View Full Version : Assuming...
Babylove
24 Sep 2003, 01:00
Okay assuming that Anthony Rocca's appeal is unsuccessful (which unfortunately I think will be the case), who do you think would be the replacement for him?
Walker. (And Rupe for Leon IMO)
Oh Furious One
24 Sep 2003, 01:28
David King.
Dejavu I think this has been done but here goes McKee or Walker
Lockyer24
24 Sep 2003, 11:36
Leaning towards Molloy now.
guess_who
24 Sep 2003, 15:45
MM will pull of a selection surprise and will make one change for a small, IE. Betharas, King or Freeborn
If Fraser hapens to get injured then A we are screwed B BK will do the ruck
guess_who
24 Sep 2003, 15:46
Originally posted by Lockyer24
Leaning towards Molloy now.
It can't be Molloy who will do the ruck to help out Fraser, unless we make a second change...
grayham
24 Sep 2003, 16:11
Originally posted by guess_who
It can't be Molloy who will do the ruck to help out Fraser, unless we make a second change...
Couldnt Fraser potentially ruck all day. Keating did it in last years grand final. Goodes did it for the Syd v Port final.
It puts all your eggs in one basket, but means you dont have to play a rookie or Stunning, which is almost admitting defeat.
Originally posted by grayham
Couldnt Fraser potentially ruck all day. Keating did it in last years grand final. Goodes did it for the Syd v Port final.
It puts all your eggs in one basket, but means you dont have to play a rookie or Stunning, which is almost admitting defeat.
Unbelievable!!! A decent post by Grayham that is not slagging Collingwood. Well done.
I think that Walker will come in, so too will Mckee but, Mckee will ruck around the ground allowing Fraser to play CHF. Walker will start at CHF before moving into a pocket. If walker does not come in, Rupe will and he'll play as the CHF. Good grab, quick, and a good kick. Be surprising who mans him up as usually one of the Scotts get him and he's beaten them each time. Chris Johson will play on our small forward, Didak / Lokan.
brentoncowell
24 Sep 2003, 16:37
It was obvious that Malthouse was trying BK in the ruck and its obvious that it was successful. He is the second ruck, and thats why i believe Molly will come in and Ben to line up at CHF. We might play Cloke at CHF to stop Leppitsch from running forward and to add height to the attack.
Magpira
24 Sep 2003, 19:13
Has to be McKee. We need Ruck back up for Josh and I don't think Kinnear or Walker are good enough.
Or maybe Josh will take the bounces and go forward and Kinnear will run with the Lions Rucks?
Babylove
24 Sep 2003, 22:06
Don't forget that Molloy sometimes does the forward rucking. The biggest question about him would be his fitness.
Piebot 3k
24 Sep 2003, 22:11
Fraser to take the centre bounces, and CHF, rucking as needed in the forward 50, with help from probably Kinnear, or Walker. Also Tarrants virtually a CHF anyway by the time he runs out and marks.
McKee to handle ruck in the back half.
Walker. Fraser first ruck, with Kinnear and Walker rotating in the forward line and ruck.
sebastien
24 Sep 2003, 22:46
Now Rocca is out unless Ed takes it to court, I am leaning towards McKee
IMO he can also be a target up forward, his kicking isnt bad