PDA

View Full Version : Collingwood trade bait


The Clokes
15th September 2003, 16:37
Jarrod Molloy
Mark McGough
Leon Davis
Ben Kinnear
Rupert Betheras
Steven McKee

bacon buster
15th September 2003, 16:40
no thanks
i'd say a few teams would be after molloy though

vicpride99
15th September 2003, 16:40
Jarrod Molloy- would get a 3rd round pick
Mark McGough- maybe a 3rd round pick.
Leon Davis- a solid player, like James McDonald
Ben Kinnear- nothing
Rupert Betheras- nothing
Steven McKee- a draft pick if your lucky.

bacon buster
15th September 2003, 16:43
Originally posted by vicpride99
Jarrod Molloy- would get a 3rd round pick
Mark McGough- maybe a 3rd round pick.
Leon Davis- a solid player, like James McDonald
Ben Kinnear- nothing
Rupert Betheras- nothing
Steven McKee- a draft pick if your lucky.

leon davis solid?
i think he is anything but. capable of the miraculous, but he is playing in collingwood's reserves for a reason

wooshta_9
15th September 2003, 16:45
well have Mark McGough at Freo we'll give you our first rund draft pick 13.

The Clokes
15th September 2003, 16:50
That seems fair "wooshta_9"

Mark is a great player.... its just we have to many players like him: example - Scotland, O'Bree, Licuria and Burns.

pinkus maximus
15th September 2003, 16:52
we wouldnt give a first round pick for mcgough. Maybe 2nd round

Demon37
15th September 2003, 17:10
pick 20 for Mark McGough.
Paul Wheatley for Leon Davis.

The Clokes
15th September 2003, 17:15
that sounds okay that swap "Demon37"

On Paul Whaetley he looks a real athlete who may just have a few rough edges to work on…

I ‘d really like to use him as a running wingman if he came to pie land…

Im surprised youd want to let him go.

Broadbridge_20
15th September 2003, 17:21
Originally posted by The Clokes


Im surprised youd want to let him go.

So am I.

People are forgetting how good he was in 2002. Damaging player who has the most penetrating kick in the competition.

We'd be nuts to get rid of him for a player like Davis.

CammoAU
15th September 2003, 17:36
****.....wouldn't want any of them at Carlton-land.

Maybe Molloy if we traded Whitnall, but the two of them together....well, ****, you have a sausage sizzle at training and you'd have to send World Vision in for the rest of them.

TheMightyDons
15th September 2003, 17:42
Talk about over-rating players. If a player can't crack a team's best 22, then there is no way he is worth a pick below 30.

Jabso
15th September 2003, 17:46
I think you can unfortunatly add Scotland and Lockyer to that list.

Presti_is_god
15th September 2003, 18:09
Jasbo why would we trade Tarks he is a absolute chapion I cannot see 1 reason why we would trade him.

As for Scotland I think he will only go if he says he wants to and i think he has changed his mind about leaving now.

CammoAU
15th September 2003, 18:12
Yeah, I think we might just take Lockyer off your hands. :D

Demon37
15th September 2003, 18:19
Originally posted by jabso
I think you can unfortunatly add Scotland and Lockyer to that list.
Would love to snap up either one.

Watch Scotland become a star at his next club.

hotpie
15th September 2003, 18:28
Originally posted by bacon buster
leon davis solid?
i think he is anything but. capable of the miraculous, but he is playing in collingwood's reserves for a reason

.......and that reason is that the senior side is second on the ladder. He just cant break into the senior 22. Same as half a dozen of his mates who would be walk up starts at 12 other clubs.

hotpie
15th September 2003, 18:30
Originally posted by Demon37
Would love to snap up either one.

Watch Scotland become a star at his next club.

Scotland is staying.

Lockyer might be traded though, although I expect MM would give him a year to prove he can still cut it after his knee.

Presti_is_god
15th September 2003, 18:49
Why are you so down about Tarks he is a champion. We could keep huim for his kick ins alone.

Put it this way who would you rather running around for us? Andrew Williams or Tarkyn Lockyer.