PDA

View Full Version : What would these West Coast players fetch?


RichosGuns
22 Jun 2008, 14:54
After watching West Coast last night it would seem that they will be looking to clean their list out at the end of the year. Therefore what do you think the trade value of these players are:
- Staker
- A Hansen
- Seaby
- Fletcher
- Braun
- Selwood
- Stenglein
- Armstrong

dyl_tigerman
22 Jun 2008, 15:20
- Staker - 2nd round pick
- A Hansen - 3rd plus player
- Seaby - nothing
- Fletcher - not much
- Braun - 2nd or 3rd
- Selwood - 3rd or 4th
- Stenglein - probably the highest of the lot 1st or 2nd
- Armstrong - unsure


these players are alll premiership players so they would be a little handy.... i would have staker down at tigerland with maybe steinglien

Prem87
22 Jun 2008, 16:00
Staker - 2nd/3rd round pick
A Hansen - late 2nd
Seaby - early 2nd
Fletcher - worthless + too old
Braun - will retire
Selwood - untouchable
Stenglein - 3rd - too old
Armstrong - worthless

Demons 21
22 Jun 2008, 17:03
After watching the game last night Hansen has to be a very late 2nd or 3rd he was hopeless. So was Braun Fletcher and Selwood all was crap. Armstrong is too old and doesnt kick enough goals when he has a chance so he is worthless. Staker has value cause of his size from watching he was going alright in the forward line the past couple of games.

Kram81
22 Jun 2008, 17:03
- Staker - 3rd round
- A Hansen - 2nd/3rd round
- Seaby - 3rd round
- Fletcher - nothing, a hack
- Braun - old and crap now
- Selwood - won't trade
- Stenglein - 4th round
- Armstrong - nothing, a hack

WaltzingMatera
22 Jun 2008, 18:22
I'd think that we would get the most for Seaby.

MickyCrow
22 Jun 2008, 18:50
Josh Carr back to Port, Tyson Stenglien back to the Crows:D

Masten2McKinley
22 Jun 2008, 19:03
- Staker - 3rd round
- A Hansen - 3rd round
- Seaby - early 2nd
- Fletcher - nothing
- Braun - nothing
- Selwood - 2nd round (one of our best players)
- Stenglein - 3rd round (getting old and doesnt look when he kicks)
- Armstrong - nothing

weagles_fan
22 Jun 2008, 19:22
Staker - 2nd/3rd round
A Hansen - 3rd round/nothing
Seaby - 2nd round
Fletcher - nothing
Braun - nothing
Selwood - Wont be traded
Stenglein - 2nd/3rd round
Armstrong - nothing

TheBigUnit
22 Jun 2008, 19:23
I'd think that we would get the most for Seaby.

Agree. He has the most upside out of the names mentioned. He's shown with greater responsibility/TOG he can produce some very good footy, unfortunately that'll never happen when Cox is in the team.

Selwood and Seaby would definitely attract interest and have some value, the others I'm unsure would attract any and have little if any value.

UpTheGuts
22 Jun 2008, 20:58
what about jaymie graham?

UpTheGuts
22 Jun 2008, 20:59
I say again.... GF teams should always be the biggest traders.... imagine what Hansen would have got 20 months ago?

Embers
22 Jun 2008, 21:12
Staker to Bulldogs. He would eat it up at that club. 2nd rounder.

Ash Hansen - Keep around because he has no value

Mark Seaby - Keep around till Gold Coast need a ruckman

Fletcher - Will retire

Braun - Will retire

Selwood - Untradeable

Stenglein - Too old

Armstrong - Delisted.

Our trade bait would be our KPPs. Staker, Chad Jones, Jaymie Grahan, Eric McKenzie all have some value. The midfielders we have, we have to keep cos we have no depth in that spot at all

Viva la Mattner
23 Jun 2008, 10:55
give them a 3rd rounder and bring Stinga back to the crows!