PDA

View Full Version : Which Half-Forward Flank would you take?

Houli2Gumbleton
9 Jun 2008, 12:35
which one?
hellfire
9 Jun 2008, 12:36
That one.
Houli2Gumbleton
9 Jun 2008, 12:37
That one.

have another look at the thread
hellfire
9 Jun 2008, 12:39
have another look at the thread

Went with the Chap-daddy.

Okeefe second.
doggiesin08
9 Jun 2008, 12:43
Murphy probably better than Gia for the dogs.
Houli2Gumbleton
9 Jun 2008, 12:50
I know there are better ones. I just couldn't split these four so i decided to create a poll.
hendo8888
9 Jun 2008, 13:01
Chapman and RO'K are about even
SJ and Gia are about even but not as good as the other 2
Camo1902
9 Jun 2008, 13:04
none of em, i'll stick with Didak
Houli2Gumbleton
9 Jun 2008, 13:05
none of em, i'll stick with Didak

I know there are better ones. I just couldn't split these four so i decided to create a poll.

I know there are better forwards ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Carn Hawkas
9 Jun 2008, 19:39
Chapman, would suit our rough game style.
cormick
9 Jun 2008, 20:05
I went Chapman before i realised that SJ was Steve Johnson...duh.

So Steve Johnson just from Chapman
Cerpin Taxt
9 Jun 2008, 20:25
SJ because he's capable of kicking bags of goals.
Claude Balls
10 Jun 2008, 12:36
none of em, i'll stick with Didak

There's always one half witted supporter who comes up with this shit. Do you see Didak as part of the question Einstein?
Palmer Stoat
10 Jun 2008, 14:18
Chapman for mine. Very, very good player.
jimmy.h
10 Jun 2008, 15:13
If SJ is Steve Johnson, then him by a mile.
Benchwarmer77
10 Jun 2008, 16:24
O'Keefe for me
walkers a legend
10 Jun 2008, 20:52
O'keefe
Ron
10 Jun 2008, 21:31
O'Keefe or Chapman.

Gia is more of a winger i reckon, wouldn't really be playing him forward, well not in front of any of the other three anyway. SJ is a massive frontrunner, when the team struggles he goes missing.
trumby
10 Jun 2008, 23:29
SJ 4 $ure
jimmy.h
12 Jun 2008, 14:34
SJ is a massive frontrunner, when the team struggles he goes missing.

In the 7 games he played in last year where they opponents got within 5 goals of us, he kicked 20 goals (2.9 a game). In the games we won by more than 5 goals, he kicked 28 (2.2 a game).

This year in games we have struggled (Collingwood, Port, Sydney, North and Freo) he has kicked 11 (2.2 a game) and in games when we weren't pushed he has kicked 12 (2.3 a game).

If anything, Johnno plays better in the closer games than he does in the cat's floggings
Claude Balls
12 Jun 2008, 15:34
O'Keefe has a fantastic work rate and is a very good mark, though as far as I'm aware, his scoreboard influence is minimal. I'm happy to be shown some statistical and qualitative reasoning to the contrary, from someone who no doubt would watch him more often... like a Sydney supporter.

Chappy's lead up work is just as good as O'Keefe's, while he is more dangerous close to goal, kicking quite a few and setting up even more.

SJ is the most prolific goal kicker of those four players. That counts for something.

Anyway I voted Chappy. Still a great player despite being hampered with injuries the last 18months. His 2006 was phenomenal.