View Full Version : hang me, hang me now....
chrisjudd3
13 Sep 2003, 01:23
The early results from footy manager #1
Methinks something went wrong aliong the way
Gains:
Wirrupunda (originally traded to sydney, gained via carlton)
Darcy
Saddington
Franchina
Koschitzke
Pik 5
Pik 18
Losses:
pik 14
pik 26
Dean Cox
Chad Fletcher
David Haynes
Callum Chambers
Darren Glass
Michael Collica
Leppitsch (via carlton)
Embley
B Braun Saddington Read
HB Green Jakovich Hunter
C Wirrupunda Adkins Judd
HF Chick Gardiner Jones
F Matera Koschitzke Sampi
R Darcy Cousins Kerr
Inter: Banfield Wooden Braun Morrison
Wanted to get Hay, but the price was too much.
I know there are some who lynch me for this...
Black Thunder
13 Sep 2003, 01:31
yes me thinks so to :p
Do you have a breakdown of each of the trades?
What is this Footy Manager and where can I get it?
Black Thunder
13 Sep 2003, 01:41
Originally posted by jod23
What is this Footy Manager and where can I get it?
it's a game being played on the main board....
chrisjudd3
13 Sep 2003, 01:41
Wirrpunda and McDougall for Saddington and pik 14
Haynes, Chambers, Fletcher, Cox, pik 14 for Leppitsch and Wirrupunda
Leppitsch and Embley to Bulldogs for Darcy and pik 5
Collica, Glass, pik 26 for Kositchke and Franchina
Got a the KPs filled out at the cost of Embley and Fletcher, two gn midfielders.
Black Thunder
13 Sep 2003, 01:44
Originally posted by chrisjudd3
1) Wirrpunda and McDougall for Saddington and pik 14
2) Haynes, Chambers, Fletcher, Cox, pik 14 for Leppitsch and Wirrupunda
3) Leppitsch and Embley to Bulldogs for Darcy and pik 5
4) Collica, Glass, pik 26 for Kositchke and Franchina
Got a the KPs filled out at the cost of Embley and Fletcher, two gn midfielders.
1) That's an absolute shocker mate :p I dunno wat you were on when you agreed to that.
2) That's pretty ordinary just because 5 guys are never worth 2 guys.
3) That's not too bad but you coulda done much better
4) That's a good one - easily your best trade.
chrisjudd3
13 Sep 2003, 01:53
Trade number 2 was probably my only regret. I setlled for Leppa and Wirru after Hawthorn refused the offer Hay and pik 9
Trade 1 wasn't that bad, We needed a KP badly, and one who had the experience.
Trade number 3, originally Robert Murphy was supposed to be added in the deal....shrugs.
Thank god you aren't our recruiting manager.
PS - It's Wirrpunda.
Black Thunder
13 Sep 2003, 02:27
Originally posted by chrisjudd3
Trade 1 wasn't that bad, We needed a KP badly, and one who had the experience.
McDougall for Saddington and pick 14 is allrght, but with Wirrpunda in there it's plain robbery :p
I'm playing in games 2 and 3. This is how I'm going... I think Game 4 is still open...
GAME 2
Gains:
Polak
Losses:
Lynch
Cox
Chambers
Braun
Morrison
GAME3
Gains:
Primus
Livingston
Krakouer
Knotting
Losses:
Dean Cox
Callum Chambers
Drew Banfield
Michael Collica
Phil Matera
Selwood
Munro
Humm
3rd Round Pick
5th Round Pick
Tell me what you think :D
Originally posted by Sera
I'm playing in games 2 and 3. This is how I'm going... I think Game 4 is still open...
GAME 2
Gains:
Polak
Losses:
Lynch
Cox
Chambers
Braun
Morrison
GAME3
Gains:
Primus
Livingston
Krakouer
Knotting
Losses:
Dean Cox
Callum Chambers
Drew Banfield
Michael Collica
Phil Matera
Selwood
Munro
Humm
3rd Round Pick
5th Round Pick
Tell me what you think :D
Gained 5..............lost 13including picks
I guess you have a big chunk of salary cap left. Let's try and put some transfer fees on the players a la soccer and see what the sums are.
Gains
Polak $500K
Primus$800K
Livingston $350K
Krakouer $200K
Knotting $350K
Total $2.2M
Losses
Lynch $100K
Cox $300K
Chambers $150K
Braun $350K
Morrison $250K
Drew Banfield $200K
Michael Collica $150K
Phil Matera $500K
Selwood $150K
Munro $100K
Humm $180K
3rd Round Pick $50K
5th Round Pick $30K
Total $2.51M
reasonably close but we have too much tied up in Gardy and Primus.
i think going after primus was a bit of a waste, im guessing you gave up a fair bit of talent for him to.......if i was you id try and trade either primus or gardiner for a CHF or CHB, however tim knotting was a good a pick-up
eagleskickass
13 Sep 2003, 20:40
Originally posted by Frodo
Gained 5..............lost 13including picks
I guess you have a big chunk of salary cap left. Let's try and put some transfer fees on the players a la soccer and see what the sums are.
Gains
Polak $500K
Primus$800K
Livingston $350K
Krakouer $200K
Knotting $350K
Total $2.2M
Losses
Lynch $100K
Cox $300K
Chambers $150K
Braun $350K
Morrison $250K
Drew Banfield $200K
Michael Collica $150K
Phil Matera $500K
Selwood $150K
Munro $100K
Humm $180K
3rd Round Pick $50K
5th Round Pick $30K
Total $2.51M
reasonably close but we have too much tied up in Gardy and Primus.
and also there is NO WAY you could trade that many players and picks for so few, we would then need to draft a hell of a lot of players to fill our list, or do some more multiple trades following us, we wouldnt have enough draft picks to pick up enough AND we'd go so far over the cap it is not funny, it may be close in cap situation that trade but when u add the salary of everyone we pick up to fill the squad it is well off and would make us so much worse off.
Originally posted by regal_eagle
i think going after primus was a bit of a waste, im guessing you gave up a fair bit of talent for him to.......
I gave up Phil Matera and a 5th round pick for Primus. Gardiner could then play at FF or CHF.
Originally posted by Sera
I gave up Phil Matera and a 5th round pick for Primus. Gardiner could then play at FF or CHF.
yeh thats a reasonable trade but still Gardiner isnt in the All-Australian team because he is good in the forward line. Im sure most would agree to let him ruck.