top 10 players.

[Phil Macrackon]

g,day everyone, i thought it would be kool for everyone to write down who they think the top 10 players are in the bulldogs.
heres mine
1. Chris Grant
2. Scott West
3. Brad Johnson
4. Rohan Smith
5. Luke Darcy
6. Tony Libberatore
7. Nathan Eagleton
8. Jose Romero
9. Simon Garlic
10. Matthew Croft

[Phil Macrackon]

come on people.
who do ya think the top 10 bulldogs players are.

[HahnPremium8]

I reckon you should have had Nathan Brown in your top 10! http://www.bigfooty.com/ubb/biggrin.gif

------------------
aka HahnPremium37
<A HREF="http://www.geocities.com/isdogisgood" TARGET=_blank>
http://www.geocities.com/isdogisgood
</A>

[Phil Macrackon]

testing something

[Phil Macrackon]

yah but brown isnt playing at the moment.
its hard to tell
i will make a few adjustments

[Carob6]

1 Chris Grant
2 Scott West
3 Brad Johnson
4 Nathan Brown
5 Matthew Croft
6 Matthew Robbins
7 Jose Romero
8 Tony Liberatore
9 Rohan Smith (maybe should be higher at the moment)
10 Luke Darcy

[Waltzing Woof Biscuit]

1. Chris Grant
2. Scott West
3. Brad Johnson
4. Nathan Brown
5. Luke Darcy
6. Rohan Smith
7. Matthew Croft
8. Jose Romero
9. Simon Garlick
10. Tony Liberatore

[X_box_X]

top 4 is pretty good phil.
but here is mine.
1. Chris Grant
2. Scott West
3. Brad Johnson
4. Rohan Smith
5. Jose Romero
6. Luke Darcy
7. Nathan Brown
8. Tony Libberatore
9. Simon Garlic
10. Nathan Eagleton

[BlG POOPA PUMP]

1. myself
2. my dog
3. spgahetti head
4. gary ablett
5. chop sticks
6. pussy cat
7. up da azz
8. you
9. him
10. ahahahaha

[Westy Boy]

Originally posted by X_box_X:
top 4 is pretty good phil.
but here is mine.


Do you usually reply to yourself Phil/X_Box? Just a little tip, next time you wanna create two identities on a bulletin board, how about giving two different email addresses (and both spell GarlicK the same) so it's not so obvious?

BTW- You seem to have a lot of repsect for Inside Footy's list http://www.bigfooty.com/ubb/wink.gif.

Anyway, heres mine.

1. Chris Grant
2. Scott West
3. Brad Johnson
4. Nathan Brown
5. Rohan Smith
6. Nathan Eagleton
7. Luke Darcy

and here is where our major problem lies in my opinion..... not enough depth. Below our top seven, it's failry even amongst the rest of the list, so in terms of importance to the team ...

8. Kingsley Hunter (FB)
9. Craig Ellis/ Matty Croft (CHB)
10. Trent Bartlett (FF)

[This message has been edited by Westy Boy (edited 15 March 2001).]

[HahnPremium8]

LOL http://www.bigfooty.com/ubb/eek.gif

Here is my top 10.

1. Chris Grant
2. Scott West
3. Brad Johnson
4. Nathan Brown
5. Luke Darcy
6. Rohan Smith
7. Matthew Croft
8. Jose Romero
9. Nathan Eagleton
10. Kingsley Hunter

It was really hard for me as well after the seventh player cos i reckon quite a few others could easily be there like Libba, Dimma, Ellis, Curley etc

------------------
aka HahnPremium37
<A HREF="http://www.geocities.com/isdogisgood" TARGET=_blank>
http://www.geocities.com/isdogisgood
</A>

[Aussie_Roo]

Hi Doggy Fans

Hope you don't mind me invading your board, but I thought you might like a different perspective of your Top 10 from the opposition's point of view. Here it goes:

1. Scotty West: Pure consistency over a long period of time. One of the best midfielders around.

2. Chris Grant: Terrific player, whom is just as good at either end of the ground. However, would like to see him kick more goals.

3. Brad Johnson: Classy mid-fielder who can kick goals.

4. Luke Darcy: Good ruckman, who will carry your ruck division this year. Should do alright.

5. Nathan Brown: Best youngster at the club, needs to be a little more consistent. Future star.

6. Rohan Smith: Unfortuneately, I think we have seen the best of him. However, on his day can be dangerous and is still valuable.

7. Matthew Croft: Hard working defender who has been serviceable.

8. Craig Ellis: Could have been anything this guy - if it weren't for injuries.

9. Nathan Eagleton: Great pick up.

10. Tony Liberatore: 'The Energizer' just seems to keep going on.

The reasoning behind Chris Grant being at no.2 was that, it's no secret that your biggest strength is your mid-field. I looked at it if either player had a miss a game (depending on who you were playing of course), you could most likely cover Grant, given that your mid-fielders such as the Johnsons, Eagletons, Smiths etc.. kick a lot of goals and could probably kick a winning score. Whereas if West was missing, despite having an excellent mid-field you would most likely miss his presence greater. Either way, they are both fantastic players.

cheers

[Curly5]

Thanks for that view AussieRoo, I pretty well agree with you right down the line, except for Craig Ellis. Reckon I would tack Mitch Hahn onto the end there instead.