Best Players in the GV 2000-2009 [Archive]

tuckylives

14 Dec 2009, 08:08

Who would be the best 5 players from each club in the 00's?
Anthony McPhee and Simon McCarty from Rochy rate.

ringo1

14 Dec 2009, 08:12

Anthony McPhee and Simon McCarty from Rochy rate.

Echuca;
Rhys Archard
Craig Scholl
Colin Durie
Brad Smith
Steven Orr/Josh Maddox

ringo1

14 Dec 2009, 08:13

My picks.

1. Rhys Archard (Ech)
2. Anthony McPhee (Roch)
3. Gary stevens (Tat)
4. Craig Scholl (Ech)
5. Stephen Ash (Shepp)

Best of all time...draw...Gary Cooper (Mooroopna), Rhys Archard (Ech):thumbsu:

Did andrew Thomson play in this period??? Would have to be included

yeehaaaaaaaaaaaa

14 Dec 2009, 08:14

Anthony McPhee and Simon McCarty from Rochy rate.

My picks.

1. Rhys Archard (Ech)
2. Anthony McPhee (Roch)
3. Gary stevens (Tat)
4. Craig Scholl (Ech)
5. Stephen Ash (Shepp)

Best of all time...draw...Gary Cooper (Mooroopna), Rhys Archard (Ech):thumbsu:

SUPASTARR

14 Dec 2009, 16:08

Best from EACH club not best of all time

Chargers2004

14 Dec 2009, 17:22

Best from EACH club not best of all time

Saad Saad and Paul Scanlon at Seymour.:thumbsu:

ringo1

14 Dec 2009, 19:32

Kristen Height would also be in the mix at Echuca. Paul Newman, Josh Vick and Lincoln Withers would be in the top 5 at Ky

Alley cat

15 Dec 2009, 20:15

Saad Saad and Paul Scanlon at Seymour.:thumbsu:

It's hard to go past Shane Schottner from Seymour.

ringo1

16 Dec 2009, 21:03

:thumbsu:It's hard to go past Shane Schottner from Seymour.

Could add O'Keefe and Brendan Liddell to that list. So it would read;
Saad
O'Keefe;
Schottner;
Liddell;
Scanlon
fair line up and thats not in order:thumbsu:

sizzled

17 Dec 2009, 17:13

chris atkins,brett warburton,brad campbell,stephen ash,adam baker,rys archard,tim rasmussen,matt forys,suane hueston,jarrod sutherland,matt storer,daniel maher

bloods05

2 Jan 2010, 07:30

Did andrew Thomson play in this period??? Would have to be included

What about Stephen Pearce,was a gun player when down with us in Melb.

ringo1

2 Jan 2010, 18:15

What about Stephen Pearce,was a gun player when down with us in Melb.

Stephen Pearce was a very good player for Echuca and may play some footy for Echuca this year

"Roar Passion"

2 Jan 2010, 18:46

"Roar Passion"

2 Jan 2010, 18:52

Kristen Height would also be in the mix at Echuca. Paul Newman, Josh Vick and Lincoln Withers would be in the top 5 at Ky
Hey Ringo how many games/seasons has Height played at senior level at Echuca , I had a feeling he only played one season before heading down town ??
I'd have Ash Bryne in Echucas top 5 !!

ringo1

2 Jan 2010, 19:16

Hey Ringo how many games/seasons has Height played at senior level at Echuca , I had a feeling he only played one season before heading down town ??
I'd have Ash Bryne in Echucas top 5 !!

I think he debuted in 2000 and may of played in the 2001 flag? I would say about 30-35 games at most but looking forward to him adding to the tally in the next few years. Yeah Ash would have to be considered:thumbsu:

"Roar Passion"

2 Jan 2010, 19:27

I think he debuted in 2000 and may of played in the 2001 flag? I would say about 30-35 games at most but looking forward to him adding to the tally in the next few years. Yeah Ash would have to be considered:thumbsu:
BOG in granny ?

ringo1

2 Jan 2010, 19:36

BOG in granny ?

Yeah pretty sure Ash won the medal for BOG

"Roar Passion"

3 Jan 2010, 07:32

Yeah pretty sure Ash won the medal for BOG
I actually thought Kristan Height won the medal the year he played in the flag ?

ringo1

3 Jan 2010, 11:43

I actually thought Kristan Height won the medal the year he played in the flag ?

I think that you are right. Ash and Heighty both won the medal.

hank1

4 Jan 2010, 08:32

I think that you are right. Ash and Heighty both won the medal.

They award 2 medals for the GV GF, one voted by the umps and one by the media.

Can Shop

5 Mar 2010, 08:56

bigkeg

13 Mar 2010, 19:37

D. Brophy. shepp bears.

footymack

18 Aug 2010, 13:32

The local shepp sides i reckon

Swans: Sutherland, Damien Yze, Warbarton, Rachele, Durbridge (2 morrison medalists there)

Bears: Ash, Mellington, Marc Harrop, Byers, Ahmet, ( 2 morrison medalists)

United: Kennedy, Sidebottom, Barlow, Gibson, Forys

My best 5 for a few clubs boys:

United: Justin Crough, Darren Mitchleton, Gibson, Sidebottom, Kennedy

Moor: Brad Campbell, Steven Cox, Kane Boyer, Rob Osborne, Jarror Harbrow

Swans: Sutherland, Warbuton, Rachele, Damian Yze, Looby

Bears: Byers, Ash, Marc Harrop, Ahmet, Mellington

Tat: Linc Wellington, Lee Warnett, Kirby, Cosgriff

Bunga25

1 Sep 2010, 13:00

My best 5 for a few clubs boys:

United: Justin Crough, Darren Mitchleton, Gibson, Sidebottom, Kennedy

Moor: Brad Campbell, Steven Cox, Kane Boyer, Rob Osborne, Jarror Harbrow

Swans: Sutherland, Warbuton, Rachele, Damian Yze, Looby

Bears: Byers, Ash, Marc Harrop, Ahmet, Mellington

Tat: Linc Wellington, Lee Warnett, Kirby, Cosgriff

Yeah Crough and Mitchelson were superstars for united in 2000 and belted steven ash in the granny that year from memory..

footymack

1 Sep 2010, 16:47

Yeah Crough and Mitchelson were superstars for united in 2000 and belted steven ash in the granny that year from memory..

Yes that is correct Mitchelson smashed Ash and left him with his bottom lip half hanging off but Ash was smiling after it as they won the Flag. Both Tremellen and Bovalino killed united that day I think they kicked 4 goals and 6 goals respectivley. Was a very sad day for the Dee's as they had all the netball teams in and all 3 football teams in and only managed a few premierships in the netball from memory...

DICTATOR

1 Sep 2010, 17:16

Yes that is correct Mitchelson smashed Ash and left him with his bottom lip half hanging off but Ash was smiling after it as they won the Flag. Both Tremellen and Bovalino killed united that day I think they kicked 4 goals and 6 goals respectivley. Was a very sad day for the Dee's as they had all the netball teams in and all 3 football teams in and only managed a few premierships in the netball from memory...
What, united loses all 3 games of football in 1 day THE BIGGEST STAGE on the same day GRAND FINAL DAY...THERE IS A GOD :D:D

SUPASTARR

2 Sep 2010, 21:35

My best 5 for a few clubs boys:

United: Justin Crough, Darren Mitchleton, Gibson, Sidebottom, Kennedy

Moor: Brad Campbell, Steven Cox, Kane Boyer, Rob Osborne, Jarrod Harbrow

Swans: Sutherland, Warbuton, Rachele, Damian Yze, Looby

Bears: Byers, Ash, Marc Harrop, Ahmet, Mellington

Tat: Linc Wellington, Lee Warnett, Kirby, Cosgriff

Just of interest did Harbrow play seniors at the Cats?? Or just some 3rds?

footymack

3 Sep 2010, 12:36

Just of interest did Harbrow play seniors at the Cats?? Or just some 3rds?

yeah harbrow played seniors at mooroopna. played most of the year in 2007 from memory