Round 15 Carlton v St Kilda - Player Votes

[Kildonan]

Please feel welcome to vote in the Banger / Buckets / Baldock Award

We're using a flexible system of voting where 15 pts are allocated to vote with. You can give a maximum vote of 5 pts and a minimum of 1 pt for any one player.

Typical Vote: N Riewoldt 5, L Hayes 4, L Ball 3, S Milne 2, J Geary 1
Acceptable: N Riewoldt 5, L Hayes 5, L Ball 2, S Milne 2, J Geary 1
Acceptable: N Riewoldt 3, L Hayes 3, L Ball 3, S Milne 2, J Geary 1, J Koschitzke 1, L Montagna 1, D Armitage 1

Please be aware that there are two Fishers, Clarkes, and Gardiners so please use initials to clarify.

This thread will be stickied until next Friday and the totals will be tabulated.

[gta007]

5. Stephen Milne
4. Nick Riewoldt
3. Max Hughton
2. Jason Gram
1. Justin Koschitzke

[dylan_mike]

Carlton:
Judd
Gibbs
Scotland

Saints
Reiwoldt
Milne
Hayes

[Persevering Saint]

4. Milne
4. Riewoldt
3. Hayes
3. Maxy
1. Kosi

[sirviv]

5 - Riewoldt - Kept presenting all night and took Waite to the cleaners for the first time
4 - Milne - Kicked 5 and did alot of other nice things which was pleasing
3 - Hughton - Kept Fev to 3, 2 from free kicks
2 - Hayes - Best on ground to 1/2 time died out of the game after that
1 - Gram - Ran had all night

[Danger Mouse]

3 Gram (We are a much better side with Gram in the middle)
2 Milne
2 Riewoldt
2 Sam Fisher
2 Hudghton
2 Hayes
2 King

[TassieSaint]

5 Hudghton
4 Hayes
3 Riewoldt
2 Milne
1 Gram

[Fehring]

5. Hudghton
4. Riewoldt
2. Milne
1. Jones
1. Blake
1. Hayes
1. Gram

[Squizzy1970]

Carlton:
0 Judd
0 Gibbs
0 Scotland

Saints
5 Reiwoldt
5 Milne
5 Hayes

Needs to be out of 15, so thought I'd lend a helping hand.

[Squizzy1970]

Too even for me to do the 5-4-3-2-1.

2 Goddard (just doesn't get beaten these days)
2 Riewoldt (3 goals, 4 score assists)
2 Fisher S (beat his opponent and rebounded all night)
2 Hudghton (9 spoils which is the most I've seen before)
2 Milne (no wonder opposition fans hate him)
1 Gram (great tussle with Judd who had 0 scoring shots and 0 score assists)
1 Hayes (tireless with no clangers and 8 tackles)
1 Harvey (19 possessions in 59% TOG is first class and was very creative again. Hey Dermie .... well you know where you can stick it)
1 Koschitkze (would have had 3 bar the blood rule. Game high 4 contested marks)
1 Dempster (kept Stevens to 7 kicks, no scoring shots, 1 score assist. Best game for the club).

[SOLMAN86]

3 Riewoldt(tpyical game)
3 Milne(5 goals says it all)
2 Hayes(Instrumental First half)
2 Gram (is really turning into a gun mid fielder)
2 Koschitzke (stood up in a big game)
1 Maxy (held Fev enouh said)
1 Harvey ( the old maestro just keeps on keeping on)
1 King (Great Tap Work all night ensuring mid fielders 1st use)

[CHBench]

3 - Gram: Gram always good in the middle
3 - Riewoldt: Close to 04/05 form
3 - Hudghton: Wouldn't leave fevy alone :D:thumbsu:
3 - Milne: 5 Goals
2 - King: Set up 4 or 5 goals from awesome ruck work
1 - Hayes: Legend

[Juggalo Balla]

5 - Gram - Stopped Judd
5 - Hudghton - Stopped Fev
5 - Hayes - Stopped everything else

[Look2Me4Guidance]

5 - Nick Riewoldt (absolute star)

4 - Max Hudghton - sensational game

3 - Jason Gram - very impressive work

2 - Lenny Hayes - just the usual from the Len Dog.

1 - Clint Jones - getting more confident with his disposal every week.

Sorry Milney :eek:

[alo_saints_fan]

hey guys sorry haven't been able to vote alot this year, mainly because I havn't been able to see alot of live games this year, and i dont like voting when i watch it on TV, because you never get the full picture; so here goes.

5. Riewoldt- Amazing game
4. Hayes- superb in and under
3. milne - kicked 5, but not a best on game
2.Gram- great run with role and was damaging
1. Maxy hudgton- Always reliable, kept fev quiet.

[Kildonan]

5 J Koshitzke
4 N Riewoldt
3 M Hudghton
2 J Gram
1 S Fisher

[sainter_girl]

5 - Reiwoldt
4- Kosi
3 - Max
2 - Lenny
1 - Gram

[AFLOnline]

5. Stephen Milne
4. Nick Riewoldt
3. Max Hughton
2. Nick Dal Santo
1. Lenny Hayes

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

4. Roo
4. Max
3. Milney
1. Kosi
1. Hayes
1. Gram
1. King

Unlucky: Jones, Macca, Dempster.

[The Punter]

5 Riewoldt
4 Hayes
3 Koschitzke
2 Jones
1 Hudghton

[HoldenMCaulfield]

5 N Riewoldt
4 M Hudghton
3 J Koschitzke
2 S King
1 J Gram

[tim_saints]

5. Jason Gram- Provided a really good option in the middle of the ground.
4. Max Hudgton- Beat fev end story
3. Nick Riewoldt- As always great option up forward and playing great footy.
2. Lenny Hayes- Clearing the ball out of the middle so well this Year, pushing for all asutralian in my mind.
1. Stephen Milne- Is starting to play frount and centres really well and kicking goals

[Rough_Edges]

5 - Nick Riewoldt
4 - Lenny Hayes
3 - Justin Koschitzke
2 - Max Hudgton
1 - Stephen Milne