View Full Version : players i think should be traded or delisted
St.Rick
11 Oct 2002, 18:16
hi new here ,
Players i think should go whats your opinion?
Beetham ,Callaghan , Capuano , Davis , Plapp and maybe Chris Jones but i dont know much about him.
Savatage
11 Oct 2002, 18:34
Originally posted by St.Rick
hi new here ,
Players i think should go whats your opinion?
Beetham ,Callaghan , Capuano , Davis , Plapp and maybe Chris Jones but i dont know much about him.
Yes, No, No, Yes, Yes, Yes. Chris Jones just ain't got it.
Welcome to Big Footy!
Mattster
12 Oct 2002, 00:56
not a saints supporter but the only one i would consider keeping is Capuano if you trade Everitt. Having said that, don't you still have Trent Knobel? Ah bugger it, get rid of them all :)
Saint4Life
12 Oct 2002, 01:46
capuano is shizenhousen
i say get a brand new ruckman if everit goes
p.s - i voted for plapp
next would have benn capuano
i think beethem will be good if he can get into form
St.Rick
12 Oct 2002, 18:50
Yes i went Plapp as well but to be honest i dont think it would do any damage to us if they all went, you could probably count the good games of all of them on two hands in the last 2 years.
Saint4Life
13 Oct 2002, 12:42
yea i guess
the only 2 i think so stay is beethem and callaghan
i actually capuano is worse than plapp
I say get rid of Beetham, he seems to be more interested in grog than footy.:mad:
Vaul Darkhour
15 Oct 2002, 16:12
well considering you cannot vote for only one player, the poll should really be 'Who should we keep?'.. that'd give a more accurate indication...
For my 2 cents.. same as Sav and Callaghan as my first choice to keep..
Well I've only seen one game this year, but based on 2001 and what I've read and heard......
get rid of Beetham, Capuano (if there's an alternative) and Davis.
I don't know Chris Jones!
St.Rick
16 Oct 2002, 02:27
Yeah when i set it up i couldn't find an option to list from 1 to 6 so i just left it as was.
If Everitt does go i'd still delist Capuano hasnt done enough and only played a few good games with north, i followed his career from earlydays as he lived near me back then in creswick .
Year Games Kicks Marks H.Balls Disp Goals Pts H.O
1995 15 68 46 63 131 5 4 88
1996 18 81 41 62 143 6 81
1998 13 59 25 26 85 3 3 121
1999 19 127 63 65 192 4 4 263
2000 14 69 36 19 88 5 2 129
2001 12 70 51 26 96 8 119
2002 7 44 37 37 81 4 37
Totals 98 518 299 298 816 35 13 838
Avr 12 5.2 3 3 8.3 8.5
St.Rick
24 Aug 2003, 20:25
just looking through my old posts and found this, should of got rid of caps last year :) who will go this year
DarkRider
25 Aug 2003, 21:51
Milne.
The invisible mullet
26 Aug 2003, 00:02
Black
evertonfc
26 Aug 2003, 16:54
Milne and Black will stay unless someone gives us a top 20 pick for either of them.
riccardo
26 Aug 2003, 18:48
Milne and Black will stay, and be given an opportunity to prove thier continuing worth in season '04. The fact that players like these 2, who would be assured of a regular game at many other clubs, aren't in St Kilda's best 22, shows the deapth the Saints have, and need to keep in order to continue to improve to the flag.
Lawrence is in real danger, but I really can't see any players voulentarily leaving the Saints at this stage, or the coaching staff letting any of them go.
DarkRider
28 Aug 2003, 23:04
Originally posted by evertonfc
Milne and Black will stay unless someone gives us a top 20 pick for either of them.
God that's funny. Top 20 !! Try last 20 if you're lucky.:D
Win a few games and you start to think you are as good as the big boys.:rolleyes:
Savatage
29 Aug 2003, 00:33
Originally posted by DarkRider
God that's funny. Top 20 !! Try last 20 if you're lucky.:D
Win a few games and you start to think you are as good as the big boys.:rolleyes:
Carn the Mighty Roys, you ****ing traitor. Go desert your dying football club, then hop onto another bandwagon & then another. Do you even barrack for a footy team?
Oh that's right, you don't, but you still have the time to give other clubs ****. Maybe seek therapy.
Last time I checked your "hero" Wayne Carey was in Adelaide.
Do us all a favour & go and stalk him over there.
Hawks will take Milne and Black!
How about Loats and our top 10 draft pick for Milne, Black and St Kildas 2nd round draft pick?
Not long ago Milne was playing good footy, kicking goals and he's still young.
Black still has some good footy left in him, just needs the right environment.
evertonfc
12 Sep 2003, 14:49
Originally posted by Shwab
Hawks will take Milne and Black!
How about Loats and our top 10 draft pick for Milne, Black and St Kildas 2nd round draft pick?
Not long ago Milne was playing good footy, kicking goals and he's still young.
Black still has some good footy left in him, just needs the right environment.
Why should we trade Milne and Black? We have no reason to. It would require a substantial amount of compensation, significantly greater than what you're offering.
To get us even thinking about trading Milne + Black + 2nd Round Draft Pick in a package deal, you would be required to offer a deal in the Vicinity of Pick 10 + Nathan Thompson/Jade Rawlings/Jon Hay. At the very least.
David Loats holds no interest to St Kilda.
evertonfc
12 Sep 2003, 15:05
Originally posted by DarkRider
God that's funny. Top 20 !! Try last 20 if you're lucky.:D
Win a few games and you start to think you are as good as the big boys.:rolleyes:
Battler.
roach44
18 Sep 2003, 02:03
Milne will stay, Black wants out, spoke to him 2 weeks ago. Was almost going to do a Beetham this year and just quit, but will find himself at either Carlton or Richmond. Oliver, Thompson, Schwarze (both), Peckett, Capuano (already), Callahan, Wulf. There's 7 spots on our list.
sainter
18 Sep 2003, 22:11
Originally posted by roach44
Milne will stay, Black wants out, spoke to him 2 weeks ago. Was almost going to do a Beetham this year and just quit, but will find himself at either Carlton or Richmond. Oliver, Thompson, Schwarze (both), Peckett, Capuano (already), Callahan, Wulf. There's 7 spots on our list.
Actually after going into season 2003 with a shortened list that would make about 10 spots.
I don't think we need to have a massive clearout, a few of the players you listed may struggle to get a game in front of some of our youngsters but will definitely add depth and keep the senior team players honest.
Savatage
18 Sep 2003, 22:46
Originally posted by roach44
Milne will stay, Black wants out, spoke to him 2 weeks ago. Was almost going to do a Beetham this year and just quit,
Is he psychotic or what's his story?
Considering Peckett is negotiating a new contract as we speak & Thompson will be a required player & considering Troy Schwarzes one year remaining on contract, I would say you've got a fair bit of it wrong.
Your opinion or inside information?
As sainter said, there is just no point with a cleanout considering the availability on spots.
evertonfc
19 Sep 2003, 00:47
Originally posted by roach44
Milne will stay, Black wants out, spoke to him 2 weeks ago. Was almost going to do a Beetham this year and just quit, but will find himself at either Carlton or Richmond. Oliver, Thompson, Schwarze (both), Peckett, Capuano (already), Callahan, Wulf. There's 7 spots on our list.
I heard on the grapevine that GT told you that Nick Riewoldt was quiting football to take up a role in WWE?