how bout this

[The Clokes]

TRADE ONE

Collingwood get - Nick Stevens + Luke Livingston

Carlton get - Simon Prestigiacomo and Heath Scotland

Port Adelaide get - Carlton's 1st round pick and Collingwood 1st round pick



TRADE TWO

Collingwood get - Chris Lamb

Melbourne get - Mark McGough

[chiliboy]

Im hoping the 1st one is a joke..

The second is good though, makes sense..

[The Clokes]

whats wrong with the first one?

[TD]

Collingwood supporters need to realise that you actually need to give up some quality to get quality. Do you honestly think Stevens is the equal of Scotland?

[The Clokes]

in my trade collingwood is giving up Presti and our first round pick as well.


presti is a great full back which carlton need

[Lloydy!]

Originally posted by TD
Collingwood supporters need to realise that you actually need to give up some quality to get quality. Do you honestly think Stevens is the equal of Scotland?

couldnt agree more

[godees]

I'd definately do the second one.

[SMOO]

So you are telling me for our 2nd pick AND Livingston WE get Prsti and Scotland.Umm.... really rate these two do you.. did u think long and hard about this... you have got to be kidding....

[Hawk in waiting]

Originally posted by The Clokes
TRADE ONE

Collingwood get - Nick Stevens + Luke Livingston

Carlton get - Simon Prestigiacomo and Heath Scotland

Port Adelaide get - Carlton's 1st round pick and Collingwood 1st round pick



TRADE TWO

Collingwood get - Chris Lamb

Melbourne get - Mark McGough

Carlton don't have a 1st round pick. They have a priority pick because they were crap this year.

I think you will see Pagan simply delist some players and try redraft experienced players later in the draft, as he used to do at North. They surely won't give up pick 2 in the draft for anything but a marquee player, e.g. Nick Stevens and another player.

[Ausgard]

Originally posted by Hawk in waiting
Carlton don't have a 1st round pick. They have a priority pick because they were crap this year.

thats a bit nit picky


Originally posted by Hawk in waiting

I think you will see Pagan simply delist some players and try redraft experienced players later in the draft, as he used to do at North.

I think he only did it once with Martyn (but you are probably right)


Originally posted by Hawk in waiting
They surely won't give up pick 2 in the draft for anything but a marquee player, e.g. Nick Stevens and another player.

Pick 2 will be Nathan Brown, Nick Stevens, or the top Victorian kid in the draft. Pagan has a pretty big say in what happens over their and he is not a moron

[jivey]

carlton getting hammered there

[scooter600x]

Originally posted by The Clokes
TRADE ONE

Carlton get -

Screwed big time

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by The Clokes
TRADE TWO

Collingwood get - Chris Lamb

Melbourne get - Mark McGough

I like Lamb but if we could get McGough in return I wouldn't complain.