View Full Version : Buddy or Fev?
Hodgepodge
16 Jun 2008, 16:19
Buddy kicked 1.6 on the weekend, Fev kicked 8 . . .
Have at it, jackals!
Fev has more talent, and is a team player - something Franklin never will be. :)
Hodgepodge
16 Jun 2008, 16:33
parrot you make me laugh
woods_gun
16 Jun 2008, 16:37
both talented but buddy is a freak.
Benchwarmer77
16 Jun 2008, 16:39
Fev has more talent, and is a team player - something Franklin never will be. :)
Planning to grow that 2nd eye any time soon parrot ??? :D
Carn Hawkas
16 Jun 2008, 16:40
Buddy is better.
Fevola is too selfish.
Buddys the best forward in the competition. I cant split him and Gablett for the best in the comp yet.
Schmick
16 Jun 2008, 18:52
Buddy is Fevola and Cyril rolled into one unit. Of course Buddy.
jonoman89
16 Jun 2008, 18:53
Buddy because he is a CHF, therefore more valuable.
Fevola is the best FF in the competition by the length of the flemington straight though.
Buddy is better.
Fevola is too selfish.
Most hypocritical post of the day.
Fevola's defensive game shits all over Franklin's, even though Franklin is the better forward at the moment.
blues4flag
16 Jun 2008, 20:33
Most hypocritical post of the day.
Fevola's defensive game shits all over Franklin's, even though Franklin is the better forward at the moment.
Exactly.
Franklin.
Can play anywhere, also a better forward than Fev.
Also only 21.
Buddy anyday.
Fevola is a wanker.
HolyWars
16 Jun 2008, 20:48
Buddy, but I really like Fev and is a great forward.:thumbsu:
patto_man
16 Jun 2008, 21:07
id probably say fev because he is a better shot for goal and is usually consistent at scoring goals and is in better form at the moment
Hodgepodge
16 Jun 2008, 21:14
Buddy because he is a CHF, therefore more valuable.
Fevola is the best FF in the competition by the length of the flemington straight though.
What about Bradshaw? Is Buddy a CHF? I don't know . . . that position hardly exists anymore. . . he definitely is a roaming forward though, the richardson/riewoldt/cloke type who can go all over the ground.
Mitchell Madness
16 Jun 2008, 21:18
id probably say fev because he is a better shot for goal and is usually consistent at scoring goals and is in better form at the moment
buddy has 1 "POOR" game every 5 or so matches. so does fev... Franklin has 60 goals, Fev 50..... umm... care to try again?:o
Buddy had 21 possie's on the weekend 8 shots on goal, 9 last quarter judd like posessions and a crucial 60 metre goal to become hawthorns best last quarter midfielder and that was supposed to be a bad game for 21 year old forward, he's a freak and the best by a country mile. When he is beaten by a defender like bock did can be a damaging 196cm midfielder would give anything to have him.
jonoman89
16 Jun 2008, 21:34
What about Bradshaw? Is Buddy a CHF? I don't know . . . that position hardly exists anymore. . . he definitely is a roaming forward though, the richardson/riewoldt/cloke type who can go all over the ground.
I put Fev above Bradshaw because A) Fev doesn't have consistent midfield delivery like Bradshaw B) He's been more consistent over his career.
Hodgepodge
16 Jun 2008, 21:39
I put Fev above Bradshaw because A) Fev doesn't have consistent midfield delivery like Bradshaw B) He's been more consistent over his career.
He has judd and 3 #1 picks banging the ball into him. Your team's in the 8 now, you can't make those excuses anymore.
tigers_of_old_08
16 Jun 2008, 21:56
A simple look at the goal tally - Buddy hands down. :rolleyes:
stevedarui
16 Jun 2008, 22:12
Interesting poll Fev has problems with alcohol and Buddy has problems with injunctions.
Buddy short term and if he can overcome his problem with injunctions long term as well.
Luke_Hodgey_15
16 Jun 2008, 22:49
buddy any day of the week
what can't the man do
(before you say play in the backline i think he could he's quick and tall no player could get past him(not that he would ever be put there))
wce4premiership
16 Jun 2008, 22:52
Buddy all the way.