Jeff White to the Crows [Archive]

Broadbridge_20

15 Sep 2003, 13:37

Originally posted by cheesecake shop
I hear Jeff White is going to the Crows for either Goodwin or Tyson Stenglien

If that happens I will never say a bad word about the Melbourne Football Club again.

White for Goodwin would be unbelievable.

Where did you get this from?

Demon37

15 Sep 2003, 14:03

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
If that happens I will never say a bad word about the Melbourne Football Club again.

White for Goodwin would be unbelievable.

Where did you get this from?
Agree.

But Adelaide would have to be pretty stupid to trade for another 27 year old. They are better off trading Goodwin for a top 10 pick.

Stiffy_18

15 Sep 2003, 14:07

Originally posted by cheesecake shop
I hear Jeff White is going to the Crows for either Goodwin or Tyson Stenglien Get real!!!!!! You have been listenign to much to Chris McDermott and his suggestion that Crows should go for Jeff White.:rolleyes:

Why would we trade a player of Goodwin's or Stenglein's value for an inconsistent, undersized ruckman who has chronic shin problems??????

If we are to trade Goodwin it will be more likely for someone like Ottens;)

Thunderstruck

15 Sep 2003, 14:37

Originally posted by cheesecake shop
I hear Jeff White is going to the Crows for either Goodwin or Tyson Stenglien

What a load of total toss!!! As if we'd trade a quaility dual All Australian Midfielder like Goodwin for White!!! and Stinger!! our best at Clearances!! Thats rubbish, we lost Johnson and theres no way we'd lose one of them lot!

Neither of them are worth the top 3 bloody picks!

Falchoon

15 Sep 2003, 19:11

Can we have Matthew Clarke, you certainly couldn't have he and White in the same side.

Deestroy

15 Sep 2003, 19:24

White for Goodwin? Gees I wish.
Chances of happening? Nil.

Kane McGoodwin

15 Sep 2003, 19:31

Originally posted by Falchoon
Can we have Matthew Clarke, you certainly couldn't have he and White in the same side.
What would you offer the Crows for Matty Clarke? He doesn't take many marks around the ground, but that shouldn't be a problem with all your marking KPP. One of the best tap ruckman & would give Harvey, Hayes & Co. 1st use of the ball.

evertonfc

15 Sep 2003, 20:05

Not a great deal.

He's over 28, and that's too old for me to offer anything substantial.

Great ruckman playing good football, but you'd be asking a lot more than what we'd offer.

Jerome

15 Sep 2003, 20:38

Originally posted by Falchoon
Can we have Matthew Clarke, you certainly couldn't have he and White in the same side.

Give us Barry Brooks and you've got a deal.

Hosko

15 Sep 2003, 21:01

f we are to trade Goodwin it will be more likely for someone like Ottens
ahh yes and i here that we are trading aaron henneman for nathan brown :rolleyes:

bacon buster

15 Sep 2003, 22:09

i'm sure adelaide could really use another ruckman

chiliboy

16 Sep 2003, 00:12

Well all you doubters out there..

I also have heard that one mentioned reound at demon land..

You people seem to forget that Jeff White in full flight is something special, ask John Barnes..

At the moment its looking like if a deal is done, it'll be either white, pick 20 to crows, goodwin, doughty..

OR

white for steinglen and 2nd rnd pick..

These trades have been mentioned on MMM, 3AW, and Fox Footy, plus from a deep source at the MFC..

Stiffy_18

16 Sep 2003, 00:59

Originally posted by chiliboy
Well all you doubters out there..

I also have heard that one mentioned reound at demon land..

You people seem to forget that Jeff White in full flight is something special, ask John Barnes..

At the moment its looking like if a deal is done, it'll be either white, pick 20 to crows, goodwin, doughty..

OR

white for steinglen and 2nd rnd pick..

These trades have been mentioned on MMM, 3AW, and Fox Footy, plus from a deep source at the MFC.. If you say so:rolleyes:

Broadbridge_20

16 Sep 2003, 01:35

Originally posted by chiliboy

At the moment its looking like if a deal is done, it'll be either white, pick 20 to crows, goodwin, doughty..

I hope you're right.

If you could swap Doughty for Bode it would be PERFECT.

CrowBoi

16 Sep 2003, 06:26

personally I hope none of this goes ahead.... if it does, Gary Ayres' should be sacked....

PrideOf

16 Sep 2003, 11:33

Originally posted by chiliboy
white for steinglen and 2nd rnd pick..

You've got the draft pick in the wrong place. The only way this trade would happen is:

White AND 2ND RND PICK for Stenglein

Stiffy_18

16 Sep 2003, 14:41

Originally posted by PrideOf
You've got the draft pick in the wrong place. The only way this trade would happen is:

White AND 2ND RND PICK for Stenglein Don't wory guys chiliboy is another one of those Melbourne supporters who severely overrate their players and underrate the opposition.

Goodwin will not be traded unless its part of the deal to bring Ottens back home. Personally I think the chances of this happening is 1%.

White is an undersized ruckman who has chronic shin injury. Why would you trade a 2 time All Australian midfielder for an undersized ruckman??????

Chiliboy is living in a fantasy land;)

Docker4life

16 Sep 2003, 15:24

How would Jeff White survive in Adelaide? Wouldnt he get homesick?

bluechampion

16 Sep 2003, 15:28

If you end up with Jeff White AND Matthew Clarke, what do you want for Rhett Biglands?

Stiffy_18

16 Sep 2003, 15:30

Originally posted by Docker4life
How would Jeff White survive in Adelaide? Wouldnt he get homesick? Thats exactly right. If white is not at Melbourne next year it will be at anothetr Victorian Club. He left Freo because he was homesick and was offered more money by demons

Stiffy_18

16 Sep 2003, 15:31

Originally posted by bluechampion
If you end up with Jeff White AND Matthew Clarke, what do you want for Rhett Biglands? There is more chance of Matthew Clarke leaving than there is of Rhett Biglands.

Clarke is 30 so he is not far from retirement. Biglands is our number one ruckman ATM;)

We are more likely ot draft a young ruckman or go for Lade from Port Adelaide than we are to go after White;)

Falchoon

16 Sep 2003, 17:51

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
What would you offer the Crows for Matty Clarke? He doesn't take many marks around the ground, but that shouldn't be a problem with all your marking KPP. One of the best tap ruckman & would give Harvey, Hayes & Co. 1st use of the ball.

How about James Begley ;)

Seriously, 2nd rounder, (pick 24)