View Full Version : Could we see McGuane up forward on Saturday kicking a swag?
TigerTroy0055
5 Jun 2008, 23:24
My guess is yes although I'd rather him down back than Polak. Polak is poo in the backline. Why is Morton not in the side and Pettifer in the side. Why are people so unkind?
Why can't they drop Bowden and let Collins or Connors play in the forward line. They'd be good for 3 goals a game.
Why will they do with Tivendale what they've done with Hyde. It will pain me to watch Tivendale not put his head over the ball on Saturday. Then get dropped to Coburg get best on ground , get promoted again and play crap again. I say his career is on the line on Saturday. Hyde should never return.
dgtigers72
5 Jun 2008, 23:26
My guess is yes although I'd rather him down back than Polak. Polak is poo in the backline. Why is Morton not in the side and Pettifer in the side. Why are people so unkind?
Why can't they drop Bowden and let Collins or Connors play in the forward line. They'd be good for 3 goals a game.
Why will they do with Tivendale what they've done with Hyde. It will pain me to watch Tivendale not put his head over the ball on Saturday. Then get dropped to Coburg get best on ground , get promoted again and play crap again. I say his career is on the line on Saturday. Hyde should never return.
Thanks for the post Kamahl.....:thumbsu:
polakthetiger
5 Jun 2008, 23:35
Thanks for the post Kamahl.....:thumbsu:
LMOA....spat my coffee with that one DGT. Gold!!
carn tigez
5 Jun 2008, 23:41
Thanks for the post Kamahl.....:thumbsu:
:confused::confused::confused:
RichosGuns
5 Jun 2008, 23:52
Wouldn't suprise me if he is a late exclusion TT. You would think at least one of him Patto or Polak will be left out of the starting 22. Very top heavy
TigerTroy0055
6 Jun 2008, 00:05
Wouldn't suprise me if he is a late exclusion TT. You would think at least one of him Patto or Polak will be left out of the starting 22. Very top heavyWe are a bit tall but imagine if Essendon ad a marking forward last week. Loyd did his usual (rolling around on the ground playing for free kicks) and lucas was well under done. I think TW is onto something.
bigrayohall20
6 Jun 2008, 09:03
I think we can expose their lack of height if we can play a big forward line. They might have to play a few players away from their comfort zones which will help us a lot.
I think we can expose their lack of height if we can play a big forward line. They might have to play a few players away from their comfort zones which will help us a lot.
Except when the ball hits the deck down forward and the Crows backline run it out like a mofo.
Thanks for the post Kamahl.....:thumbsu:
lmaooooooooo exactly what I thought reading the OP:D:D
How's McGuane's goalkicking?....surely better than Polak:o Has McGuane even kicked a goal at AFL level?
His field kicking is pretty hit and miss
CamWallace16
6 Jun 2008, 11:53
Polak has kicked 21 goals in 102 games.
McGuane has kicked 0 goals in 21 games.
kicking is pretty ordinary so I think im going to stick with Polak.:)
bigrayohall20
6 Jun 2008, 12:12
Polak has kicked 21 goals in 102 games.
McGuane has kicked 0 goals in 21 games.
kicking is pretty ordinary so I think im going to stick with Polak.:)
Has he had an opportunity though??
I'm sure he played up forward as a junior.
bigrayohall20
6 Jun 2008, 12:13
Except when the ball hits the deck down forward and the Crows backline run it out like a mofo.
Well that happens every week to us so i wouldnt be surprised.
tucker777
6 Jun 2008, 15:45
Polak has kicked 21 goals in 102 games.
McGuane has kicked 0 goals in 21 games.
kicking is pretty ordinary so I think im going to stick with Polak.:)
what a completely useless stat:thumbsd:
Polak has played up forward at AFL level
McGuane hasnt
CoggaRules
6 Jun 2008, 16:20
My guess is yes although I'd rather him down back than Polak. Polak is poo in the backline. Why is Morton not in the side and Pettifer in the side. Whyare people so unkind?
Why can't they drop Bowden and let Collins or Connors play in the forward line. They'd be good for 3 goals a game.
Why will they do with Tivendale what they've done with Hyde. It will pain me to watch Tivendale not put his head over the ball on Saturday. Then get dropped to Coburg get best on ground , get promoted again and play crap again. I say his career is on the line on Saturday. Hyde should never return.
dude, this would have to be the most useless post known to mankind.
So the title of the thread says, "Could we see McGuane up forward on Saturday kicking a swag", correct?
and your answer is a four word "guess" at the beginning and then you go off on a ridiculously stupidity riddled post that talks about anyone but Luke. Not to mention your affixation with Collins..FFS what a load of utter ____ing BS. ;)
Mario Speedwagon
6 Jun 2008, 16:46
dude, this would have to be the most useless post known to mankind.
So the title of the thread says, "Could we see McGuane up forward on Saturday kicking a swag", correct?
and your answer is a four word "guess" at the beginning and then you go off on a ridiculously stupidity riddled post that talks about anyone but Luke. Not to mention your affixation with Collins..FFS what a load of utter ____ing BS. ;)
Haha exactly........yet this is the same nupty who criticises others for not knowing anything about footy.:o
TigerTroy0055
6 Jun 2008, 18:34
If McGuane lines up in the forward line at some stage does that qualify me to know any thing about footy Mario. If he does and he kicks 3 or more that does qualify me even more.
Have we got the best forward line in the comp that doesn't need tweaking to make it better. Is McGuane a foot taller and just as fit as 75% of our forward line. Are the other 25% of our forward line that are as tall as him kicking 3 or more goals a game.
Well , I say give him a run and find out. He's got a great grab on him.
CoggaRules
6 Jun 2008, 18:43
If McGuane lines up in the forward line at some stage does that qualify me to know any thing about footy Mario. If he does and he kicks 3 or more that does qualify me even more.
Have we got the best forward line in the comp that doesn't need tweaking to make it better. Is McGuane a foot taller and just as fit as 75% of our forward line. Are the other 25% of our forward line that are as tall as him kicking 3 or more goals a game.
Well , I say give him a run and find out. He's got a great grab on him.
yeah,.....but "when he doesnt line up" and "when he doesnt kick 3 or more" then that will qualify you as having NFI with a diploma. ;)
jockey-sized midfielder
6 Jun 2008, 19:01
My guess is yes although I'd rather him down back than Polak. Polak is poo in the backline. Why is Morton not in the side and Pettifer in the side. Why are people so unkind?
Why can't they drop Bowden and let Collins or Connors play in the forward line. They'd be good for 3 goals a game.
Why will they do with Tivendale what they've done with Hyde. It will pain me to watch Tivendale not put his head over the ball on Saturday. Then get dropped to Coburg get best on ground , get promoted again and play crap again. I say his career is on the line on Saturday. Hyde should never return.
Why does no one rate Polly down back? He played his best football as a loose man roaming around the backline taking contested grabs. Easily made top 10 in our B&F couple of years ago/last year?
How's McGuane's goalkicking?....surely better than Polak:o Has McGuane even kicked a goal at AFL level?
His field kicking is pretty hit and miss
That's better than some of our blokes whose field kicking is pretty "miss and miss."
BTW Cogga, try "fixation" you angry, angry man.
tucker777
7 Jun 2008, 00:46
Why does no one rate Polly down back? He played his best football as a loose man roaming around the backline taking contested grabs. Easily made top 10 in our B&F couple of years ago/last year?
thing was he didnt take enough of those contested grabs and he didnt create any forward momentum when he got the footy...mcmahon at least creates or tries to create run from our backline
plus we now have a guy that plays loose and takes contested marks everywhere
Richo!!!
jockey-sized midfielder
7 Jun 2008, 01:01
thing was he didnt take enough of those contested grabs and he didnt create any forward momentum when he got the footy...mcmahon at least creates or tries to create run from our backline
plus we now have a guy that plays loose and takes contested marks everywhere
Richo!!!
touche'
TigerTroy0055
7 Jun 2008, 11:05
yeah,.....but "when he doesnt line up" and "when he doesnt kick 3 or more" then that will qualify you as having NFI with a diploma. ;)
If that happens then I will throw my hands in the air and shout to the mountain tops. " Its official I Tiger Troy am a useless Twat like Cogga Rules , I am now an official member of the Cogga Rules , I have no F#cken idea club" I will happily throw my hat in the ring with you and Mario but I will have to get some tips on how to be an abusive wanker Cogga. I'm sure it won't take long because you do it with so much ease!
RichosGuns
7 Jun 2008, 13:12
If that happens then I will throw my hands in the air and shout to the mountain tops. " Its official I Tiger Troy am a useless Twat like Cogga Rules , I am now an official member of the Cogga Rules , I have no F#cken idea club" I will happily throw my hat in the ring with you and Mario but I will have to get some tips on how to be an abusive wanker Cogga. I'm sure it won't take long because you do it with so much ease!
get arcked up ;)
TigerTroy0055
8 Jun 2008, 05:26
get arcked up ;)No just wanted you to see it, didn't think for a minute that you'd be back