PDA

View Full Version : Kane Tenace vs Colin Sylvia

Demon37
4 Oct 2003, 00:48
Just (yet) another question for the Draft experts on here!

Who is the better long term prospect out of Tenace and Sylvia? Obviously they are different players, but who do you think should be taken at 2?

I'm pretty sure we will take whichever one Carlton doesn't pick.
Yze_Magic
4 Oct 2003, 02:10
I HOPE THEY TAKE TENACE


I DEFINITELY WANT SYLVIA
DaveW
4 Oct 2003, 04:40
Originally posted by Demon37
I'm pretty sure we will take whichever one Carlton doesn't pick. So Bradley will fall in the Bulldogs' lap?
OldSchool
4 Oct 2003, 07:23
Originally posted by DaveW
So Bradley will fall in the Bulldogs' lap?
That is the plan :)
OldSchool
4 Oct 2003, 07:29
Originally posted by Demon37
Just (yet) another question for the Draft experts on here!

Who is the better long term prospect out of Tenace and Sylvia? Obviously they are different players, but who do you think should be taken at 2?

I'm pretty sure we will take whichever one Carlton doesn't pick.
Both are very good prospects and whilst Tenace did not finish the season off well he never the less played some excellent games throughout the season.
Tenace is very quick and a hard working midfielder and is a very efficient kick whilst Sylvia is more versatile whith a strong mark and an accurate kick plus is a very physical player.
I think you should go for Sylvia but I dont think you would be disappointed either way. Tenace may even slip down the rankings and you may get the chance to draft him at #5.
Hosko
4 Oct 2003, 18:01
i would take Sylvia. Seems to have more facets to his game especially with his goal kicking ability.
|D_J^B_J|
4 Oct 2003, 18:10
The Blues and Demons will be making a big mistake if they overlook Bradley.
Demon37
4 Oct 2003, 18:31
Originally posted by |D_J^B_J|
The Blues and Demons will be making a big mistake if they overlook Bradley.
I would love Bradley, but Sylvia sounds awesome.

"The closest player we've seen to Michael Voss in the last 10 years."

If it is a choice between him and Tenace, I'd probably take CS.

Thanks for the info everyone.

:cool:
CowboyFromHell
4 Oct 2003, 19:09
Originally posted by |D_J^B_J|
The Blues and Demons will be making a big mistake if they overlook Bradley.

But then you could say that about Sylvia, Tenace etc. It's that sort of draft. Someone will always slip through your grasp.
superstar
4 Oct 2003, 20:20
Originally posted by Demon37

"The closest player we've seen to Michael Voss in the last 10 years."


Watch more footy.