View Full Version : how bout this trade
The Clokes
4 Oct 2003, 17:26
Essendon – Heath Scotland and Trent Croad
Collingwood – Nick Stevens
Port Adelaide – Danny Jacobs, Collingwood’s first round pick
Fremantle – Mark McGough and Corey McGrath
port get ripped, i think dons would rather just do a straight first rnd pick + jacobs for stevens
Massively inbalanced in favour of Port IMO. Stevens is good, but not worth 2 first round picks and a more than handy player.
And even though Croad is starting to be exposed as a limited, over-rated player, not sure that the 2 players Freo get in this proposal would make up for him.
You've edited the original proposal to now reflect only 1 first round pick to Port.
A little more even.
The Clokes
4 Oct 2003, 17:44
i give up... trading is too hard... :)
Originally posted by Carlos
You've edited the original proposal to now reflect only 1 first round pick to Port.
A little more even.
Except now we get Jacobs and pick 18 or so for our no.1 midfielder ;)
Essendon would offer better than that on their own.
The simple solution is to leave Jacobs out of it.
Dane Swan Fan
4 Oct 2003, 19:05
Originally posted by Lloydy!
port get ripped, i think dons would rather just do a straight first rnd pick + jacobs for stevens
Well dude Port need something. Stevens quit. They might end up with nothing.
wooshta_9
4 Oct 2003, 21:44
I like it we would love to get our hands on McGough and McGrath would rather Ash mcGrath but cory will do.
Originally posted by Dane Swan Fan
They might end up with nothing.
In which case Collingwood will also end up with nothing