View Full Version : Doughty
Crows fans, what would you want in return from Essendon for Michael Doughty?
Thunderstruck
17 Sep 2003, 12:21
Interesting one that, he is a good player IMO.
Id have to say a tall, most likely someone like Dean Solomon/David Hille or Danny Jacobs.
TheMightyDons
17 Sep 2003, 12:27
HAHA, that's a ****er. While you're at it Thunderstruck take Lloyd and Hird too.
Thunderstruck
17 Sep 2003, 14:05
Originally posted by TheMightyDons
HAHA, that's a ****er. While you're at it Thunderstruck take Lloyd and Hird too.
He is worth one of them not all of them.
As for Hird and Lloyd? Maybe Lloyd but why would we want Hird? Getting towards the end now for him.
Stiffy_18
17 Sep 2003, 14:06
Originally posted by bozza
Crows fans, what would you want in return from Essendon for Michael Doughty? Not sure what your list it like but probably a decent tall.
How is that ruckman going Tristian <something>?????:confused:
Stiffy_18
17 Sep 2003, 14:07
Originally posted by Thunderstruck
Interesting one that, he is a good player IMO.
Id have to say a tall, most likely someone like Dean Solomon/David Hille or Danny Jacobs. You defunetly overrate Doughty or underrate the ones you mentioned;)
Thunderstruck
17 Sep 2003, 14:10
I rate Doughty ahead of Ladhams, Begley, Gallagher, Nelson, Shirley and Skipworth
Jacobs has been pretty bad this year, his effort on tredrea who had a bit of the flu was terrible.
Stiffy_18
17 Sep 2003, 14:16
Originally posted by Thunderstruck
I rate Doughty ahead of Ladhams, Begley You're kidding???????:confused:
Thunderstruck
17 Sep 2003, 14:27
Certainly not
Doughty for Bolton, thats pretty fair if you ask me.
There is no way Jacobs, Soloman or Hille would be traded for him, they are way better players, Jacobs has had a good year by the way, obviously the match against Port Adelaide is still fresh in your mind where he had a bad game.
Thunderstruck
17 Sep 2003, 15:14
I guess...
But Bolton is the type of player u think u guys would want to keep more than say Jacobs for example. He seems to have more strings to his bow so to speak. Still Bolton for Doughty, yep sounds fine.
Jars458
17 Sep 2003, 17:27
How about Doughty and our second round pick for Solomon?
I would be happier to trade Doughty to a team that give us a youngish ruckman in return
dougthelegend
17 Sep 2003, 17:47
Originally posted by Jars458
How about Doughty and our second round pick for Solomon?
I would be happier to trade Doughty to a team that give us a youngish ruckman in return
not for solomon, he's very much a required player.
Kane McGoodwin
17 Sep 2003, 19:34
Originally posted by rama_9
Doughty for Bolton, thats pretty fair if you ask me.
Sound fair to me too.
year of the roo
17 Sep 2003, 20:01
how about doughty to the kangaroos for s.motlop and a draft pick in the later rounds?? both are very good talented players that are struggling to get a game at there current clubs. would be a win-win for both clubs imo.
Kane McGoodwin
17 Sep 2003, 20:06
Originally posted by year of the roo
how about doughty to the kangaroos for s.motlop and a draft pick in the later rounds?? both are very good talented players that are struggling to get a game at there current clubs. would be a win-win for both clubs imo.
Sounds reasonable to me, but would prefer Bolton from Essendon.
Stiffy_18
17 Sep 2003, 21:09
Originally posted by rama_9
Doughty for Bolton, thats pretty fair if you ask me.Originally posted by year of the roo
how about doughty to the kangaroos for s.motlop and a draft pick in the later rounds?? both are very good talented players that are struggling to get a game at there current clubs. would be a win-win for both clubs imo.
Finally 2 decent trades. i agree with Kane McGoodwin, Bolton is adressing our needs more than Motlop
Finally 2 decent trades. i agree with Kane McGoodwin, Bolton is adressing our needs more than Motlop
we have no use for a fringe player like Doughty, the roos can have him!
panthers
17 Sep 2003, 23:31
Are you crow ppl for real Doughty stuggles to keep his place at South let alone trade him for some real players in Soloman and Bolton Get ya hand of it:D :D :D
Kane McGoodwin
18 Sep 2003, 09:49
Originally posted by panthers
Are you crow ppl for real Doughty stuggles to keep his place at South let alone trade him for some real players in Soloman and Bolton Get ya hand of it:D :D :D
Doughty played consistent footy for South - you just don't want to lose him! ;) I was just asked by Dons / Roos supporters whether I would accept the Bolton / S Motlop trades & confirmed that I would - wouldn't you, or do you have your hand on it...:p