Thomson
10 - Barry Hall
9 - Luke Ablett
8 - Ted Richards
8 - Leo Barry
7 - Darren Jolly
7 - Jude Bolton
6 - Craig Bird
6 - Martin Mattner
6 - Henry Playfair
5 - Ben Matthews
5 - Nic Fosdike
3 - Peter Everitt
3 - Ed Barlow
2 - Jarrad McVeigh
1 - Paul Bevan


Well time is almost up. Have to say that I am more than happy with the top 7 including the order. A little surprised that LRT and Davis have rated so highly and surprised that Leaping Leo didn't even make the top 15.

Most important thing though is that it looks like Kirky made the number one spot and that is as it should be.

[bedford]

Well time is almost up. Have to say that I am more than happy with the top 7 including the order. A little surprised that LRT and Davis have rated so highly and surprised that Leaping Leo didn't even make the top 15.

Most important thing though is that it looks like Kirky made the number one spot and that is as it should be.
And interesting how low Mchack is.

[SouthSwans]

Yeah McHack is pushing, he'd be just on the edge of my top 10, needs a little more time being less hacky and he'll be there.

I see Benny's only votes came from me.... :(

[lovetheswannies]

not sure if this will make the deadline...

5 Malceski
4 Kennelly
3 Kirk
2 Buchanan
1 Micky

[MalceskiFan]

Yeah McHack is pushing, he'd be just on the edge of my top 10, needs a little more time being less hacky and he'll be there.

I see Benny's only votes came from me.... :(

Yeah, sorry about that. He was in my top 5 but a lack of senior action this year coupled with a pretty poor performance in the one game he did play has pushed him out :(

I'll always have a soft spot for Benny though:thumbsu:

[Dudley]

Quite amusing how far off this is from first 5 picked because of the jobs they have done.

IMHO

pick 1 = Goodes

pick 2 = Kirk

pick 3 = C Bolton

pick 4 = Tidagheh

Pick 5 = J Bolton


6-9 Jolly, Ablett, Magic, Mcveigh

[funkyfetlock]

Jude at pick number 5 you think? Maybe last year but not so sure this year.

[Dudley]

Yep, does his job week in week out

hard ball get extraordinaire, makes others blokes back off, think i may have under-rated his importance to us.

Disposal ordinary, but he gives us heaps, every other team in comp rates him, why ?

["Copperplate"]

Hall
O'Keefe
Kennely
Currie
Veszpremi