View Full Version : Goodes Is Gone
ran off the line and collected Bartram in the head, no eyes for the ball.
the only question is how many weeks
swanniez1983
22 Jun 2008, 14:58
ran off the line and collected Bartram in the head, no eyes for the ball.
the only question is how many weeks
Do you really need to be told the answer?? ;)
darcytiger
22 Jun 2008, 15:02
unless he shanked him with a bit of broken glass, prison break style. I'd say 0 weeks and all his carry over points taken off, because he is such a nice person.
flukeyluke
22 Jun 2008, 15:02
Is it Groudhog day:confused:
Each week this question gets asked and each week the answer is the same.
So the answer is zero weeks.
jacko57
22 Jun 2008, 15:03
ran off the line and collected Bartram in the head, no eyes for the ball.
the only question is how many weeks
Mate, if he didn't actually use a samurai sword, we all know he'll get off.
It wasnt even bad enough for the tribunal to take a look at it. A free kick at most.
Anti-pow
22 Jun 2008, 15:06
unless he shanked him with a bit of broken glass, prison break style. I'd say 0 weeks and all his carry over points taken off, because he is such a nice person.
depends on the shank really, Low force, slipped with shank so maybe reckless
and if he missed all the vital organs i would say 125 points, take an early plea and get a reprimand :p
jerry springer
22 Jun 2008, 15:08
unfortunatly nothing in it
ChuckNorris
22 Jun 2008, 15:11
Bartram will be cited for making unnecessary contact with his head to Goodes. He should know better.;)
Goodes could line up an umpire and not get weeks, protected species of the highest order.
Duskfire
22 Jun 2008, 15:13
Goodes would have to stroll on the field and take out five players with an uzi before the AFL would think about suspending him. And they would be like, "well, if the players weren't in the way of the bullets..."
sneakydaycrawler
22 Jun 2008, 15:18
Bartram will be cited for making unnecessary contact with his head to Goodes. He should know better.;)
Thats ____ing gold.:D:thumbsu:
94_Eagles
22 Jun 2008, 15:19
Its Goodes. Duh.
He's got off for far worse.
Anyone else, 1 week. Goodes? will probably get a written apology from the ump that booked him
Bloods_33
22 Jun 2008, 15:21
ran off the line and collected Bartram in the head, no eyes for the ball.
the only question is how many weeks
what a load of rubbish tyson stenglein from west coast did the same in the opening bounce of our game against west coast were was your post then, youre a joke.
legend166
22 Jun 2008, 15:22
Absolutely kidding yourselves. Ran off the line? He was going directly for the ball. You can see his eyes go directly for the ball.
This is the softest thing Goodes has ever done.
rusdid24
22 Jun 2008, 15:28
Look I haven't seen it but he deserves 1 week, no more. :p
Banyo Bloods
22 Jun 2008, 15:29
Absolutely kidding yourselves. Ran off the line? He was going directly for the ball. You can see his eyes go directly for the ball.
This is the softest thing Goodes has ever done.
Agreed - Deserved a free kick move on to next topic
Goodes protected species blah blah blah :thumbsd:
hellfire
22 Jun 2008, 15:30
Look I haven't seen it but he deserves 1 week, no more. :p
He's in my SC, so I'm totally objective here....
1 week. :thumbsu:
Teak_Pies
22 Jun 2008, 15:31
He has carry over points. Will get 1 week.
Messenger
22 Jun 2008, 15:31
Look I haven't seen it but he deserves 1 week, no more. :p
Neither have I but 2 weeks seems fair to me;)
He's got off for far worse.
Anyone else, 1 week. Goodes? will probably get a written apology from the ump that booked him
But he hasn't been reported :confused:...
Some idiots have got to the point of if Goodes gives away a free kick he must be gone.
NQTIGER
22 Jun 2008, 16:04
Wow the sydney ppl get defensive whenever the sniper does anything
davey_magik
22 Jun 2008, 16:26
Considering how cheap and dirty he is, it'd be nice if he went for this, even if it doesn't warrant weeks.
Rik E Boy
22 Jun 2008, 16:29
ran off the line and collected Bartram in the head, no eyes for the ball.
the only question is how many weeks
Er...nothing in it. Just like that dodgy 50 that ended the game as a contest. Shocking umpiring.
regards,
REB
about time he went
but he wont
do carry over points mean nothing when we are talking to Protected Species Adam Goodes :mad:
DeadlyAkkuret
22 Jun 2008, 19:54
Pathetic thread.
Fair enough if he actually did something worth complaining about, but that was as soft as it gets!
DeadlyAkkuret
22 Jun 2008, 19:59
Wow the sydney ppl get defensive whenever the sniper does anything
Yeah we get defensive when one of our players is attacked for something that only warranted a free kick. What a suprise:o
ams4crows
22 Jun 2008, 21:35
I will piss myself if he cops a week for this because of the carry over points he only needs 7 points
If he goes then football is dead it'll become netball soon enough!
When last I checked, the head was protected so all you who think he should get nothing, need to actually look at the incident and tell me what part of head-high contact he didn't commit.
DeadlyAkkuret
23 Jun 2008, 03:55
Look I haven't seen it but he deserves 1 week, no more. :p
Lol yeah pay that. Some of Adam's best games have been against the Pies, but it's a shame the rest of the team never shows up.
The Sim Dog
23 Jun 2008, 05:27
Where gonna hear all sorts of stuff about this unfortunately because of what he has been let off for in the past.
Problem is this time I really don't see anything in it. Contact was barely made at all. No case to answer.
Bloody Hell
23 Jun 2008, 08:13
unfortunatly nothing in it
Just about sums up all the Goodes "hysteria".
ChisBlues
25 Jun 2008, 13:41
Just about sums up all the Goodes "hysteria".
No hysteria,
Goodes is protected by the AFL. Deserved two weeks.
ChisBlues
25 Jun 2008, 13:46
Just about sums up all the Goodes "hysteria".
Jordan Lewis got one week for fairy tap on Daniel Pratt against North earlier in the year.
Goodes let off for fairy tap earlier in the year.
Players suspended for not going for the ball & hitting people in the head with the hip.
Goodes gets let off for not going for the ball & hitting people in the head with the hip. If it was another player it would have been deemed reckless but causing no injury so one week. Because it was Goodes he is let off.
he deserved to be suspended this time but because of his bad record should have got more. However Mr Protected does not have a bad record because he was protected twice this year.