lamby29's Phantom Draft

[lamby29]

1. Adam Cooney
2. Kane Tennace
3. Raphael Clarke
4. Kepler Bradley
5. Andrew Walker
6. Farren Ray
7. Troy Chaplin
8. Colin Sylvia
9. Brock McLean
10. Fergus Watts

Thoughts?

[Groucho]

Originally posted by lamby29
1. Adam Cooney
2. Kane Tennace
3. Raphael Clarke
4. Kepler Bradley
5. Andrew Walker
6. Farren Ray
7. Troy Chaplin
8. Colin Sylvia
9. Brock McLean
10. Fergus Watts

Thoughts?

From what I know that seems a pretty good line up. I'm fairly sure that Rylie Dunn will go top 10 but wouldn't know who he'd replace out of that lot.

[stefoid]

Cooney and Bradley for the dogs? Id take that.

[Yze_Magic]

Lamby Im hoping we take Colin Sylvia

[lamby29]

Originally posted by Yze_Magic
Lamby Im hoping we take Colin Sylvia
Maybe, but we need some pace in our midfield, and Raphael provides that. Can also play as a key forward.

Walker would be a good pick up at 5. Can kick long on either foot. Maybe the next Leon Cameron?

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by lamby29
Maybe, but we need some pace in our midfield, and Raphael provides that. Can also play as a key forward.

Walker would be a good pick up at 5. Can kick long on either foot. Maybe the next Leon Cameron?

id be hoping for something better than the next Leon cameron with 2 top 5 picks


the next Hird, Voss, Carey etc....

;)

[lamby29]

Originally posted by Yze_Magic
id be hoping for something better than the next Leon cameron with 2 top 5 picks


the next Hird, Voss, Carey etc....

;)
If you saw Sandy play today, you would realise that we have the next Carey in Nick Smith!

Hird and Voss clones would be nice though.

:)

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by lamby29
If you saw Sandy play today, you would realise that we have the next Carey in Nick Smith!

Hird and Voss clones would be nice though.

:)

yeah i watched the game. he is the second coming of Stewart loewe. his hands are like buckets, he has a vice like grip

exciting stuff

[tiger of old]

Originally posted by lamby29
1. Adam Cooney
2. Kane Tennace
3. Raphael Clarke
4. Kepler Bradley
5. Andrew Walker
6. Farren Ray
7. Troy Chaplin
8. Colin Sylvia
9. Brock McLean
10. Fergus Watts

Thoughts? if sylvia is still avail by pick 6 the tigers will pounce!

cheers!

[tashibatts]

Originally posted by lamby29
1. Adam Cooney
2. Kane Tennace
3. Raphael Clarke
4. Kepler Bradley
5. Andrew Walker
6. Farren Ray
7. Troy Chaplin
8. Colin Sylvia
9. Brock McLean
10. Fergus Watts

Thoughts?

Brock McLean at #9.. that will do me happily, however, if Dunn is still about at #9- I want him at Arden St.

Go Roos

[BigCat1]

The cats are very happy were their pick to :D Welcome aboard Cappy number 2

[Hosko]

I dont think Clarke will go top 4. Melbourne would benefit more from someone like Ryley Dunn.
No doubt the Bulldogs would be very very happy if the draft went that way though!

[CowboyFromHell]

I don't want Clarke. McLean, Sylvia, Dunn will do nicely.

[Falconer02]

FIRST ROUND
1.Cooney
2.Bradley
3.Tenace
4.Chaplin
5.Mclean
6.Dunn
7.Gayfer
8.Clarke
9.Walker
10.Sylvia
11.Ray
12.Burges
13.Hall
14.Watts
15.Spencer
16.Moody
17.Willoughby
18.Cosgriff
19.Travers.

Father Son
1. Collingwood-Brayden and Heath Shaw
2.Geelong-Ablett and Blake
3.Melbourne-Johnson

[lamby29]

I would be over the moon if we finished with Tennace, McLean and Johnson.

[bozza]

Originally posted by Falconer02
FIRST ROUND
1.Cooney
2.Bradley
3.Tenace
4.Chaplin
5.Mclean
6.Dunn
7.Gayfer
8.Clarke
9.Walker
10.Sylvia
11.Ray
12.Burges
13.Hall
14.Watts
15.Spencer
16.Moody
17.Willoughby
18.Cosgriff
19.Travers.

Father Son
1. Collingwood-Brayden and Heath Shaw
2.Geelong-Ablett and Blake
3.Melbourne-Johnson

Seen as we have pick 13 now I'd like to know who Hall is, haven't heard of him!

[Effes]

Falconer, Carlton will be taking either Tenace or Walker at pick 2. Most likely Tenace.

[Falconer02]

Originally posted by bozza
Seen as we have pick 13 now I'd like to know who Hall is, haven't heard of him!

Cameron Hall apparantly one of the best players in the tac cup at the start f the year.

[scooter600x]

Originally posted by Falconer02


Father Son
1. Collingwood-Brayden and Heath Shaw
2.Geelong-Ablett and Blake
3.Melbourne-Johnson

4. Richmond - Roach

[79Vintage]

Colin Sylvia was dominate for Bendigo over North Ballarat yesterday, tough on the ground and in the air. Considering he plays exactly how Richmond like their players, if he is still available at number 6 in the national draft, I reckon he's a certainty to go to Punt Road. And the Tiges supporters can be very happy about this.

[Dog Town]

Originally posted by 79Vintage
Colin Sylvia was dominate for Bendigo over North Ballarat yesterday, tough on the ground and in the air. Considering he plays exactly how Richmond like their players, if he is still available at number 6 in the national draft, I reckon he's a certainty to go to Punt Road. And the Tiges supporters can be very happy about this. Sylvia is a gun.Anyone who gets him will be pretty happy I would say.Pick 3-10 seems to be his range.

[chiliboy]

Sylvia will go top 5!!!

Demons likely to take him at no.5

Melbourne WILL take Clarke with 3, no doubt...

[kretchy]

Originally posted by 79Vintage
Colin Sylvia was dominate for Bendigo over North Ballarat yesterday, tough on the ground and in the air. Considering he plays exactly how Richmond like their players, if he is still available at number 6 in the national draft, I reckon he's a certainty to go to Punt Road. And the Tiges supporters can be very happy about this.
Be chuffed if we could get Sylvia, but if he is gone I like the sound of Ryley Dunn.

[Weaver]

Originally posted by Falconer02
FIRST ROUND
Father Son
1. Collingwood-Brayden and Heath Shaw
2.Geelong-Ablett and Blake
3.Melbourne-Johnson

Ablett will not go to Geelong this year. The season is over and he didn't play for the Geelong Falcons and so is not elligable in the draft as I understand the rules.

[vicpride99]

Blake they reckon would be a top 10 pick that is good value.

[Kid Dynamite!]

Originally posted by Weaver
Ablett will not go to Geelong this year. The season is over and he didn't play for the Geelong Falcons and so is not elligable in the draft as I understand the rules.

I doubted he'd play at all this year, and I dont even think he wants to play at the highest level. The kids got a good head on his shoulders and wants to stay out of the limelight which is fair enough. Falconer, dont expect Geelong to be picking him up anytime soon.

[Deestroy]

Originally posted by chiliboy


Melbourne WILL take Clarke with 3, no doubt...
There is plenty of doubt, with probably 10 or more players who could go in the 3-5 range. I would be happy with Tenace and McLean at the Dees.

[OldSchool]

Originally posted by 79Vintage
Colin Sylvia was dominate for Bendigo over North Ballarat yesterday, tough on the ground and in the air. Considering he plays exactly how Richmond like their players, if he is still available at number 6 in the national draft, I reckon he's a certainty to go to Punt Road. And the Tiges supporters can be very happy about this. Sylvia was a little quiet early on yesterday, by his standards, but really hit his straps after 1/2 time.

[lamby29]

Originally posted by Deestroy
There is plenty of doubt, with probably 10 or more players who could go in the 3-5 range. I would be happy with Tenace and McLean at the Dees.
I would be happy with Tennace and McLean too, although Tennace will got at #2 and McLean probably won't go Top 5.

There is always one high quality player who slips out of the Top 10, and I think it will be Dunn this year.

[WoeyFanclub]

anyone know , or heard anything of a guy that joined rangers late by the name of cailin porter, played footy with him and hes a gun. Dno if he will get drafted or not, joined rangers 2 late but certianly has ability 2 make it at the afl level.

[tige19]

I think Matt Moody will go alot earlier, im tipping around 5-10 even a top 5 wouldnt suprise!!!

[dasler]

I think Matt Moody will go alot earlier, im tipping around 5-10 even a top 5 wouldnt suprise!!!

Clearly you have been smoking to much when you wrote that tige. I've watched him for the last couple of years and he will be lucky to go top 10 this year, he hasn't been very good.

One thing i did notice is that if he was up to it this year he would kick bags of 7 and 8 every week with the delivery he gets from the South Fremantle midfield. They usually have 60 inside 50's to about 30 per game.

Therefore i disagree with you

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by Falconer02
14.Watts I would absolutely LOVE that:D

[thunder39]

I just saw Kepler Bradley play today for West Perth against East Perth in the WAFL preliminary final in his fourth game of league football, and if he doesn't go at number 1 or 2 in the upcoming draft then there must be some bloody good young players out there at the moment. He can play anywhere from full back to full forward, in the ruck or on the wing. Apparently he's a Sydney supporter and was hoping to get picked up by the Swans and being a Freo supporter I was thinking gee this bloke wouldn't look too bad in purple but i don't the Swans or the Dockers or anyone without a top 2-5 pick will have a chance of drafting him.

[evertonfc]

Originally posted by Stiffy_18
I would absolutely LOVE that:D

If we're unable to take Clarke at #8, 75% chance we will take Watts I'd think, provided he hasn't already been taken.

[Black Thunder]

I really hope Farren Ray sticks around till pick 11 (I think that's the one we have??)


Also, what do people reckon the chances are of Beau Waters sticking around till pick 43 are??? or if we wanted him, would we most probably have to take him with pick 27?

[Broadbridge_20]

I don't know a lot about the players available but unless it's a really weak draft I hope we don't go for Raphael Clarke with pick 3.

[Kid Dynamite!]

Originally posted by Black Thunder
Also, what do people reckon the chances are of Beau Waters sticking around till pick 43 are??? or if we wanted him, would we most probably have to take him with pick 27?

Dont be surprised if Port take him with either our first pick (18) or IF he's around for that long, our second pick (33 I think). Rated VERY highly down at Alberton.

[marcuz]

Ricky Dyson will be perfect for essendon. Ive noticed you didnt pick him to go top 10 lamby29. Dyson was all-australian so if he doesnt go top 10 he wont last much longer and we have pick 13

[Demon37]

Updated Phantom Draft Top 10.

1. Adam Cooney
2. Kane Tennace
3. Raphael Clarke
4. Kepler Bradley
5. Colin Sylvia
6. Andrew Walker
7. Troy Chaplin
8. Fergus Watts
9. Brock McLean
10. Farren Ray

[dogman22]

Cooney and Bradley would be best-case scenario for the Bulldogs, but apparently Scott Clayton is high on Farren Ray as well. If Brown goes, part of the trade may include a high-enough pick so that Bulldogs get Ray as well

[Tigerbob]

If Sylvia is around, Richmond will take him no doubt, but my belief is Melbourne will snap him up a pick earlier.

1.Cooney is the obvious number 1
2.Tenace seems to be the logical pick for a struggling blues midfield
3.Apparently Raphael Clarke is Melbourne bound with this pick
4.Logical choice for the bullies would be Bradley
5.This is where Sylvia will go, i just know it, hope not but he will
6.Dunn - Richmond will take him if Sylvia is gone.

Thats all for now....

[jivey]

waht school is watts at

[Rooboy36]

Wesley college in st.kilda

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by Black Thunder
Also, what do people reckon the chances are of Beau Waters sticking around till pick 43 are??? or if we wanted him, would we most probably have to take him with pick 27? Absulutely no chance mate. He will go first round or second at the latest. Most likely to be picked up by one of the Adelaide clubs in 1st round. Most likely Alberton bound:(