View Full Version : Shield team of the year:
courtjester
12 Mar 2009, 13:55
ACA Sheffield Shield Team of the Year
Phillip Hughes (NSW)
Chris Rogers (Vic)
Michael Klinger (SA)
Lee Carseldine (Qld)
Callum Ferguson (SA)
Marcus North (WA, capt)
Graham Manou (SA, wk)
Brett Geeves (Tas)
Steve Magoffin (WA)
Brett Dorey (WA)
Dirk Nannes (Vic)
Ryan Harris (Qld, 12th man).
The_Trav
12 Mar 2009, 14:42
Cant argue with that
wotdoiput
12 Mar 2009, 15:01
Yup looks about right if you ask me.
So what that is saying is that Graham Manou is our next best wicket keeper after haddin?
Looks like australia is going to struggle with keepers unless Wade improves with the gloves
wotdoiput
12 Mar 2009, 15:09
Nothing wrong with MAnou this season. Solid with both the bat and the gloves for the Redbacks.
The Reaper
12 Mar 2009, 16:48
Shows how bad the rest of the WA team was
aussie1st
12 Mar 2009, 16:59
Manou has improved a lot and deserved his place in the side. That is a pretty good side and pretty much reflects the national side with no speciallist spinner again showing our lack of spin depth.
The_Trav
13 Mar 2009, 18:43
So what that is saying is that Graham Manou is our next best wicket keeper after haddin?
Looks like australia is going to struggle with keepers unless Wade improves with the gloves
Whats wrong with Manou? He's always been clean with the gloves and was easily the best of the keepers with the bat.
Spudregus_87
14 Mar 2009, 14:43
Like it jester, like it....
Could argue a case for harwood over dorey, but probably too much VIC bias there.....:)
Fair enought to not include a spinner either...north just as good as any domestic talent we have unfortunately..
Hodge could've made that team I reckon.
Spudregus_87
14 Mar 2009, 15:11
Hodge could've made that team I reckon.
Hodge IN
Ferguson OUT
How could i forget!?!?!:confused:
courtjester
15 Mar 2009, 12:31
The team in the OP was the official CA team.
I'd have Hodge in it over Ferguson as well.
I'd actually have Hodge in the Australian team as well. But that's another story....