Box Hill v Collingwood Sat 2 July @Box Hill 1.10pm [Archive]

View Full Version : Box Hill v Collingwood Sat 2 July @Box Hill 1.10pm

rdhopkins2

26 Jun 2011, 15:10

ROUND 14

http://www.boxhillhawks.com.au/photos/fixtures/bhh-vs-collingwood.gif

Seniors
Saturday 2nd July
Box Hill City Oval
1:10pm
(note early start for TV)

http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTy4qCbneptEvDn4yutCu-Ce72DZHksSBdCyIgukynBNsRZQLTRRA
or www.3wbc.org.au (http://www.3wbc.org.au)

http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQPHjEGhp_sLYX1c6rRDatcPrDReXFqMN1JhOrEqwx NzFCzmAqo

Teams TBC

Here we are again and looking forward to the Box Hill/Hawthorn double banger against the Magpies. I hear your excitement already!! Pumped?? PUMPED??? PUUUUUMPPPPEEDDDD???

Make sure you record the game to watch when you get home again on TV and listen to the broadcast through 3WBC at the ground.

Development Team vs Frankston
Sunday 3rd July
Box Hill City Oval
11:00am

Notsoyabby

27 Jun 2011, 19:19

With the injuries to the Hawthorn players and the "pending" suspension to Lewis it will be interesting to see how our Team looks on Thursday night. Hopefully one or two Hawthorn and Box Hill players back and a chance to reward some of the Development squad players for their good form so far this year.

Personally I would like to see Dylan Van Unen get another game.

Would love to see Aaron Johns and Robert Allen get a game if positions open up on the half back line (but doubt it will happen).

Any thoughts or favorite players you would like to see?

Rudi Gilham

27 Jun 2011, 19:36

Liam Tobin & Ben Monkhorst!

BuddyHawkers

27 Jun 2011, 22:06

Is Dylan Van Unen on our list of players?

I like to see is Mitch Hallahan, Wanganeen and Will Sierakowski

FriarTuck

27 Jun 2011, 22:11

Would be nice for K4 to get a run.

its game on

27 Jun 2011, 22:55

Would be nice for K4 to get a run.

Even better if L2 gets another run.

MF_Hawks

28 Jun 2011, 09:31

i am looking forward to watching langers play his second game for the box hill hawks. it will be interesting to see if he can consistantly string together games where he is in the best.

TheFourPillars

28 Jun 2011, 12:49

Count me in see you guys down there

The Convert

30 Jun 2011, 14:15

Strikes me as a game we really must win or we slip further down the table. Time for the boys to say that injuries are there but they do not matter as we are going to win

go hawks!!!

30 Jun 2011, 19:46

Box Hill team.

Note, this is a 1.10pm game televised on ABC.

Welcome back and good luck to X Ellis. We need a strong performance from him in the next 2 weeks to push for selection in the seniors.

Strange that Laddo is not playing given he trained this week.

Langford is not playing as he is injured.

Pay attention to Menegola this rookie will be a star as well as Wanga.

Like to see Milne show something this week to add to our depth.

Given Sundays game, I assume Lowden will be held back with Sirra.

Box Hill Hawks vs. Collingwood (ABC TV)
Saturday 2nd July
Box Hill City Oval at 1:10 PM
Box Hill Hawks
B
Mirra
Pollard
Duryea
HB
S. Gibson
Cheney
Puopolo
C
Morton
Sierakowski
Milne
HF
Wanganeen
Pattison
Bateman
F
Schneider
Williams
Menegola
R
Lowden
Young
X. Ellis
Int
Gilchrist
Andrews
Van Unen

Nye
Tobin
Jackson

Monkhorst*
Boumann
Kiel

Neil
Kitchin
Fagan

Northe

go hawks!!!

30 Jun 2011, 19:49

Development squad

Box Hill Hawks vs. Frankston (Reserve Grade)
Sunday 3rd July
Box Hill City Oval at 11:00 AM
Box Hill Hawks
B
Phelps
Kennedy
Thompson
HB
Purcell
Johns
Allen
C
Nye
Hallahan
Jackson
HF
Cust
Tobin
Hoegel
F
Cass
Van Unen
X. Murphy
R
Ralph
Kitchin
Mahony
Int
Fagan
D. Cooper
A. Ellis

Cunningham
Cassidy
R. Wilson

Iliov
Carroll
Sketcher

Kickett
Wilsen
Cooper

Halahan is the only HFC listed player which is an indication of our injuries. Surprised he is not playing seniors, this kid trained strongly during the week, and should excel in the development squad.

moginie

30 Jun 2011, 21:07

Guys, can anyone tell me how Thomas Kickett has been going in the Dev Squad? As a scholarship listed player, is he playing well enough to be upgraded to the rookie list next year?

SS JP

1 Jul 2011, 10:19

Development squad

Halahan is the only HFC listed player which is an indication of our injuries. Surprised he is not playing seniors, this kid trained strongly during the week, and should excel in the development squad.

Mahony in the followers' line is the same one that's our rookie yeah? How has he been going this year?

Rudi Gilham

2 Jul 2011, 09:19

Today's team may look something like this, now that the senior team has been finalised.

B Duryea Pollard Mirra
HB Sierakowski Boumann Gilchrist
C Milne Ellis Williams
HF Wanganeen Pattison Jackson
F Morton Menegola Andrews
R Lowden
RR Gibson

R Schneider
IC Kiel, Van Unen, Tobin, Monkhorst, Neil, Kitchen, B Fagan, Northe

Just a rough guide. I think the "Monkhorst" named isn't Box Hill's Ben, but his younger brother Zach?

Not a strong side, and Collingwood will have the likes of Goldsack,
Ben Johnson, MacAffer & Buckley running around, but at the City Oval, we should have an advantage.

FriarTuck

2 Jul 2011, 09:56

Mahony in the followers' line is the same one that's our rookie yeah? How has he been going this year?

Mahony is short and stocky. Pretty much your standard run of the mill VFL player. Have not seen a great deal of him but with his physical attributes he will need to be extraordinary.

go hawks!!!

2 Jul 2011, 10:38

Mahony is short and stocky. Pretty much your standard run of the mill VFL player. Have not seen a great deal of him but with his physical attributes he will need to be extraordinary.

FT & SS (actually better add JP to that:D)

Mahony is playing sorry.

He like langers, is a NSW Rookie chosen over T Stubbs.

He is 18, and has an AFL body. Terrific physique. With that, you can compare his body to mitchell. Like Mitch he is slow.

He most likely will be starting of HBF, so needs to show elite kicking skills and footy brains to excel to AFL level.

Watch for Halahan as well, playing for dev squad. This kid will be a star.

Baz_hawk

2 Jul 2011, 13:25

Sierakowski not playing? Haven't seen him out there.

Perhaps we are expecting a late change.

Like Lowden, he will be a great player in the future. Needs to put on some muscle but otherwise a very good, versatile player

shepp

2 Jul 2011, 13:25

Coll kick their first and lead 1.2 to BH 0.2

Who is number 1 for BH? I hope Hawthorn consider recruiting him. Tall, speedy defender with clean hands and good disposal.

Baz_hawk

2 Jul 2011, 13:39

Poor use of the ball from our boys thus far

Baz_hawk

2 Jul 2011, 13:52

3 minutes in 2nd term,

BHH- 1. 6 (12)
COLL- 3. 3 (21)

go hawks!!!

2 Jul 2011, 14:13

Hello my name is Derick WANAGANEEN, going to be a star

SSSSSS

2 Jul 2011, 14:27

Loved Mortons goal

Rudi Gilham

2 Jul 2011, 14:32

Coll kick their first and lead 1.2 to BH 0.2

Who is number 1 for BH? I hope Hawthorn consider recruiting him. Tall, speedy defender with clean hands and good disposal.

Jarrad Boumann, the former Doggies listed player.

I hope to see more from Menegola, Schneider & Lowden in the second half.

petershi1234567

2 Jul 2011, 14:32

Hello my name is Derick WANAGANEEN, going to be a star

Made Stubbs look ordinary......great balance and read of the footy

Schneider is hard at at - puts the body on he line

Lowden looks a great prospect

Good to see Ellis and Morton getting some touches

Henry Jr

2 Jul 2011, 14:41

Hello my name is Derick WANAGANEEN, going to be a star

Hi there Derick

go hawks!!!

2 Jul 2011, 14:52

Hi there Derick

Tell us what is on your mind henry? Actually you spelled it out above:D:D

Baz_hawk

2 Jul 2011, 15:18

Have the wind in the last, should win based on how the game has been played. Wind is having a big impact

Henry Jr

2 Jul 2011, 15:41

Thought Big X might have smiled when he was on TV :eek:

Milestone

2 Jul 2011, 15:45

Lowden!!

Henry Jr

2 Jul 2011, 15:45

Thought Big X might have smiled when he was on TV :eek:

Bet he's smiling now...

Go Stangers!

Pessimistic

2 Jul 2011, 15:47

X and Lowden have burned the party pies

LuvMyHawks

2 Jul 2011, 15:52

Bet he's smiling now...

Go Stangers!

What great win, the Lowden mark and goal,the last one he kicked was fantastic..X kicked another winner to get us there as winners.. Wanganeen played well too in the first couple of qtrs..Well done boys!!:D

bebe89gf

2 Jul 2011, 15:59

lowden looked pretty good

BuddyHawkers

2 Jul 2011, 16:21

What was the score and the goal kickers? thanks

LuvMyHawks

2 Jul 2011, 16:46

[quote=BuddyHawkers;21504665]What was the score and the goal kickers? thanks[/quote

I can't remember the full score, but I do know we were 73 pts, to 69 pts at the final siren...
Thank goodness for Lowden in the last 3 to 4 mins..:)

nuclearman

2 Jul 2011, 16:59

Great win by the Hawks -- just got home from the match

Of the Hawthorn listed ...

Ellis if he pulls up well should be an inclusion for the seniors next week against the Lions -- won the game there at the end.

Best game I have seen from Morton in a loooong time. Should be considered - good games from Duryea, Wanganeen and Milne (in that order)

Great to beat the magpies !!!!!!

GO HAWKS

The BIG X

2 Jul 2011, 17:23

Thought Big X might have smiled when he was on TV :eek:

Received 8 texts saying the same thing - only smile at the end IF WE WIN

Remember its only a game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:eek:

mark1234

2 Jul 2011, 17:38

I am not a Morton fan, but he did some really good things including a goal from 70 Metres out, i was impressed, he has some talent thats why we have kept him all these years,

Wangas did some good things but needs to get stronger, and as others have said Lowden looks a player,

Hodgepodge

2 Jul 2011, 17:47

Pretty excited by Lowden, particularly his skills for a big man. Decent tap ruckman, and also can take a mark , but his agility and disposal is great to watch for a 206cm ruckman.

Goldhawk

2 Jul 2011, 17:53

Mmmmm an undermanned Box Hill Hawks side beats Collingwood reserves.

And tomorrow an undermanned Hawthorn side takes on Collingwood,this could get interesting. :D

Great win by a very undermanned Box Hill side. :thumbsu:

Hodgepodge

2 Jul 2011, 17:56

Ellis looked like he would fit into the seniors pretty well.

The Convert

2 Jul 2011, 18:00

Not having a go at the system of development but having blokes that have played a few games and train together can make a huge difference. The DS shows this week in and week out. Love to see the win and hopefully 2 more wins will follow tomorrow (and one tonight)

Buddyman

2 Jul 2011, 19:11

Really impressed with Luke Lowden today, his first 5 minutes he was in absolutely everything. I think as the match went on his fitness tarted to show as he had less of an influence. But then again he kicked the winner :)

Wanga showed a bit, but I think with the role he plays he has to be near perfect with the ball, kicking accurately nearly every chance he gets. I'm referring to his early miss, which was really poor. With players that are of short stature they have to have some brilliant facet in their game to be selected for the big smoke. I don't think he is that pacy and nor a brilliant user. Obviously has a big leap, shown by a couple of spectacular grabs. I seem rather negative on him but all in all he played quite well, definetely in our top 5 imo. Also we have to recognize that if he does get an opportunity with the hawkers sometime in the future (2012 maybe...), he will not be given chances to really take the big marks like he did today. I think the pies blocking was poor and against a top team theres no chance a player like Wanga will be given an open crack at the footy. Anyway I was quite pleased with his display and hopefully he continues to develop, he already has quite a bit this season from what I can gather.

Duryea, was very good in my opinion. Really happy with the way he set up the play and he has a very long kick on him. A massive shame that he isn't that few centimetres taller, as he then would have been coming into senior calculations from my reckoning. Thought he was quite good defensively and offensively and I think he is a similar player to a Ladson of '08 :) Heres hoping anyway!!!

I was also very impressed with Jarryd Morton. He tooked quite a few very solid grabs and showed enough to me to suggest he is closing in on selection. Kicked poorly on a few occasions but overall was great. 70 metre goal was amazing (wind assisted of course), and I think when the going got tough he rised to a new level. If we cop another injury, god forbid, I will not be unhappy with this man coming into the team and givinga solid contest.

X man played a solid, 24 possesion game (think it was 24 may have been more). Brilliant kick to Lowden to set up the win and was an obvious leader in the huddles through every quarter. Showed a lot of class as the game wore on, and I think form a senior point of view give him another week or two, and then he will no doubt be ready for a big second half and finals series to come from this man. He played a half back role, in which he showed composure and for once in his time did not look injured, nor did he get a facial injury of some sort. Really pleased with his game and fingers crossed he pulls up well.

Sierakowski did not play due to him being an emergency for tomoz. Umm not too sure if or who I left out but hopefully you guys will enjoy that review.

Good win by the boys and it's good to see that we still have youngsters continue to come out and push for selection. I'm a happy hawker, but now for the big one tomorrow!

Mr Cyril Rioli

2 Jul 2011, 19:35

Really impressed with Luke Lowden today, his first 5 minutes he was in absolutely everything. I think as the match went on his fitness tarted to show as he had less of an influence. But then again he kicked the winner :)

X man played a solid, 24 possesion game (think it was 24 may have been more). Brilliant kick to Lowden to set up the win and was an obvious leader in the huddles through every quarter.

Lowden not required now but it was great to see we have a solid contributor as a back-up.

Watched Ellis closely (I was at the match)- he spent half the match on the bench. His impact considering his few minutes was super impressive! Looking forward to watching him in the ones very soon

BlackByrd

2 Jul 2011, 19:37

Good job mate! Cheers

TheFourPillars

2 Jul 2011, 19:51

I wont' bother with the write up given the game was on tv but some observations:

Hawthorn Listed

Xavier Ellis: He was only supposed to play half a game today apparently but due to his competitive nature played out the whole game. Was used sparingly in the first half so that he could run out the game. He showed his class in the last few minutes of the game. Really important going forward that Ellis is able to get fit and hungry.

Jarryd Morton: Gradually getting some football games into him after missing the season so far. He is building his fitness base took a very important contested mark in the last also played all over the ground.

Riley Milne: Played his best game for Box hill this week. I thought he really put in today. Yes he made some mistakes dropped marks, skill errors but couldn't doubt his hunger for the contest need a few more games like this Riley keep it up.

Tom Schneider: A player of the future had a good game today needs another pre season. Gets the ball shows great footy nouse turns it over now and then but that is to be expected. Look forward to his development and fitness over the rest of this year.

Derick Wanganeen: Had 5 minutes at the end of that 2nd quarter where he was irresistible. Good forward pressure but still needs some time to develop some fitness.

Luke Lowden: Well the hero what can u say Stephen Gilham ( who Lukey boards with) actually didn't believe he could kick it and now owes young Lowden a sloppy kiss (i dare say lukey won't hold him to it). Took some good marks in the forward line and around the ground still learning the caper will be a star in the ruck in the future. I hope he gets a taste of the big league this year perhaps round 24?

Taylor Duryea: Had a good game i thought was great across half back in providing a contest and run from the half back flank.

Jordan Williams: Got in it today but struggled to impose himself into the contest.

Sam Menegola: Needs to play a few more games to get himself up with the game plan and speed of the game at box hill level. He has elite fitness so will just be about him being able to hit the contest.

Box Hill Listed:

Sam Gibson: Great game again by the captain. Would most definitely be leading the B&F

David Mirra: This kid needs to be hawthorn listed next year. I think he is a natural defender. Played another great game in defence. Really missed him againts Bendigo two weeks ago.

Jarrad Boumann: Great game in defence from him today took some great contested marks and provided run from the backline.

other mentions Pattison, Andrews and Gilchrist the latter kicked a 80 metre bomb through for a point in that last quarter. All in all a thrilling last quarter.

Rudi Gilham

2 Jul 2011, 19:57

There's something about Boumann. Quick blokes who stand 196cm don't grow on trees. I'd be very surprised if he isn't on an AFL list next season, hopefully with us.

savagelunchbox

2 Jul 2011, 20:17

We saw the good BH and the bad BH today. Fortunately there was enough good BH to get us the win.

Was impressed by Morton and Ellis as pretty much the only 2 Hawthorn experienced players playing.

Like the looks of Wanganeen and Schnieder. Get their fitness up and there's the future of Hawthorn.

Menegola showed some real smarts today. Smart disposal and good positioning around the ground.

Mirra = Ben Stratton of 2012?

buddy marvellous

2 Jul 2011, 23:11

There's something about Boumann. Quick blokes who stand 196cm don't grow on trees. I'd be very surprised if he isn't on an AFL list next season, hopefully with us.
Yep, totally agree. Just needs to work out how to bounce the ball when running! Played a good game, certainly impressed David Rhys-Jones on the T.V

Collins-Langford-Ayres

3 Jul 2011, 09:38

Interested to know how Stubbs went for the Pies?

go hawks!!!

3 Jul 2011, 10:20

Jarrad Boumann: Great game in defence from him today took some great contested marks and provided run from the backline.

.

Thanks TFP as usual.

The guy is bold above, should be training in our gym right now. He will definately be picked up by the HFC next year. Hopefully taking Morton's/ Bruce place.:thumbsu:

Old Bullman

3 Jul 2011, 10:56

Often very hard to guage how players are going at the lower level, especially up forward. Menagola didnt smash it possession wise but had time when he got the ball. It is a trait you cant teach. When he starts to use his big engine, he will be very good.

FairCall

3 Jul 2011, 11:43

Yeh I think Menagola is coming along nicely for his first year. Nothing flashy so not noticed as much as others but has skill and takes a good mark. The Bombers game he started slowly but actually went against the trend and improved as the game went on for his first senior game.

satan1

3 Jul 2011, 12:25

Menagola will be a jet if he hasnt lost anything from last year. Has great hands, skills and nous. Obviously will need some time given how much football he has missed this year.

FriarTuck

3 Jul 2011, 12:30

BlackByrd

3 Jul 2011, 17:25

Best game from Morton in a long time. He was moving far more freely than he has been. His attack on the game was first rate. Same for XL. Will be back in the ones sooner rather than later.

Not sold on Lowden's ruck work. He was pushed off the ball way too easily. I was hoping to see more improvement.

What is wrong with Menegola? Nice hands, great balance, good vision and good skills. Seems pretty solid to me. Looks like the proto type HFF.

Yep Morton was good day. Best game for the year by a mile.

Ellis was good, looks to be over his injuey.

I wouldn't be too worried with Lowden's ruckwork.. He's effectivly only a second year player and is still pretty raw. Once he gains muscle he'll be better in the ruck.

Thought Riley Milne was outstanding. Finished with something like 38 possessions. Great game, best on by a mile.

jonesy86

3 Jul 2011, 18:27

Interested to know how Stubbs went for the Pies?

Pretty quiet, did one or two handy things but will take some time to get up to speed as it was his first game for about 6-8weeks after injuring his ankle.

BuddyHawkers

3 Jul 2011, 20:02

Splodge15

3 Jul 2011, 21:49

Roby

3 Jul 2011, 22:29

If the club doesn't draft Boumann, I'll be quite disappointed. Particularly after picking some other blokes ahead of players like Ed Curnow, Cam Pedersen and Luke Markovic. The club seems to have a reluctance to draft Box Hill blokes based on a few past failures, which they need to get over.

I'm not that keen on Boumann just yet. He has had one or two good games, had 7 goals kicked on him at Williamstown. Plus there are several better tall KPD in the VFL, and one played for Collingwood yesterday.

Mirra is the one WE HAVE TO put on the list, or someone else for sure will.

The Convert

4 Jul 2011, 08:35

Our Development Team played very well

Box Hill Hawks
Goal Kickers: L. Kitchin 4, J. Cass 4, D. Cooper 4, R. JACKSON 3, J. Sketcher 3, K. Nye 2, T. Kickett 2, B. Kennedy 2, A. Ellis 2, R. Wilson 2, M. Thompson 2, S. Cust , A. Fagan , R. Allen , M. Hallahan , T. Purcell
Best Players: L. Kitchin, R. JACKSON, R. Allen, R. Wilson, D. Cooper, X. Murphy
Frankston
Goal Kickers: J. Greeley 2, A. Simpson 2, C. Bywater , B. Crowe
Best Players: R. Jaroszczuk, J. Cole, N. Bateman, J. Greeley, J. Anwyl

Boxhill Hawks Final score 236 points to Frankston 41 :eek:

Tough season for Frankston boys. On the other hand a few of our youngsters are taking the opportunity to have a real go. Post injuries when the others come back the coach is going to have some tough decisions to make in the reserves based on results.

its game on

4 Jul 2011, 16:29

I was at the game and came back and watched the ABC broadcast on a home recording.

Gee I was impressed with Sam Gibson who had a microphone stuck under his nose with his team down by 3 with 5 minutes to go and was very composed and measured. Following a nailbiting win the microphone was there again and he conducted himself so professionally, talking about AFL/VFL alignments etc, he's a credit to himself and Box Hill.

I think his AFL time has probably passed by, but Box Hill officials should everything to keep this bloke at the club.

Hawksfor11in11

4 Jul 2011, 16:46

Loved Boumans game. hope we draft him next year

Rudi Gilham

4 Jul 2011, 16:53

Loved Boumans game. hope we draft him next year

The combination of height and pace, alone, and the dearth of defensive talls in the AFL, should see him a monty to be at least Rookie listed.

Casey's Tim Mohr and Sandy's Sean Tighe are likely tall defenders to come under scrutiny this year.

stemline

4 Jul 2011, 18:47

Lowden not in the goalkickers? Which one is wrong?

10.13 73 d. 10.9 69

Box Hill Hawks

Goal Kickers: D. WANGANEEN 2, L. Tobin , B. Monkhorst , J. Morton , A. Pattison , S. Gibson , X. Ellis , B. Fagan , T. Gilchrist
Best Players: R. Milne, B. Neil, X. Ellis, T. Duryea, S. Gibson, A. Pattison

Roger Rogerson

4 Jul 2011, 19:01

The combination of height and pace, alone, and the dearth of defensive talls in the AFL, should see him a monty to be at least Rookie listed.

Casey's Tim Mohr and Sandy's Sean Tighe are likely tall defenders to come under scrutiny this year.

I tend to agree that he is rookie material rather than the main list.

Couple of occasions when he was put under pressure on the weekend he went to water without any composure at all. He doesn't seem like a reliable backman to me but that observation is from 1 game only and from a TV viewing rather than live. I can see the the height and pace attraction but looked a bit all over the shop for mine.

Mirra on the other hand...

Rudi Gilham

4 Jul 2011, 19:50

Yes, I don't mind David Mirra. Looks a likely half back flanker. Good mark, steady disposal.

He and Puopolo could bring a touch of Italia to our defence!

arupist

7 Jul 2011, 11:30

A question to anyone who watch the game -

Stubbs - are we missing out on something here? Or are we happy for him to be on the Pies list and not ours?

TheFourPillars

7 Jul 2011, 12:36

A question to anyone who watch the game -

Stubbs - are we missing out on something here? Or are we happy for him to be on the Pies list and not ours?

Hard to say from that game because it was his first back from injury. Lacks a bit of leg speed but again could be fitness related because it his first game back

savagelunchbox

7 Jul 2011, 15:55

Mirra is the one to keep an eye on come draft time. Boumann has been a rookie before and it didn't work probably for the same reasons Roger noted.

Boumann is too skinny too. Mirra is more AFL ready body wise but he'll still need to bulk up a bit more. Mirra also has age working on his size.
Mirra - 21 in 2012
Boumann - 23 in 2012.