Melbourne trade bait [Archive]

lamby29

13th September 2003, 22:21

What would you give up for the following players:

Jeff White
Brad Green
Russell Robertson
Nathan Brown
Luke Williams
Paul Wheatley
Chris Lamb
Luke Molan

Kane McGoodwin

13th September 2003, 23:51

What value do you have on Jeff White?

lamby29

13th September 2003, 23:54

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
What value do you have on Jeff White?
First round pick + fringe player.

Kane McGoodwin

14th September 2003, 00:33

Originally posted by lamby29
First round pick + fringe player.
Probably too much for my liking, given that he is injury proned.

lamby29

14th September 2003, 00:39

Adelaide shouldn't go after him.

Your list is old enough as it is, without trading for a 27 year old.

Sera

14th September 2003, 00:47

I'd give you a 3rd round pick for Nicolson.

Yze_Magic

14th September 2003, 00:57

Originally posted by lamby29
What would you give up for the following players:

Jeff White
Brad Green
Russell Robertson
Nathan Brown
Luke Williams
Paul Wheatley
Chris Lamb
Luke Molan

Russell Robertson?!?!?!

forgive lamby, for thee has sinned

Robbo is our heart and soul!

lamby29

14th September 2003, 01:00

Originally posted by Yze_Magic
Russell Robertson?!?!?!

forgive lamby, for thee has sinned

Robbo is our heart and soul!
For some reason, I always include Robbo on the 'Trade Bait' list.

He would be very stiff to be traded after his 2003 season though.

Deestroy

14th September 2003, 01:48

Originally posted by Sera
I'd give you a 3rd round pick for Nicolson.
Pass.

Though not playing many games this year, I read somewhere he still managed to lead our clubs in spoils. We'd be more screwed without him.

The Doctor

14th September 2003, 06:35

Originally posted by Deestroy
Pass.

Though not playing many games this year, I read somewhere he still managed to lead our clubs in spoils. We'd be more screwed without him.

Pat Wiggins for Chris Lamb

CrowBoi

14th September 2003, 08:47

Originally posted by lamby29
For some reason, I always include Robbo on the 'Trade Bait' list.

He would be very stiff to be traded after his 2003 season though.

It does happen though... Remember Woewoeful?

Either way, I hope you don't lose Robbo... He seems quite snug in your lineup...

OneEyedPie

14th September 2003, 09:47

SORRY MATE THEY ARE ALL SOFT PLAYERS NO HARD NUTS

dougthelegend

14th September 2003, 09:52

Originally posted by lamby29
What would you give up for the following players:

Jeff White

i'd like to see Jeff White as the #2 ruck for the bombers.
but seeing as he will be #2, how about our first draft pick?

chiliboy

14th September 2003, 10:47

You people are CRAZY!!

JEFF WHITE WOULD BE NO.1 RUCKMAN FOR 14 TEAMS IF FULLY FIT!!

He's been injured for the last 2 years.

The only reason the dees will consider trading him is because they have jamar, and jolly..

But unless they get a quality kid for him, they will develop him into a CHF, wcich is the likely scenario over trade!!!

lamby29

14th September 2003, 11:18

Originally posted by CrowBoi
It does happen though... Remember Woewoeful?

Either way, I hope you don't lose Robbo... He seems quite snug in your lineup...
A bit different. Woewoeful was coming off 2 average seasons.

dougthelegend

14th September 2003, 11:38

what would u take from the bombers for White?

lamby29

14th September 2003, 11:39

Originally posted by dougthelegend
what would u take from the bombers for White?
Danny Jacobs.

dougthelegend

14th September 2003, 11:42

straight swap, u'r dreaming. age difference, White injury prone...

scooter600x

14th September 2003, 12:24

Originally posted by chiliboy
You people are CRAZY!!

JEFF WHITE WOULD BE NO.1 RUCKMAN FOR 14 TEAMS IF FULLY FIT!!

He's been injured for the last 2 years.

Luke Darcy, Matthew Primus, Steven King, Michael Gardiner, Adam Goodes, Peter Everitt.

Even if he was fit (which he never is, and might not ever be) he still wouldn't be no. 1 ahead of any of these guys.

Unfortunately, he's also not a very good forward (except for the 4 goal number he did on us, but David Hille did that as well).

Don't expect too much for him.

PS. try not to shout, I've only just got the baby to sleep.

dascman03

14th September 2003, 12:31

Brad Green has just been re-signed. Hence, he cant be traded. Ill have White though.

chiliboy

14th September 2003, 12:45

Your kidding..

White in full flight is better than Primus, Everitt, and Darcy..

Plus, he'll be a good forward once he learns the position!!

funky_monk

14th September 2003, 13:13

Originally posted by chiliboy
Plus, he'll be a good forward once he learns the position!!

At 27?

dees 4 life

14th September 2003, 13:19

Originally posted by lamby29
What would you give up for the following players:

Jeff White
Brad Green
Russell Robertson
Nathan Brown
Luke Williams
Paul Wheatley
Chris Lamb
Luke Molan

There is many more players that are trade bait.

Peter walsh
Daniel Ward
Troy Broadbridge
Travis Johnstone
Mathew Whealan.

As well as the players you have listed.

sabre_ac

14th September 2003, 17:48

Armstrong please

TheMightyDons

14th September 2003, 17:57

Jacobs for White?

Deestroy

14th September 2003, 18:02

Originally posted by sabre_ac
Armstrong please
Not for sale.

lamby29

14th September 2003, 18:32

Originally posted by TheMightyDons
Jacobs for White?
Yes.

TheMightyDons

14th September 2003, 18:56

Done.

The Shev

14th September 2003, 20:04

Keep Jeff White so then he has a chance to punish all these bastards who underrate him once he gets fit next year. Before he got injrued this year, he was our best player.

Broadbridge_20

14th September 2003, 23:50

Originally posted by dougthelegend
what would u take from the bombers for White?

Straight swap for Mark Johnson, Damian Cupido or Dean Rioli.

White + Green for Jason Johnson + Shane Harvey

evertonfc

15th September 2003, 00:07

Originally posted by lamby29
First round pick + fringe player.

For White?

Pass. At least from a St Kilda perspective. Too much to give up for someone not of that calibre, but of that age. Much rather spend our beans on Charman, Seaby or Cox.

Perhaps Collingwood would offer their First round pick + Heath Scotland/Rupert Betheras/Dane Swan?

dougthelegend

15th September 2003, 12:59

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
Straight swap for Mark Johnson, Damian Cupido or Dean Rioli.

White + Green for Jason Johnson + Shane Harvey
JJ will not be traded
Rioli will not be traded
MJ will not be traded
Cupido will not be traded

Broadbridge_20

15th September 2003, 13:22

Originally posted by dougthelegend
JJ will not be traded
Rioli will not be traded
MJ will not be traded
Cupido will not be traded

Everyone's available at the right price.

dougthelegend

15th September 2003, 14:04

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
Everyone's available at the right price.
it would have to be an extraordinary deal for us to even consider letting any of those players go!

sabre_ac

15th September 2003, 15:53

Ill do a swap of Walker for Armstrong and a 3rd round pick.

Deestroy

15th September 2003, 16:21

Originally posted by sabre_ac
Ill do a swap of Walker for Armstrong and a 3rd round pick.
Hahahaha, no **** you would.
I wouldn't swap Armstrong for Walker let alone throwing in a 3rd rounder.

Dreaming.

dees 4 life

15th September 2003, 20:18

The white for Jacobs deal would benifit both clubs. We need a young defender and Jacobs fits the bill. Essendon need a exprianced ruckman, white fits that deal. Good deal for mine.

Porthos

15th September 2003, 21:53

Nick Stevens for Nick Smith and Daniel Bell

marcuz

15th September 2003, 21:58

White + Green for Jason Johnson + Shane Harvey

Jason Johnson is our best midfielder. If he goes we are ****ed. Shane harvey is a clone of his bro, has terrific pace something our midfield lacks so that deal does not suit us

Hosko

15th September 2003, 22:28

White + Green for Jason Johnson + Shane Harvey
ridiculous!!
would not even consider doing JJ for white and green, let alone giving you Harvey aswell.

Crusty Bode

15th September 2003, 23:31

Whelan or Jamar wold be welcome at the Crows....however we dont have much to offer in the way of useful players, so draft picks and fringe players is probably the only possibility. What Crows would the Dees be interested in?