View Full Version : Team vs Collingwood
So is the consensus, Kingsley in for Brogan?
I for one would like to see no changes and give Kingsley the possibility of an extra weeks rest. He is not a vital player in my eyes. I have a feeling the selection panel feel differently though.
I think leave the team unchanged... if anything maybe start Stuart Dew on the bench as a reminder to pull his finger out.
Give Kingo 1 more week and give Brogan another opportunity.
SKC
rubberman
5 Sep 2002, 17:30
Unchanged from last week.
Don't forget that there is Che in the mix as well.
Personally I liked the looks of last weeks side, however I think there will be minor changes. Hope Guerra doesn't end up being the one that misses out.
Guerra could miss out, but Guerra can't miss out. He was an excellent pressure player for us last week, and should be able to do the same this week.
Wouldn't be surprised to see Kingsley in for K.Cornes actually.
Che was one of the players in a Collingwood jumper at training so I think the decision has been made there. I would hope to see Dew on the field a bit longer than he was against Brisbane. I know he only had 2 kicks for 2 goals but he was barely there at all. But I'm sure Kingsley will have to come in as I can't see Brogan staying and giving us 3 talls in a night game. I just hope Poults doesn't start on the bench, he's starting to come into some form.
koulagirl32
5 Sep 2002, 19:11
Kingers is indeed in for Brogan.
Collingwood's ins/outs were:
in: Didak, Rocca, Steinfort
Out: McGough, Richardson, Holland
Collingwood look a bit weak in the midfield really
rubberman
5 Sep 2002, 22:21
Originally posted by koulagirl32
Kingers is indeed in for Brogan.
Collingwood's ins/outs were:
in: Didak, Rocca, Steinfort
Out: McGough, Richardson, Holland
Good to see Kingers back in the side probably playing from the bench. Will he fall for Malthouses tactic of keeping him in the back pocket this time. I dont think so.
Was Holland omited or too scared to face Kane Cornes.:D
Originally posted by Porthos
Collingwood look a bit weak in the midfield really
Especially if the weather sets in. It's gonna be chilly at the Park. Fair chance of rain.
Originally posted by koulagirl32
Kingers is indeed in for Brogan.
Collingwood's ins/outs were:
in: Didak, Rocca, Steinfort
Out: McGough, Richardson, Holland
Here's some tips from an outsider:
Steinfort will take on the tagging role previously allocated to Licuria. He has been our best running player (that's not saying much on present form) and will play a more offensive role this Friday.
Rocca was not injured and will be fresh from his rest - you will miss Wakelin and if we win we will have Bickley to thank.
Although we have been hit and miss I think our forwards are the most dangerous in the comp and will be our strength. Our weakness will be the midfield and covering your small forwards.
Oh, and of course, Primus.
Good luck!
Originally posted by hotpie
Rocca was not injured and will be fresh from his rest - you will miss Wakelin and if we win we will have Bickley to thank.
Good luck!
Thank you. Rocca I can see as the main worry. That's not to say I think he will dominate, just that I don't know what's going to happen with him this time with Wakelin out. I'm confident Paxman can handle Tarrant, whether Mead will find it hard going on Rocca or Bishop will be tried there I couldn't be sure. Of course, after last week Cornes could have a go at Rocca but I think it more likely that Mark Williams will want to keep him forward. We were definitely losing something in the forwards with only the one full-time big forward there.