Worst ever Bulldogs

[jboyar]

This should spark some debate , I haven't missed many matches since 1970 so i've seen them all, top 5

1. John Reid (got taken off at half time in his first game , this was before interchange )
2. Robbie Semmens ( made No. 31 famous at Footscray.
3. Sedat Sir ( never looked like it , I still cringe thinking about his last game vs WCE , did he ever pass the ball to a fellow player , he sure knew where the boundary was )
4. Zeno Tzatzaris ( played 34 games in 7 seasons , had plenty of dash , almost misses out on my list as he got 3 Brownlow votes against Geelong one day !!.)
5. Robert Anderson ( from ACT had a couple of starts at his VFL career , probably had the best stat of running around in circles)

All these players had more than one season at the club and were not one game/season shockers .

[dog crazy]

I must be older than you. how about Russel Tweedale,paul Gow and Alby Smets.

[Captain Sensible]

I havent had a lot of time to think about it and I will try to expand on my points a bit later on, but how about these names 1. Mark Noble-only a couple of games but how many years did Hart keep him at the club? 2. Terry De Koning-What was going through his head? 3. Neil Cordy-So much talent-so little disipline So very,very frustrating 4. Alistair Ford-The only man whose 'dud' brother was a better plyer 5. Michael Malthouse-I know he is not a player but he should have won at least one flag in his time at doggyland and is now proving what a dud coach he is at Collingwood