View Full Version : Trade suggestion
Noel Gallagher
3 Jul 2008, 12:40
Hey guys before you shoot me down think about this trade scenario which could benefit both clubs.
We need a quick outside midfielder, you guys need a KPP.
How about one of either Tim Boyle OR Beau Dowler for Tambling PlUS a third round pick.
What would you say?
beaver fever
3 Jul 2008, 12:42
Hey guys before you shoot me down think about this trade scenario which could benefit both clubs.
We need a quick outside midfielder, you guys need a KPP.
How about one of either Tim Boyle OR Beau Dowler for Tambling PlUS a third round pick.
What would you say?
Ridiculous. Richmond topping off with a 3rd rounder is just insulting.
Besides Tambling is inside, not outside.
Noel Gallagher
3 Jul 2008, 12:49
Sorry that was a typo.. we would offer you OUR third round pick along with either Boyle or Dowler
So who's giving away the third round pick? I would've thought that Tambling would have greater worth than either of those two considering he is actually playing regular footy, so if we had to give away Tambling AND a third rounder for one of them, I would be very pissed. Plus I rate Tambling so I'd rather we didn't even do a straight swap.
Edit: Ah k. I'd still say no, but only just. A third rounder is just so unpredictable...there's a fair chance that he would never get near playing a game for the club, but a lot of third rounders turn out to be great players.
beaver fever
3 Jul 2008, 12:55
Sorry that was a typo.. we would offer you OUR third round pick along with either Boyle or Dowler
Still a bad trade for Richmond. Dowler hasn't shown enough at VFL level IMO and Boyle is never going to help our team long-term.
Our outside midfielders include: McMahon, Collins, Edwards, Oakley-Nicholls, Tivendale, Hyde, White.
Now from that group we can ignore Tivendale and Hyde because they are hacks.
We won't trade McMahon, Collins or Edwards, but White may be your man. What do you want for him?
I don't think those Hawthorn players have shown enough to be worth it.
It would be *very* amusing to have Tambling at Hawthorn though..Watching the Hawks fans here backtrack on all their comments :)
I don't think those Hawthorn players have shown enough to be worth it.
It would be *very* amusing to have Tambling at Hawthorn though..Watching the Hawks fans here backtrack on all their comments :)
God it is almost worth doing just to hear that! :D
rocklovelive
3 Jul 2008, 14:10
We'll take Franklin thanks.
Bojangles17
3 Jul 2008, 14:37
Hey guys before you shoot me down think about this trade scenario which could benefit both clubs.
We need a quick outside midfielder, you guys need a KPP.
How about one of either Tim Boyle OR Beau Dowler for Tambling PlUS a third round pick.
What would you say?
Not a very balanced deal, Dowler has yet to prove he's even a good VFL player, Hughes performance at both VFL and more recently at AFL would have him light years ahead. Boyle is an ok player however we are grooming the like of riewoldt and Morton to be that 2 and 3 rd option and both I believe have more upside than Boyle.
Tambling could be a trade option for us, the coaches will need to determine how many of our young group have already caught RT and how many are expected to...and there are a number in that category. But no your option would be of zip interest, a fairer swap would be Meyer for Dowler
No chance, Tambling is getting a regular game and his stats are improving every year since he was drafted.
Dowler can't even prove himself at VFL level and we don't need Boyle
Would have to be Dowler & first round pick at the bare minimum seeing as it will effectively be a 2nd round pick given how late in the round it will be
beaver fever
3 Jul 2008, 14:43
Tambling for Thorp perhaps?
CoggaRules
3 Jul 2008, 15:09
Not a very balanced deal, Dowler has yet to prove he's even a good VFL player, Hughes performance at both VFL and more recently at AFL would have him light years ahead. Boyle is an ok player however we are grooming the like of riewoldt and Morton to be that 2 and 3 rd option and both I believe have more upside than Boyle.
Tambling could be a trade option for us, the coaches will need to determine how many of our young group have already caught RT and how many are expected to...and there are a number in that category. But no your option would be of zip interest, a fairer swap would be Meyer for Dowler
isnt this the guy that has a second knee reco now?
P.S i would be forgetting about trading with teams who are contenders, when you are looking to get into the mix, you do deals with the likes of the eagles, dees etc. They will want to offload semi senior players to make way for their rebuild, we are at that point where we are ready to add "experience" to the mix. ;)
Noel Gallagher
3 Jul 2008, 15:21
No Dowler has not has two reco's that was Beau Muston and now Max Bailey as well unfortunately.
Beau Dolwer for Meyer =no deal. Dowler was a top ten pick #6 whilst Meyer was around 12?
Tambling for Thorp =no deal as well we are potentially groming him as a key defender which we really need as well as a pacy outside mid.
Dowler came to us with a fractured hip (had a car accident just before the draft) Highly rated but doesn't get the right delivery at Box Hill who are struggling at the bottom. Our Forward line is now pretty set so one of dowler or Boyle may be shopped around at seasons end.
Personally I'd rather keep Dowler who has far more upside
AlexRance
3 Jul 2008, 15:33
No way tambling for dowler and 3 round pick.
Peter SasseGum
3 Jul 2008, 16:14
Tambling needs to stay on our list.
He is a top line pick with the skills, composure, and capability to become an absolute superstar
He's getting plenty of game time, which is helping progress his experience and contribution to the team.
Well done to TW and the selection committee for sticking with Tambling, and ensuring that he becomes a valued contributor for the Tigers :thumbsu:
CoggaRules
3 Jul 2008, 16:19
Tambling needs to stay on our list.
He is a top line pick with the skills, composure, and capability to become an absolute superstar
He's getting plenty of game time, which is helping progress his experience and contribution to the team.
Well done to TW and the selection committee for sticking with Tambling, and ensuring that he becomes a valued contributor for the Tigers :thumbsu:
ok dude, time to play chasey, who were the professionals that forgot to tell the players to pack another set of boots against the Swans? ;)
Bojangles17
3 Jul 2008, 16:22
No Dowler has not has two reco's that was Beau Muston and now Max Bailey as well unfortunately.
Beau Dolwer for Meyer =no deal. Dowler was a top ten pick #6 whilst Meyer was around 12?
as if thats a relevant argument 3 years later, it's what they've done since that is the catalyst for debate, for both the answer is clearly $%#@ all. Dowler is no more advanced nor on his pittful performances so far warrant any higher upside than Meyer, In fact I could argue that Meyer has played far less footy so much less is known about him. In any case you cant fool me , I know Hawk supporters that readily admit he %@#@house
Peter SasseGum
3 Jul 2008, 16:26
ok dude, time to play chasey, who were the professionals that forgot to tell the players to pack another set of boots against the Swans? ;)
This topic is about trade suggestions, so I'll keep my answer brief.
The players are professional athletes who should have been prepared with the appropiate footwear. Do you expect the trainers to ensure they are wearing clean underwear, or have their nails trimmed?
Well done to TW and the football department for giving the guidance to the players about who to best conduct themselves on the field, whilist ensuring each player has appropiate accountability for their own actions :thumbsu:
Top_4_Tiger
3 Jul 2008, 16:30
I wouldn't trade Meyer for Dowler, let alone Tambling.
Meyer has been injured for the past 18+ months, Drownler is a proven dud.
CoggaRules
3 Jul 2008, 16:44
This topic is about trade suggestions, so I'll keep my answer brief.
The players are professional athletes who should have been prepared with the appropiate footwear. Do you expect the trainers to ensure they are wearing clean underwear, or have their nails trimmed?
Well done to TW and the football department for giving the guidance to the players about who to best conduct themselves on the field, whilist ensuring each player has appropiate accountability for their own actions :thumbsu:
I expect the coaches who are there to "guide" the kids and develop them in the professional world, to demand that they should pack 2 pairs of boots.
Because all of them ahve been there and done that, but all of them are sleeping on the ____ing job and getting paid for it.
Since the professional athletes that form our leadership group had the professionalism to "show the way", NOT, then the buck stops with the coaching panel. Not the trainers. You reference to clean underwear and nails is a complete pile of shit. ;)
Tambling for Thorp perhaps?
Thorp has ongoing hip concerns similar to Meyer, so does Dowler but his was a fracture which should heal, when it's a joint issue like Thorps/Meyer's then its fairly concerning.
I'd say it's a shame as Thorp looks to be a gun, except now he's a Hawk I couldn't care less
Richo Rules
3 Jul 2008, 17:57
tambling will be a gun when he hits the age of 23-25
no trade at all
Boyle is shit. I rather develop Riewoldt and Hughes.
Hey guys before you shoot me down think about this trade scenario which could benefit both clubs.
We need a quick outside midfielder, you guys need a KPP.
How about one of either Tim Boyle OR Beau Dowler for Tambling PlUS a third round pick.
What would you say?
[/I]
I would say
Fruck off
Bojangles17
4 Jul 2008, 11:30
[/I]
I would say
Fruck off
is the equivalent of us putting up sarge and mcguane for xav ellis:confused:
Sorry that was a typo.. we would offer you OUR third round pick along with either Boyle or Dowler
How about mitch thorpe and Beau dowler :D
Top_4_Tiger
4 Jul 2008, 12:53
is the equivalent of us putting up sarge and mcguane for xav ellis:confused:
But even Sarge has shown triple of what Dowler has and was worth more than Pick 28 last trade period.
Peter SasseGum
4 Jul 2008, 17:57
tambling will be a gun when he hits the age of 23-25
no trade at all
Spot on.
Great to see a fellow Tiger fan look at the big picture with Tambling, and see that he is indeed a player worth hanging onto.
Well done to TW and the development staff for also seeing the potential in Tambling, and giving him the opportunities to make his mark on the AFL :thumbsu:
NO WAY to that trade suggestion.
King_Mallee
4 Jul 2008, 19:22
Hey guys before you shoot me down think about this trade scenario which could benefit both clubs.
We need a quick outside midfielder, you guys need a KPP.
How about one of either Tim Boyle OR Beau Dowler for Tambling PlUS a third round pick.
What would you say?
get of our board
Richmond FC
4 Jul 2008, 21:18
Horrible suggestion Dowler is going to struggle to make it at AFL level he is just a big HFF can play KPP my sources tell me so would be no where near a fair trade. Maybe a 4th round pick at best for him. Boyle on the other hand is a definate no go because he is a dud simply he was playing as 3rd or 4th tall. He just isnt what we are looking for.
Tigersman
5 Jul 2008, 02:15
How about JON instead?
Well done to TW and the football department for giving the guidance to the players about who to best conduct themselves on the field, whilist ensuring each player has appropiate accountability for their own actions :thumbsu:
???
So Wallet gives guidance to the players but is not accountable for their performances?
He's the master of deflections, and is the true definition of all care and no responsibility
Bojangles17
6 Jul 2008, 23:24
???
So Wallet gives guidance to the players but is not accountable for their performances?
He's the master of deflections, and is the true definition of all care and no responsibility
Like the tough decision the Blues made over fevolas pre season indiscretion huh, geez that paid off:eek:
Big Bad Buddy
6 Jul 2008, 23:29
I think Alwyn Davey Andrew Lovett and Nathan Lovett Murray are out of contract at the end of the year.
Any intrest in them?
I think We should go for Lovett Murray Key defender great player and maybe Alwyn Davey ;o. His chase and tackle is amasing.
What do you guys think?
Bojangles17
6 Jul 2008, 23:31
I think Alwyn Davey Andrew Lovett and Nathan Lovett Murray are out of contract at the end of the year.
Any intrest in them?
I think We should go for Lovett Murray Key defender great player and maybe Alwyn Davey ;o. His chase and tackle is amasing.
What do you guys think?
nlm has been around for ages, only a fringe player , Ess would never let go alwyn davey unless we offered the world for him, and why would you:confused:
Big Bad Buddy
6 Jul 2008, 23:34
nlm has been around for ages, only a fringe player , Ess would never let go alwyn davey unless we offered the world for him, and why would you:confused:
Mmm we wouldnt offer the world for him. Why would we when we have Richard Tambling. People hang sh1t on him say he was a waste of a pick but he is showing promosing signs. I wonder if richmond would Trade Richard Tambling For Alwyn Davey probs not knowing Davey is 2-3 years older. I think Richmond should keep Tambling personally but what do you think?
Bojangles17
7 Jul 2008, 13:01
Mmm we wouldnt offer the world for him. Why would we when we have Richard Tambling. People hang sh1t on him say he was a waste of a pick but he is showing promosing signs. I wonder if richmond would Trade Richard Tambling For Alwyn Davey probs not knowing Davey is 2-3 years older. I think Richmond should keep Tambling personally but what do you think?
not sure that I was suggesting we would offer the world for alwyn...ess wouldnt let him go and he's not the kind of player we need to invest our trade picks for in any case
CoggaRules
7 Jul 2008, 13:09
I think Alwyn Davey Andrew Lovett and Nathan Lovett Murray are out of contract at the end of the year.
Any intrest in them?
I think We should go for Lovett Murray Key defender great player and maybe Alwyn Davey ;o. His chase and tackle is amasing.
What do you guys think?
you have top be kidding me....do you watch the game dude? this guy has "my next move is going to cause a turnover" written all over him. ;)
I think Alwyn Davey Andrew Lovett and Nathan Lovett Murray are out of contract at the end of the year.
Any intrest in them?
I think We should go for Lovett Murray Key defender great player and maybe Alwyn Davey ;o. His chase and tackle is amasing.
What do you guys think?
The only ones we would want are Lovett and Davey and Ess. arn't gonna give them away. NLM is just and outsider with a little bit of run and picks up cheap touches with all the backwards kicking.
Id be interested in Dowler, I like the look of him.
I obviously wouldn't give up Tambling, but Petiffer and a 4th rounder or something similar would be a possibility. Or Meyer and a 4th.
For mine anyway :thumbsu:
Bojangles17
7 Jul 2008, 22:29
Id be interested in Dowler, I like the look of him.
what exactly do you like about him, I understand he's done #$!@ all since being drafted , there's no way in the world he's worth a senior player in a trade. His value would be R3 at best...we can use Pettifer in a better trade than that
You want a quick outside mid?
Have tivendale, keep dowler and we'll throw in Cam Howat in return for you keeping Tim Boyle.
what exactly do you like about him, I understand he's done #$!@ all since being drafted , there's no way in the world he's worth a senior player in a trade. His value would be R3 at best...we can use Pettifer in a better trade than that
He has done shit all, but the way he moves seems to me like he has something...(and thats not just based on yesterdays game)...and he can mark it fairly well.
I think he might be a good solid player if given a chance, ala what Josh Kenneddy looks to be turning into. Just personal opinion, but I wouldnt be too unhappy if we managed to snare him cheap :thumbsu:
W. Smithers
15 Aug 2008, 10:16
This topic is about trade suggestions, so I'll keep my answer brief.
The players are professional athletes who should have been prepared with the appropiate footwear. Do you expect the trainers to ensure they are wearing clean underwear, or have their nails trimmed?
If it meant that it would affect how they played, then the trainers should.
FandangoDingo
15 Aug 2008, 12:45
We'll take Franklin thanks.
You've had your chance! ;)
TigerGlory
15 Aug 2008, 18:55
You give us nothing, and you can have McMahon.
In fact. We'll PAY you to take McMahon. Please, just take him. Pleeeeeeeeeease. :(
beaver fever
15 Aug 2008, 18:58
oh king oath. Get that guy out of our club. 3 year deal ffs.
Newman, King, Schulz, McGuane, Raines, Pattison. Tradeable commodities we should see what we can get for.